Beowulf and Siegfried

1472 Words3 Pages

The only similarity between Beowulf and Siegfried is the letter e—that is until you actually start reading the stories. Within the early moments of Beowulf and the Nibelungenlied significant amounts of correlations steadfastly intertwined a web of parallelism between the two heroic characters. Both glory-seeking and nigh invincible warriors from noble origins, the two warriors blasted through adversities in pursuit of their ultimate goals. While both eventually fulfilled their desires, Siegfried’s satisfaction was cut short by an untimely death. Although Beowulf also eventually met his end whilst in combat with a dragon, evidence suggests that this played well into Beowulf’s plans and as such only Siegfried truly met a downfall. The question then, is: “What had distinguishes the two men’s fates?” The answer comes in the manner our heroes achieve their goals. Beowulf of the Geats and Siegfried of the Netherlands were both nearly omnipotent warriors, but the different methods that they utilized in their pursuits carved out significantly different fates. Whilst both were primarily driven personal gain, the effects of Beowulf’s actions coincided with public want whereas Siegfried’s’ deeds bought him many enemies.

Beowulf and Siegfried were ostensibly the same character—powerful, undefeatable warriors driven to satisfy their own desires. After Siegfried traveled to the city of Worms, he was immediately recognized by the Burgundian knight Hagen. Although Hagen had never seen Siegfried, he was able to describe the warrior’s deeds in exuberance: “By this hero’s hand fell the brave Nibelungs, Shilbung and Nibelung, the high princes. Wonders hath he wrought by his prowess…” Numerous accounts of Siegfried’s strength were accounted all thro...

... middle of paper ...

...s our vassal. Little service hath he done for his land”. Siegfried was eventually called to Worms where the confusion quickly stirred up hostilities. Though both men had self serving intentions, Siegfried’s goals were not at all beneficial to the community he resides in. This crucial difference here sealed far distinct fates for Beowulf and Siegfried.

Beowulf and Siegfried possess numerous similarities ranging from their appearance and history to their motivations and outlook. Both men are proud powerful warriors-nobles who are almost undefeatable in combat making their way towards their newest conquest. Although the objects of their desire are quite different, glory and Valhalla for Beowulf and Kriemhild for Siegfried, significant correspondences are displayed in their adventures. However, despite all this, only Beowulf managed to secure himself a happy ending.

More about Beowulf and Siegfried

Open Document