Argumentative Essay On The Catcher In The Rye

872 Words2 Pages

While Holden Caulfield years for companionship and care, at the same time he wants to be by himself. This leads to problems where Holden decides to meet up with people who he doesn’t like out of desperation, then bashes the person in their presence. The people near Holden aren’t a desirable person per say, and Holden aspires to be with people he is unable too. Holden would rather stay away from people to keep himself safe from the hurt they can cause them. Holden can’t stand the company he has because they aren't real, he cares about them too much, or they aren't there.
Throughout the novel Holden meets with people for drinks or love that only makes himself feel worse in the end. For instance, when Holden first meets up with Sally, he felt …show more content…

This is mostly toward Holden’s deceased brother Allie, who passed away due to Leukemia. This was the most detrimental to Holden because you can see exactly how this affected him. On the night of his passing, Holden was in his garage breaking all of the glass windows. Holden even,” Tried to break all the windows on the station wagon we had that summer, but my hands was already broken and everything by that time, and I couldn’t do it (Salinger 39).” Losing a family member at the age of thirteen changes who you become. But the real reason he loves Allie so much is because he passed away. Holden’s whole dream was to be a Catcher in the Rye and protecting the innocents of children. Since Allie passed, the only way Holden can recall him is through his memories, where he lives forever innocent. That's the reason why Holden holds onto his “Caul” as he is falling throughout the story, to protect the innocents of Allie and not let him fall with himself. The only person that Holden was able to catch in the rye was Allie, being forever innocent in the mind of …show more content…

Before she rides on it the first time, he gives the “Protection hat” to her as she rides it, protecting her symbolically if she falls trying to reach for the gold rings. As soon as the ride finishes, she runs to Holden and gives him the hat back. She goes straight back to the ride and continues to reach for the ring without his brother’s protection. That’s the whole reason why Holden finds the moment so beautiful. He got to see his sister grow up, which is exactly what he needed to stop falling. Holden is the father that Phoebe needs, being as her parents were not in the scene. Holden hates phonies and tries to avoid them because of the pain they cause him, he strays from Jane to keep her innocent in his head, and to keep Allie safe in Holden’s rye

Open Document