Is Christopher Columbus a national hero? Does he really deserve a national holiday? What good has he done, not forgetting about his invasion of the Natives? However, the United States would not be how it is if it wasn’t for Columbus. Recently, a new movement has made many headlines about renaming ‘Columbus Day’ to ‘Indigenous Peoples’ Day’. Certain cities in the United States began celebrating ‘Indigenous Peoples’ Day’ rather than ‘Columbus Day’ for decades now. Recently, the city of Cambridge held a unanimous vote with the City Council, which resulted in favoring the celebration of indigenous people, instead of Columbus. Many cities are debating whether or not changing this holiday should become official or not. This change began with a need …show more content…
for something, celebrating and honoring, not forgetting, about the importance of the Native Americans, especially those who were killed under Columbus when he invaded the New World. In today’s society, diversity matters and problems are prominent to many other issues. This conflict demonstrates a change in Americans’ thoughts while supporting American Identity, as it unfolds in the nation. Cambridge demonstrates a new awareness of diversity matters and problems with the official renaming ‘Columbus Day’ to ‘Indigenous Peoples’ Day’, proving how American Identity is about holding the same values about individual freedom. The idea of changing the name of this holiday has become slowly popular in society, as many towns decide to get on board. There are two different views people have of Columbus, the good and the bad. Some see Columbus as the brave man who created the nation, while others see him as a greedy invader that was reckless in killing off many natives. According to Christine Mai-Duc of the LA Times, “Native American activist groups, among others, see Columbus as a European colonizer who set in motion the genocide of an entire people”. The holiday name change has become in discussion because of these two different opinions of Columbus. Those who see him in a negative way have initially ignited this as they believe he does not deserve a holiday named after him, that is celebrated nationwide. On this side, people are defending the millions of natives, who they believe deserve to be honored for this holiday, more than Columbus does. According to B. Myint of Biography.com, “Columbus never set foot on our shores. In fact, October 12th marks the day of his arrival to the Bahamas”. The unfavorable side is supporting their speculation through facts about when Columbus even came. Columbus Day, which is celebrated every year on the second Monday in October, celebrates his discovery as a whole but still, disregards the indigenous natives whom Columbus sacrificed for the New World. The goal of changing this national holiday that celebrates only Columbus’s “discovery”, is to help to properly recognize those indigenous people who were there before Columbus, as Columbus just found them and completely ignored the fact that it was their home. This conflict sparks because of the opposition of Columbus, and the attempt to give the natives more attention and honoring, as they deserve it. Christopher Columbus Day has been renamed to Indigenous Peoples’ Day in Cambridge, as it was in favor through a unanimous vote.
At the beginnings, Cambridge City Council held a meeting and weighed both sides of this argument, including the history of Columbus and the importance of Italian-Americans in Cambridge. As a result, the council voted 9-0 for making the change of this national holiday in their town official. Cambridge Vice Mayor Marc McGovern outlined Christopher Columbus as, “the first person to start the genocide that took place in this part of the world”. Cambridge has been given lots of attention, but they were not the first to proclaim this new name for this national holiday. Christine Mai-Due from the LA Times states, “In 1992, the city of Berkeley was the first to declare the day Indigenous Peoples’ Day. Last year, Seattle and Minneapolis followed suit, and this year, Albuquerque; Portland, Ore.; St.Paul, Minn.; and Olympia, Wash., did too”. The importance of the natives in the nation has been the main motive for this change. The city of Berkeley was the first to celebrate ‘Columbus Day’ as ‘Indigenous Peoples’ Day’. This change occurred in 1992 and is starting to become popular and grab many cities attention in the past couple years. The importance of the Native Americans is a popular reason for this change to occur officially in Cambridge. J.D. Capelouto from the Boston Globe claims, “...it is important to reclaim the day for Native Americans, thousands of whom were killed under Columbus’s leadership when he came to the New World”. The city of Berkeley was officially the first to begin this name change but recently, Cambridge has been given most of the attention of this case, which is allowing many people and cities to start rethinking about this holiday that is celebrated in the nation every
year. The question on whether cities should change Christopher Columbus Day to Indigenous Peoples’ Day is worthy of discussion as it shows a change in Americans’ attitude and supports American Identity in the United States. Americans can forget about how lucky they really are to have such a strong essence of American Identity in the nation they live in. Ancestors have fought for the nation to continue with a stable and functioning society. The United States has freedom and democracy that is an important part of one's ‘American Identity’. It allows people to say and value what they want. Cambridge Vice Mayor Marc McGovern declares, “I view changing Columbus Day to Indigenous Peoples’ Day as a cleansing for me, as an Italian -America. I do not want Christopher Columbus to be representing my culture”. This is just one person’s point of view, illustrating how American Identity shows that this nation is not being defined by race, ethnicity or religion, but rather by their alike morals and positions with freedom of the individuals. The discussion of renaming Columbus Day in more and more towns demonstrates a new awareness for diversity problems, as it aims to give attention to the Natives in the New World before Christopher Columbus invaded. As the renaming this holiday came into question, it exposes a change in Americans’ attitude. President Franklin D. Roosevelt expresses that, “Each recurrence of Columbus Day brings to all of us a greater appreciation of the heritage we have received as a result of the faith and courage and fortitude of the Genoese navigator and his brave companions”. Americans’ attitudes are becoming more serious as they are listening to towns debate about this holiday. Americans are trying to realize what is more important to them, Columbus himself, or the heritage of the Native's World, that has formed into the nation many are proud to live in today. However, the answer to this will be different and can be different from others. That is what is so very important about American Identity, the fact that people each hold their own opinions but hold the same value of liberty. American Identity establishes the importance of freedom of holding one’s own ideas, which is shown through Cambridge’s decision to rename this national holiday. People across the nation have different views of Christopher Columbus. Either one thinks he was so courageous that he deserves his own national holiday or, one opposes, wanting a holiday called ‘Indigenous Peoples’ Day’, with an intention of commemorating the Natives that inhabited it before him. Cambridge held a vote and it resulted in an official change of ‘Columbus Day’ to ‘Indigenous Peoples’ Day’ throughout the city. Changes start with a need for something. In this case, the need was based on honoring the Native Americans who Columbus invaded, killed, and disregarded. This name change questioning has helped give awareness of diversity matters and problems the nation possesses. The freedom individuals have in the nation to hold their own speculations, proves how American Identity is about holding the same values about individual freedom rather than being the same race or believing in the same thoughts and religions. This name change conflict has helped to indicate a change in Americans’ thoughts while supporting American Identity, as it unfolds in the nation.
The credit for this change of view can be given to Washington Irving, who wrote a biography based on Columbus in 1828. This biography romanticized him and gave people the idea that he was this courageous hero who despite people’s claims that he’ll never succeed, ended up discovering what lies past the Atlantic. This biography gathered the momentum needed to catapult the collective opinion of Columbus higher in America. As time passed, more biographers wrote about him which resulted in groups forming, particularly the Knights of Columbus. They’re the group that pressed for a nationally recognized Columbus Day, which passed in
Columbus Day was not always a federal holiday. Traditionally, the holiday was observed on the 12th of October locally. Columbus Day first became a holiday in Colorado in 1906. Through lobbying by Angelo Rose, Generoso Pope, and The Knights of Columbus, Columbus Day became a federal holiday in 1937. It was signed in by Franklin Roosevelt. Since 1970, the holiday has been observed on the second Monday of October. Columbus Day had lobbying against it as well. During the early days before information was not easily available, it was said that the holiday would be used to spread Catholic influence. In later years during the Information Age, arguments such as Columbus 's character or the genocide and slavery of the Indians became widespread arguments against the celebration of the holiday. There are also many arguments as to why the holiday should be kept. Columbus 's voyages led to the colonization of the New World. His expeditions spurred the Age of Exploration, where many European countries continued to invest in exploring for shorter and faster routes to India and the Orient, and new territories to claim. His voyages also led to the Columbian
Christopher Columbus does not deserve to be honored as a hero with his own holiday. Close to 500 years, people have praised Christopher Columbus and also celebrated him as though he was the one who truly founded America. Teachers teach students that he was a great man, also how he found treasures and land known as America. Students are also taught about the names of his three ships he used on his first voyage. However, they did not teach us the truth about Christopher Columbus, and his so called “discovery”.
A great hero from Europe or a man with only himself and his people in mind? Many people believe that he was a hero whose discoveries lead to the possibilities we have in America today, while many other condemn him for the deaths of many Native Americans that occurred to make it possible to live in America today. What would someone like me see in Columbus’ discoveries and enslavements? He introduced the Europeans to new products and ways of financial expansion. Even though Columbus gave us a head start to a better life here in America, what lengths did he go to make such a life possible? He brought over diseases to the natives and also grazing animals to eat up the vegetation. These deaths would have never occurred if not for the countries that funded the exploration. Columbus and the Europeans would never have come to the Americas when they did and so many natives would not have died.
The name of the article is PRO/CON: Should we celebrate Christopher Columbus?It was made By Silvio Laccetti, McClatchy Tribune, and Los Angeles Times Editorial Board adapted Newsela staff. On 10/06/2017. There are monuments and teachers that are being destroyed. Many people died during Columbus time and when people think of Colombes they think of all the people that he killed. There are parks playgrounds and schools that tribute Christopher Columbus. The article says we should the accomplishment he made. The Los Angeles California City Council have joined with other cities to replace Columbus Day with a holiday called Indigenous Peoples Day. because of the controversy of Columbus, a lot of people
The controversy of whether or not Christopher Columbus should continue to be acknowledged by a federal holiday proves that his legacy has not escaped the scrutiny of history. Arguments born of both sides of the controversy stem from issues such as genocide, racism, multiculturalism, geographical land rights, and the superiority of certain cultures over others. In The Christopher Columbus Controversy: Western Civilization vs. Primitivism, Michael Berliner, Ph.D. declares that recognition of Columbus Day is well-deserved, claiming that Western civilization is superior to all other cultures and Columbus personifies this truth. On the contrary, Jack Weatherford's Examining the Reputation of Christopher Columbus equates Columbus' so-called discovery with brutal genocide and the destruction of ancient sophisticated civilizations. These articles demonstrate two extreme points of view in a manner that makes clear each authors' goals, leading the reader to consider issues of author bias, motivation, and information validity.
In 1492, Christopher Columbus unintentionally discovered America, when he landed in the Caribbean Islands, while looking for a direct sea route to Asia. Despite the fact that Columbus believed he had found a direct sea route to India, he has been called the discoverer of America and hailed as a hero. More recently, however, he has been called a villain, with accusations saying that not only did he not discover America, but also that he was the cause of slavery and oppression in the Americas. These allegations are absurd and lack logical evidence.
Christopher Columbus is a mythical hero or in other words, not a true hero. The story of Christopher Columbus is part of the many myths of Western civilization. Also the story of Christopher Columbus represents the power of those that are privileged and in most cases white European men that have written this mythical history. Zinn (2009 exposes the truth about Columbus through eyes of the people who were there when he had arrived which were the Native Indians (p.481). Columbus had kept a personal journal for his voyage to describe the people and the journey. What was evident throughout his journal was the Native Americans were very nice, gentle and kind hearted people (Zinn, 2009, 481). As Zinn suggests Columbus spoke of the Native Americans as” they are the best people in the world and
In some respects, we can attribute the founding of America and all its subsequent impacts to Christopher Columbus. Columbus a hero in the United States, has his own holiday and we view as the one who paved the way for America to be colonized. However, people tend to forget the other side of Columbus, the side that lusted after gold and resources that often belonged to the native inhabitants he came across in his exploration. In his insatiable greed, he and his crew committed countless atrocities, such as torture and killing of defenseless natives. Columbus’s discovery of these new lands contributes profound and negative effects as future colonists arrived. “Zinn estimates that perhaps 3 million people perished in the Caribbean alone from raids, forced labor and disease” (Zinn, 1980). Columbus was seen as a cruel man, who saw the peaceful inhabitants as right for the conquering and lead to the devastation of the native population, yet is celebrated every October.
For more than five centuries Americans have lifted Christopher Columbus to heights of greatness and god-like. We celebrate his life as though he was a man that had done us a great favor. In resent years Christopher Columbus has come under scrutiny, his life and works being questioned more than celebrated. There have be many great men and women that contributed to the building of our great nation but they do not receive anywhere as much recognition as Columbus. When a person begins to study the actual accounts of the "finding of the New World" they begin to wonder if Columbus should adored or hated for his actions. As a child I was taught that Columbus was a great man that had accomplished great things for the sake of humanity, but in reality his agenda was not to better humanity but to better himself. He found the Americas by mere chance and he did not even know of what he found. We give him credit for "finding" the Americas but history tells of the people, that he called Indians, already inhabiting the foreign land. So you decide whether or not Christopher Columbus should be revered a hero.
Other than what was taught in primary education I knew little of Christopher Columbus. I certainly did not know the truth. Educators and school board officials provided a faulty historical account of Christopher Columbus growing up. Most youth raised in America grew up with nursery rhymes and bedtime stories fictionalizing the heroic efforts and swash-buckling adventures of Columbus’ and men alike making their thievery and lack of concern for human life acceptable. All Americans including the Native and African Americans who were indirectly affected by Christopher Columbus via the slave trade and destruction of their people, observe Christopher Columbus Day. If this is so, why don’t we have a Hail Hitler Day? Hitler, though many see him as a terrible man, was simply doing what power hungry individuals have done for centuries. He simply took a page out of Christopher Columbus’ book destroying the weak and enslaving those left standing. In the case of Christopher Columbus quest for gold, he went to extreme measures to ensure he would get every last golden flake that glittered in Hai...
“In 1492 Columbus sailed the ocean blue”, is the rhyme embedded in children’s heads in the first lesson of US history. However, beyond the discovery of the New World, Christopher Columbus receives no other mentions. Especially no one acknowledges that he was the reason Native Americans were mistreated and kept as slaves. Although Christopher Columbus’ actions are not all honorable he should still be celebrated during Columbus Day as a brave explorer who risked his and his crew’s lives to find a new way of travel and land. His efforts bridged a gap between the New and Old World and helped feed Europe, which immensely impacts our society. Because of his dedication and bravery to be an explorer Christopher Columbus Day should be celebrated.
It is thought by many that Christopher Columbus was a skilled sailor on a mission of greed. Many think that he in fact did it all for the money, honor and the status that comes with an explorer, but this is not the case entirely. Columbus was an adventurer and was enthused by the thrill of the quest of the unknown. “Columbus had a firm religious faith and a scientific curiosity, a zest for life, the felling for beauty and the striving for novelty that we associate with the advancement of learning”. He had heard of the legendary Atlantic voyages and sailors reports of land to the west of Madeira and the Azores. He believed that Japan was about 4,800 km to the west of Portugal. In 1484, Columbus wanted support for an exploratory voyage from King John II of Portugal, but he was refused. In 1485, Columbus took his son Diego and went to Spain to get some help.
[2] Columbus is a mainstay of American patriotism. He is the patron saint who planted the seeds of our nation. Our culture has been lulled into his heroic myth for hundreds of years and has celebrated this man with much pomp and circumstance. Columbus’ worthiness has been the subject of much controversy and is now being linked to such un-heroic terms as mass murder, holocaust, and genocide.
To me Columbus Day should NOT be a national holiday because he was only good at being a leader and taking risk. Columbus was a betrayer, greedy man and leader of criminals. Columbus is not at all worthy of having his own holiday.