I believe in the quote and believe that the real sins in Antigone were being stubborn and prideful, theses are also the traits of the two potential tragic hero, Creon and Antigone, I believe that the true tragic hero is Antigone.
“All men make mistakes, but a good man yields when he knows his course is wrong and repairs evil. The only crime is pride.” I completely agree with the quote from the play. I think that the fact that as soon as Creon realized that he was in the wrong and turned around and tried to fix the mistakes he had made in the past. I think that this can be applied to real life too. If a leader doesn't realize that they are not perfect and that they make mistakes they will get in trouble later on. This tends to happen a lot
…show more content…
in politics. There have been many presidents that have made mistakes and not apologized for them after and try to fix the mistakes they've made. GEorge Bush made a few big mistakes while he was president but he never apologized for them and didn't try to fix them, now the majority of the people in our country don't see him a a very good president. In order to lead effectively and to make people feel like they are being ruled by a human like them leaders need to realize they make mistakes. This doesn't just apply to leaders they apply to people in everyday life too. The true sins of the entire story, were in the characters themselves. Antigone is very stubborn and Creon is full with pride. Both of these traits hurt the characters and cause them both much grief and pain. Because both of these traits are the things that make the story go around and cause the bad things to happen I believe that makes Antigone and Creon up for the potential tragic heros. Antigone says in the text “ Then I beg you: kill me. This talking is a great weariness: your words are distasteful to me,” (sophocles, l, 395) She is stubborn she knows she won't take her words back and she is ready to accept the consequences of her actions. She is so stubborn she isn't ready to accept that there was another way for her to express her anger about the way her brothers death was treated and she doesn't believe she was wrong. Creon also has the tragic flaw of pride. He will not go back on his word until his power and the fact if he is a good person or not is in question. Then when he finally goes back on his word Antigone is already dead. I think that the true sins of the story are flaws in human nature. Both Creon and Antigone have tragic flaws in their characters.
They both seem to at least loosely fit the traits of a tragic hero. the definition of a tragic hero is, a person of noble birth with heroic qualities. They are fated by the Gods or by some supernatural force to doom and destruction. But the hero struggles against this fate. I feel as though Antigone fits this definition better than Creon. Antigone is definitely more cursed than Creon is Oedipus Rex. Also her fate is worse than Creon's. She is so upset by him that she kills herself. She felt the need to leave behind her sister and future husband and kill herself. By the fact that Antigone dies and that Creon doesn't makes her the tragic hero over him. Going back to the original quote said by Tiresias, I think Antigone didn't realize that she had made a mistake and was not going to take back and try to fix anything she had …show more content…
done. Other people say that the tragic hero is Creon.
I agree that he definitely has the tragic flaw and that his fate is still pretty bad but not as bad as Antigones. But I think that sophocles was a very smart guy but also a feminist. He made 2 characters that could both be believed in a way to be a tragic hero. I think that he only made Creon's story so tragic because he wanted his play to be accepted by the targeted audience. Ancient greece was extremely sexist back when this play was written. Thucydides, a Greek philosopher in 460 BC - 400 BC once said that ”The greatest achievement for a woman is to be as seldom as possible spoken of.” By Sophocles having a story circle around a female character it was a bold move and even bolder to have her as the tragic hero. I think that he needed Creon to be there as a character that could also pose as the tragic hero while Antigone is actually the true tragic hero. Creon also changes his ways and kind of follows the quote that was said by Tiresias, but unlike Antigone he sees his mistakes and goes back to try and fix them. This makes even more of a less tragic hero because eventually he gets around his flaw and listens to the profits words of
wisdom. Antigone is the tragic hero of the play and people and leaders should recognize that they make mistakes in their life and try to fix them, they story revolves around the fact that creon and Antigone were prideful and stubborn. Although some believe that Creon is the tragic hero I think it's Antigone because she dies stays stubborn until the end and never regrets her choices. Tiresias quote is important to the story and in everyday life and is important all the time. People make mistakes but it takes a brave person to admit to them and try to fix them.
Being in power yields the assumption that everything is possible. In Creon’s case, he states that “never, if I can help it, shall evil triumph over good.” Creon’s pride in his position as King skewed his perception of what is just. He opens his Kingship commenting on this very feature of kingship, that “no other touchstone can test the heart of a man” like that of utmost power. Ironically, Creon reaches this touchstone, only to fail, causing many tragic deaths....
Haemon makes a point of this by saying, “The people here in Thebes all say the same – they deny she is (Lines 834-835). " This confirms Creon’s status as a tragic hero when he disagrees with his people's opinion on what has happened to Antigone, which causes him to step even closer to his ultimate demise. This is key because Creon shows how his ego comes before his people as Haemon stresses, which explains how his hubris, the emotion called stubbornness will contribute to his downfall. Additional way Haemon shows Creon as a tragic hero is by highlighting how his tragic flaws are not just angering humans, but the god's that their society revolves around. Haemon shows this by saying, “You're not honoring that by trampling on the god’s prerogatives (Lines 850-851).
The tragic hero, Antigone, is the tragic hero because she displays both good and bad throughout the greek tragedy Antigone. A quote that reveals she is good is “ This death of mine is of no importance; but If I had left my brother lying in death unburied, I should have suffered” ( 2. 69-71). This quote shows that Antigone is doing good because she is honoring her family by not leaving her brother unburied. Antigone is also seen as bad because King Creon talks to Antigone and says “ This girl is guilty of a double insolence, breaking the given laws and boasting about it” ( 2. 80-81). That quote shows Antigone is bad because she broke the law and was telling everyone about what she did , which also showed that she had hubris about her actions. Antigone is the tragic hero because
In the play Antigone, I choose Creon to be the tragic hero because he is the King of Thebes and he looses everything he has. Creon being King makes the audience believe that something like that can happen to the King then what can happen to us. Antigone the niece of Creon, The sister of Polyneices was punished by Creon for burying Polyneces after his death, Creon has forbidden anybody to do so. Once Creon punished Antigone the blind prophet Teiresias told him that the Gods will take revenge for his actions, then Creon tried to change everything but he is too late. Creon's tragic flaws were his stubbornness, the abuse of power and the actions he took to cause the downfall of the Thebes.
Antigone, written by Sophocles is a tale of a tragic hero who suffers with the recognition and realization of his tragic flaw. Although this short story is titled after Antigone, Creon is the main character and he provides the moral significance in the play. First, Creon withholds the respect of his citizens but it is clear to them he is not perfect through his pride (tragic flaw). Secondly, his radical reversal of fortune is made clear after he struggles with the recognition of his fatal flaw. Thirdly and lastly, his pity and fear flowers into an understanding of his prideful and destructive nature leading to his redemption. Nevertheless he is left with the burden of the deaths of his family, becoming a shell of misfortune and loneliness. Although Creon's actions cannot be labeled as courageous, his character traits pertain greatly to that of a tragic hero.
In the play Antigone, the debate over who is the real tragic hero is and the controversy of Greek ideals in the Antigone continues on to this day. Who is the tragic hero in Antigone? Is it Antigone herself or is it Creon the ruler of Thebes? The belief that Antigone is, is a strong one. Still there are people who think Creon is the tragic hero. Antigone is widely thought as the tragic her. The play is named after her. In addition, she is the antagonist in it. Many people usually associate the antagonist, the good guy as a tragic hero. Look at much television shows, especially cartoons, the good person usually wins. Then there are those who might think Creon was the tragic hero because the gods were against him, and that he truly loved his country. There are five criteria or standards you must meet first in order to be a tragic hero. First, you must be a person of high character or status. The character must not be too overwhelmingly evil or good. Then they must be brought from happiness to misery. Then brought from happiness to misery. Second, the hero enacts a harmartia, "wrong act." This either may be a flaw in judgment or an error. Third, the hero experiences a perpateia, reversal of fortune. This is the tragic downfall or plot twist in the story. Fourth, the hero recognizes his or her responsibility. Fifth, the story ends with a catastrophe. The catastrophe either may be an emotional event, this even may be a death.
A subject of debate in Sophocles’ play Antigone is which character complies with the characteristics of a tragic hero. The qualities that constitute a tragic hero are, in no particular order, having a high social position, not being overly good or bad, isolation, being tenacious in their actions, arousing pity in the audience, a revelatory manifestation, and having a single flaw that brings about their own demise and the demise of others around them. Creon possesses some of these qualities but, does not completely fulfill them all. Antigone does, however, conform to the persona of a tragic hero.
Since Creon has a tragic flaw of hubris and comes to an increased awareness about his wrongdoings, it is clear that he perfectly fits the characteristics of a tragic hero. Many readers may not be able to visualize how difficult it is for someone who loses something very important to them, unless they have experienced it firsthand. Creon's choices in the story are an example that signifies the use of the brain instead of emotions that could interfere with the decision. When given the choice of different paths, one should make compromises to satisfy not only themselves, but others around them when needed. Without doing this, it can lead to several disputes and severe devastation in life.
Greek tragedy would not be complete with out a tragic hero. Sophocles wrote Antigone with a specific character in mind for this part. Based on Aristotle’s definition, Creon is the tragic hero of Antigone.
In conclusion, Creon is the tragic character of Antigone because of his pride which caused him never ending agony by the end of this tragedy. Although Antigone’s stubbornness concerning the divine law and her brother’s burial lead her to her misfortune, her suffering was cut short by her death. On the other hand, Creon had to live through having his own son and the citizens of Thebes against his decision. Also, Haimon and Eurydices died as a result of his actions, leaving Creon without a family. Hence, Creon is the tragic character of the tragedy due to eternal distress caused by his judgment.
Thebian play of Antigone has excited many debates over the years. The most prevalent being who exactly could be characterized as the tragic hero in the story. The argument that Antigone is the hero is deffinatly a strong one. There are many critics who believe that Creon, however, is the true protagonist of the play. In order to determine whether or not Creon is the tragic hero one must first examine what a tragic hero is. Aristotle states that a hero is neither purely innocent nor purely malevolent. A hero is usually born into high rank of society, and this person must possess a tragic flaw. This flaw normally stems from either poor judgment or extreme arrogance. This flaw will inevitably contribute to the character's downfall.
Throughout literary history, tragic heroes have been defined as a great or virtuous character in a dramatic tragedy who is destined for downfall, suffering, or defeat. However, philosophers such as Aristotle tried to find connections between tragic heroes in Greek plays. This in-depth analysis of tragic heroes lead Aristotle to create six criteria for a true tragic hero: He or she has to be a Noble figure of royalty and noble in character, has to be imperfect by design, has a flaw or error that is a choice, is punished excessively for this choice flaw, has to undergo a downfall that leads to a realization, and the story of this tragic hero has to make the audience reach a moment of catharsis or purging of emotions. A prime example of a tragic hero that fits all of these criteria is Creon from the play Antigone, written by Sophocles in 441 BC. The story of Antigone is a tragedy that describes a stubborn and proud king named Creon who refuses to allow a burial for the brother of Antigone. Creon’s excessive pride leads to a series of unfortunate events resulting in the death of Antigone, his son Haemon, and his wife Eurydice. Throughout the course of the play, Creon undergoes each standard that is required by Aristotle’s terms to be a tragic hero.
Antigone could also be referred to as a tragedy sub-genre. Tragedy "recounts casually related series of events in the life of a person of significance, culminating in an unhappy catastrophe, the whole treated with dignity and seriousness" (554). Antigone is one of Sophocles' many famous tragedies. It is centered around the tragic outcome that may take place in the occurrence of being prideful. Sophocles portrays that pride can result in tragedy and in disaster. In the story, Creon is prideful as his position of King and he ultimately brings his city to ruins. "Tragedy" played a major role in the story.
In order to fully portray his view, Sophocles uses both Creon and Antigone as they function together as a tragic hero, none overtaking the other. Creon’s pride impedes but at the end, he brings shame upon himself. Antigone’s pride and wayward nature was valued by the people, and she desired what was best for her family and the moral sovereignty of the gods. Both characters depict Sophocles’ interpretation as a tragic hero by their characteristics and actions.