Analysis of Mr. White in The Monkey's Paw and Mr. Peters in The Third Wish

791 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Thematic analysis essays

What would someone do if they had only three wishes and knew that there would be a price that they would have to pay in order for them to fulfill their wishes? This is the question that overcomes the main characters, Mr. White and Mr. Peters, in the stories “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs and “The Third Wish” by Joan Aiken. In these two stories, two men were each allowed to create three wishes and had consequences that followed; therefore, they learned a valuable lesson about life.

The men in the two stories were distinct in their own ways, one being very greedy and the other very cautious. In “The Monkey’s Paw,” the main character was Mr. White. He was very discerning. When he was first introduced in “The Monkey Paw,” he asked many questions and was very curious. Mr. White was also very greedy. He was not content with hat he had, and he then, out of all the wishes in the world, asked for two hundred pounds for his own conveniences. On the other hand, the main character of “The Third Wish” is Mr. Peters. Mr. Peters is a kind-hearted, cautious man. The reader can tell that those are his traits for number of reasons. First of all, the reader can tell that Mr. Peters is compassionate because of his reaction towards a swan trying to extricate itself from a branch. He quickly rushes over and tries to free the bird. Another reason why the reader knows that Mr. Peters is kind is because they see how he wants his wife to be happy more than himself. This clearly shows how “warm his heart” is. The reader can also learn that Mr. Peters is cautious by observing the way he thinks about his three wishes. Every time he thinks of a wish, he pricks his tongue with a thorn. The traits both characters demonstrated also led the reade...

... middle of paper ...

...inal was created. The last clue given was when people ask Mr. Peters to just find another wife. Mr. Peters replies that he would be faithful to Leita. This suggests the true love between the two and the loyalty they share between each other.

As I have explained, these two stories, Mr. White and Mr. Peters both were eligible to wish for three things and, therefore, they encountered some consequences. Due to their experiences, the reader learns a valuable lesson about life. All in all, these two stories were very interesting. The way the authors set the mood of the stories based on character traits, wishes, consequences, and theme was very intelligent and well-though-out. Both stories had great themes that helped a reader understand the story and life better. I thought “The Monkey’s Paw,” and “The Third Wish,” were both marvelous pieces of literature.

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of The Book 'Black Man In The White Coat'

    164 Words  | 1 Pages

    In book " black man in the white coat", the author has been mistaken as the electrician by his professor in medical school. It's unfortunately very common experience for our black fellows. I really admired his way to deal with this discrimination. He worked his butt off and became the second in that class. The professor was shocked by his accomplishments and invited him to work in his lab. Of course, he politely refused. The professor had no words about that incident (maybe every black looks same in his eyes). The stereotyping thing is detrimental to the people who came from different race background. Now the in-between biracial people are treated even worse because they do not belong to any categories..."others". Being marginalized is hurtful

    Read More

  • Who Is Responsible For The Monkey's Paw

    194 Words  | 1 Pages

    Additionally, Sergeant Major Morris knew the consequences of wishing upon the monkey's paw, saying on page 377, "I don't know what the first two [wishes] were, but the third was for death." This implied that the previous owner of the paw had suffered such severe consequences that he wished away his own life. Although Sergeant Major Morris refrained from giving the

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Robert Guthrie's Even The Rat Was White

    1982 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Dr. Guthrie sheds light on the embarrassment that was early psychology and its extraordinary dedication to racism and, with his work, changed that discipline forever,” states William Grier’s forward for Robert Guthrie’s own Even the Rat Was White: A Historical View of Psychology (Grier, p. xi). After attending Florida A & M University in 1948 for his bachelor’s degree, Guthrie joined the military to fulfill draft requirements before returning to finish his degree (O’Connor, 2001. He went on to earn his Masters degree at the University of Kentucky followed by his doctorate in psychology at the U.S. International University in 1970 (O’Connor, 2001. He was the first African-American professor at San Diego Mesa College and one of the founding members of the Association of Black

    Read More

  • Comparing The Third Wish And The Monkey's Paw

    764 Words  | 2 Pages

    The theme in both stories are the same it is be careful what you wish for. I know this because in the “Monkey's paw” even when the man says, “ I warn you of the consequences if you must wish, wish for something sensible” Mr.white still wishes for 200 pounds this was not a very sensible wish it was actually very selfish and childish. As a result That same day a man walked up to his door and says that Mr.white's son was caught in equipment and that, “they wish to present

    Read More

  • Comparing The Monkey's Paw And The Goldfish

    698 Words  | 2 Pages

    In these stories the most noticeable similarity is that they both are centered around the three wishes and magical things that grant them. “He put a spell on it so that three separate man could have three wishes..” (Monkeyś Paw page 2). Similarly in the goldfish story, “If you found a talking goldfish that granted you three wishes, what would you wish for?” The fact that they are granted three wishes are the same, but they are granted by different things. In The Goldfish story they are granted by a talking goldfish, but in Monkeyś Paw they are granted by the cursed paw. This might seem like a little difference, but each one plays a role in the story line. This is because the character in The Goldfish [Sergei] is lonely and wants the goldfish to be its companion. This is why he struggled to give up his third wish, because as soon has the goldfish grants your third wish he is to be set free. This is the main part of this story and it would not make sense for a cursed Monkeyś Paw to

    Read More

  • How Does Jacobs Use Irony In The Monkey's Paw

    932 Words  | 2 Pages

    One may stutter over the conception that a monkey’s paw holds the power to determine fate, rather than siding with freewill. In the short story, “The Monkey’s Paw,” an average family, located in the middle class discovers a monkey’s paw and are told that they had three wishes upon that magical, yet deceiving item. However, their decisions cost them several, unintended consequences, due to greed within the human mind. The author, W.W. Jacobs uses symbolism, foreshadowing, and irony to convey the peril of wish fulfillment and the dangers of interfering with fate.

    Read More

  • Compare & Contrast The Rocking Horse Winner and The Destructors

    1293 Words  | 3 Pages

    When comparing the themes of each story, surprising similarities arise.  First, both are developed around the lives of children.  In “The Destructors” a group of boys called the Wormsley Gang have the same view of the world around them.  They have grown up together and share stories about the bombs that destroyed their town.  They also challenge each other to accomplish various tasks.   The house that the boys ultimately destroy represents the greediness of Mr. Thomas, an architect who owns the tattered home.  The Wormsley Gang called him ‘Old Misery’.  In the Rocking Horse Winner”, the story’s plot is thickend by a a young boys obsessive desire to “become lucky”.  This young boy, Paul, believes that his house is continually whispering, “…there must be more money…there must be more money”.  Paul is able to relate the self-proclaimed dissatificatoin of his mothers life with the odd mood of his house.  Paul knows that although his mother appears to have everything together on the outside, she does not love him on the inside.  Paul believes that he can please his mother if he is able to find a way to give her more money.  In both stories, the houses were very symbolic.

    Read More

  • Regret In A Christmas Carol Essay

    1063 Words  | 3 Pages

    In this Stave, Dickens shows the importance of kindness by showing Scrooge’s absence of it and the effects of his harmful indifference. Scrooge is taken into his own past and shown memories of when he was young. The Ghost shows him scenes of when he was small and alone on Christmas. This memory makes him regret his harshness towards a young caroler that had come to his door the previous day. He sees that he lacked kindness and wishes he gave something to the caroler. His indifference towards the caroler insured that Scrooge would remain alone. The Ghost also reminds Scrooge of his beloved sister, Fannie who had died and left only her son. “’Always a delicate creature, whom a breath might have withered,’ said the Ghost. ‘But she had a large heart!’ ‘So she had,’ cried Scrooge. ‘You’re right. I will not gainsay it, Spirit. God forbid!’ ‘She died a woman,’ said the Ghost, ‘and had, as I think, children.’ ‘One child,’ Scrooge returned. ‘True,’ said the Ghost. ‘Your nephew!’ Scrooge seemed uneasy in his mind; and answered briefly, ‘Yes.’” (pg. 33-34). Scrooge’s only connection to his kind and gentle sister is his nephew, who also shares Fannie’s sweet nature. Scrooge is then filled with regret because of his callous treatment and lack of relationship with his nephew, who only wanted to be kind and spread the joy of the season. Scrooge’s sheer indifference and lack of kindness towards his nephew prevented

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Salesman And The Veldt

    1343 Words  | 3 Pages

    White used on the monkey’s paw was to have 200 pounds (Jacobs 91). The previous examples prove how the theme of limiting luxury is illustrated differently in both stories by showing the wealth of each family. In “The Veldt,” the family is in a superior financial state where they have access to anything they want and where money is not an issue. However in “The Monkey’s Paw,” although it took place in 1902, the White’s first wish was for 200 pounds- 243 dollars and 83 cents- which is not an insanely large amount of money that would result in them being care-free for the rest of their lives. Overall, this proves the theme of the limiting luxury through showing the amount of means each family has and how their limit’s would be different from one another's as the two stories progress. Another instance of how the theme is portrayed differently in the short stories is how finances play a role in family life. For instance, in Ray Bradbury’s “The Veldt,” the Hadley’s have access to such an extreme amount of money that it begins to affect how the parents and kids interact. This occurs when Peter threatens his father by saying, “I don’t think you’d better consider it any more, father” (Bradbury 7). On the contrary, the relationship between the members of the White family is much

    Read More

  • Comparison and Contrast Essay

    755 Words  | 2 Pages

    “A good story, whether it is true, made-up, or somewhere in between, reveals some truth about human experiences through its characters.” The main character in “The Monkey’s Paw” is Mr. White. He could be described as protective and caring due to his love towards his family. He is also curious, because he wants to have the magical monkey’s paw, despite the warnings given to him by Sergeant Major Morris. From the beginning, all Mr. White wants is to pay off his house mortgage. Also a man, the main character in “The Third Wish” is Mr. Peters. Mr. Peters, on the contrary to Mr. White, is a lonely man who desperately wants a companion. He is granted a wife as beautiful as the forest, Leita, for rescuing the forests king. Mr. Peters shows selflessness and kindness to Leita, when he wishes her back to swan form so she may be happy with her swan sister again.

    Read More

  • Compare and Contrast Essay

    681 Words  | 2 Pages

    In short, there are multiple similarities and differences in the characters, plot, and resolution in the short story and motion picture “The Monkey’s Paw” that clearly influence the audience. For instance, the difference in characters affects the mood. Similarities in the plot influence the tone, and the corresponding resolutions impact the theme. The director of the motion picture “The Monkey’s Paw” chose to stick to some aspects of the text as well as change some for numerous reasons, some of which include keeping the audience's attention, sustaining the author's tone in the text, and ensuring that the readers and viewers receive the same message.

    Read More

  • Of Mice And Men Crooks Character Analysis

    123 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the novel Of Mice And Men the loneliest person that barely gets introduce and mentioned once is Crooks. He is mentioned in last part of the book on pg. 69. They detail everything in his bunk and how he has a collection of shoes. He is a very quiet person the only time he speaks is when he needs to, also when there’s a problem like when he saw Lennie touching slims pups. He is like a very honest and respective person he causes no trouble and he does his job without disturbing no one. It seems like Crooks never ask for help he does everything on his own. Crooks is a educated person by noticing all the books in his bunk.

    Read More

  • Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

    2677 Words  | 6 Pages

    be The monkeys paw. This story is a better length to not take a while

    Read More

  • Who Is Mr. Peters 'Third Wish'?

    565 Words  | 2 Pages

    “The Third Wish” is an outstanding and splendid short story written by the deceased author Joan Aiken. Mr. Peters is the protagonist of the story; he is loyal, compassionate, and wise. In this magical tale, Mr. Peters is granted three wishes by The King of the Forest and decides how to use his wishes, bringing much trouble. I think that Mr.Peters character traits are being loyal, compassionate and wise.

    Read More

  • Freedom: Will You Use it For Good or Evil?

    1158 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Charles Dickens’, A Christmas Carol, Ebenezer Scrooge lives as the unhappy owner of an accounting office who mistreats those around him. Scrooge has not lived life in a satisfying manner and now resides in isolation, in no hurry to right the wrongs of his past. Through the intercession of three ghosts, Scrooge journeys to Christmases of the past, present, and future and transforms from a man of greed into one of care and compassion. In the beginning of the story, Dickens contrasts the harsh personality of Scrooge with, “Gentlemen of the free-and-easy sort” (Dickens 31). Scrooge’s treatment of others is not easy to overlook, but he must seek forgiveness and set himself free.

    Read More

More about Analysis of Mr. White in The Monkey's Paw and Mr. Peters in The Third Wish

Open Document