Analysis Of The Twelfth Night And A Streetcar Named Desire

714 Words2 Pages

Without character, there can be no drama
These strong drama and dramedy plots are structured around two strong dramatic women who emphasise the importance of character to act as a vessel through which a drama can be represented in a variety of settings. In both, 1940s New Orleans set A Streetcar Named Desire and the Illyria-based Twelfth Night, the plot is centred around a woman hiding her identity, in A Streetcar Named Desire Blanche is the catalyst for the plot as is Viola for Twelfth Night, though women in very different times, they are similar in their affect on the audience but differ in how they deal with loss.
Blanche and Viola contribute to the development of the theme of hidden identity, although their methods of disguise differ. Viola’s disguise is more obvious to the audience at the start. Viola’s focus is on disguising her physical identity; it is necessary for Viola to hide her identity so she can start to re-build her life. However, the same could be said for the intentions of Blanche’s disguise. Blanche’s disguise covers her past actions and her present emotions. Both women cling to their disguises through the plot but they have very different relationships with their disguises. Viola’s hidden identity is born out of the need to survive and she views her disguise as a “wickedness” (II,ii, 24). Blanche, on the other hand “[doesn’t] want realism” and uses her disguise to shield others and herself from the reality of who she really is (Williams 86).

As complex, troubled characters Blanche and Viola established a relationship with the audience, which leaves the audience feeling sympathetic toward them both. The nature of the sympathy felt by the audience varies between characters. Viola loses her brother, and is wash...

... middle of paper ...

... very real responses to loss but evoke different qualities and actions.

Two characters that express themselves differently but, through their use of disguise and similar affect on the audience, manage to successfully portray the depth of a drama by connecting with the audience and acting as a channel for the cathartic moment, which marks a drama. These two women represent the same character but portray her in different ways. Viola’s portrayal is directed toward the fantastical, comedic setting of Twelfth Night, whereas Blanche is a much harsher, real, relatable character where the true fight with these emotion can be felt in an authentic way.

Work Cited

Shakespeare, William. Twelfth Night. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2012. Print.

Williams, Tennessee, and Elliott Martin. Browne. A Streetcar Named Desire. London: Penguin, 2009. Print. Modern Classics.

Open Document