Analysis Of John Brown

1219 Words3 Pages

Just who was this man that could make southern mobs attack northerners, regardless of their views of slavery and make the fear of slave insurrection strengthen? His name is John brown and one might say that this former slave and black abolitionist just wanted to end slavery by causing violence between the north and the south. But to his men, his only intention was to start a general slave insurrection. For example he went to Harper 's Ferry and raided an armory with the intention of starting an armed slave army. Soon Brown became doubtful of this plan a couple of months into it and as he warned his co conspirators that it might fail. But even if it failed he would hope that it would lead to the destruction of slavery. After getting caught and …show more content…

The first example would be when he quoted John Garraty “dreadful act.. It would have been far wiser and more just to have committed him to an asylum”. The second example would be when Allen Nevins thought that John Brown was only insane when he was asked about slavery. The final major example would be when he talked about Stephen Oates, who thought that it was unfair to judge John Brown insanity. This was because if you were to call Brown insane “is to ignore the tremendous sympathy he felt for the black man in America.” All of these examples have the common idea that John Brown was somehow related to being insane. Conclusively throughout the article the author believes that John Brown was truly more insane than a genius which is shown through others …show more content…

But his men only saw him trying to start a general slave insurrection. Then after getting caught at the Harper 's Ferry and put in jail he tried to offer a contrary explanation of repeatedly denying his intentions to commit violence or to start a slave rebellion. Brown did this knowing that his death would strengthen the abolitionist movement. Americans soon started to see John Brown as either a calculating insurrectionist, a martyr or as insane. There were also multiple people wrote their opinions on John Brown 's sanity like John Garraty and Allen Nevins, who believed that he was truly insane. But the most remarkable of these writers would be Stephen Oates, who thought that it was unfair to judge Brown 's sanity because if you call him insane “is to ignore the tremendous sympathy he felt for the black man in America.” Overall most of his acquaintances saw Brown 's mental state change after the Pottawatomie killings. Also some people say that Harpers Ferry happened due to his insanity but this idea is denied by most. It was also shown that not only was Brown mentally insane, he was spiritually insane too. He had believed that God personally gave him the mission to end slavery. Also, Governor Wise stated that Brown 's sanity was as much of a Political and legal issue than a medical problem. At the time

Open Document