More handpicked essays just for you.
Weimar Republic success and failures
Successes and failures of the weimar republic
Weimar Republic success and failures
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
The Weimar Republic
The Weimar Republic was created in Germany in 1918 as a result of
widespread socialist unrest. A liberal constitution was drawn up in
1919. There was extensive instability in Germany around this time. The
Weimar government had trouble pleasing right and left wing parties
because, at this time, Germany was very polarised politically. Hitler
dissolved the republic in 1933. But was it doomed from it's beginning?
One of the main fields where problems arose was the legacy of World
War 1. Germany's unexpected defeat was blamed on the "November
Criminals" and made people suspicious of the new government. The
Treaty of Versailles associated the government with Germany's
acceptance of this national humiliation. The soldiers returning back
from the front line were bitter at the republic and many joined right
wing paramilitary groups, such as the Freikorps. The war left Germany
with few allies with which to trade. This caused a growth in national
debt, which the Treaty of Versailles worsened. To counter this the new
government printed off more money causing hyperinflation, which upset
people on fixed incomes.
The nature of the revolution also upset people. It was fairly limited,
despite the liberal constitution. Ebert, the first President of the
republic, made a deal with Groener, a top General, which resulted in
the military remaining largely unchanged. This meant that many groups
hostile to the republic retained their power. The judiciary and
bureaucracy were also largely unchanged, as was the academic world. In
addition to this, the suppression of the Spartacist uprising dashed
the left wing's hopes of a socialist ...
... middle of paper ...
...of Versailles caused the debt and inflation
experienced. Ebert's deal with Groener caused the judiciary and
military to remain unaffected. When Ebert allied himself with the
right, through this deal, he was forced to suppress the left, as in
the Sparticist uprising.
I think the most significant problem facing the republic early on was
article 48. This undermined the democratic nature of the republic and
gave the President almost dictatorial powers. This actually was what
finally destroyed the republic.
I think that the Weimar Republic was doomed from the beginning as
sooner or later someone who was against the system was going to become
President and then they could destroy the system. Also, I think with
the extremely large range of political views in Germany at the time
meant that no one could please everyone.
The Weimer Republic, is the democratic government established in Germany in 1918 that ruled for fifteen years after the collapse of the German empire after the First World War.The republic consisted of moderates from the Social Democratic Party as well as their liberal allies, which included the German Democratic Party, and the Catholic Center Party. The Weimer Republic sought political democracy, which they believed was attainable by the elimination of war, revolutionary terror, and capitalism. Despite their clear goal, the Weimer Republic faced backlash by the radicals of society, which included communists, National Socialists, and the Nazi Party led by Adolf Hitler. THESIS: The Weimer Republic’s instability in the period of 1918-1933 is
Additionally, the Treaty of Versailles imposed harsh penalties on Germany, which further weakened the government's legitimacy and fueled nationalist sentiments. Overall, the Weimar Republic's instability was a result of a complex interplay of factors, including political, economic, and social issues, as well as external pressures from the international community.
As Ian Kershaw explains, the Weimar Republic was failing: "the survival chances of Weimar democracy might be regarded as fairly poor by the end of 1929, very low by the end of 1930, remote by the middle of 1931 and as good as zero by Spring 1932." In a period of Depression and when unity and firm government was essential, Müller's Grand Coalition broke up in March 1930. Logically, there were several political alternatives other than Hitler and the Nazis.
The first major reason that the Weimar republic failed was that it was extremely inefficient and did not have clear goals set within the government. All the different ideas coming from the parties in the republic, created a situation where the people of Germany were getting very unclear, vague messages. This problem can be seen in the struggle between the German Democratic Party and the Communist Party. Troeltsch, a theologian and leader of the German Democratic Party said, “The development will not stop at democracy, and a ‘dictatorship of the proletariat’ will assume the form of terrorist domination by a minority” (Doc 1). This statement is only somewhat reliable because Troeltsch was a politician, and he would benefit from over exaggerating what would happen if the opposing party were to gain control.
The Left and Right at the Birth of Weimar Germany From the general chaos and unrest that followed the Kiel Mutiny in late 1918, the centre-left emerged to lead Germany into a new era of democracy. Philipp Scheidemann, a key figure in the moderate SDP, declared a Democratic Socialist Republic from a balcony in Berlin on 9th November 1918. However, the whole of Germany was not behind him, since simultaneously, and from a different Berlin balcony, Karl Liebknecht, leader of the communist Spartacists (KPD), declared a Soviet Republic.
Evaluation of Weimar Germany The Weimar Republic was an extremely complex and diverse place throughout the entirety of the interwar years. The society and the culture that the Weimar created had several different facets and frontiers according to how one chooses to approach it. The fundamental themes of the period evolve around Political conflict, economic instability, social unrest and diverse ideologies. In relation to this essay I shall be focusing my attention on the latter themes, as I believe that the determinants of social unrest and conflicting ideologies are paramount when investigating the social and cultural development of the Weimar Republic. There is little doubt that pre-war and post-war German societies were very different.
Richard Bessel’s article stresses the political structure of Weimar Germany as the cause of its failure. Its structure was flawed in numerous ways, all of which contributed to its inevitable failure. First of all, the problems within Germany due to the First World War were massive. This caused economic, political and social problems which first had to be dealt with by the new Weimar government. The loss of the war had left Germany with huge reparations to pay, and massive destruction to repair. In order to gain the capital needed to finance efforts to rebuild, and repay the Allies, the economy had to be brought back to its prewar levels. This was not an easy task.
Following the German surrender in November 1918, the Empire experienced a brief, but significant civil revolution. The German Revolution lasted from the end of the war until August 1919. During that time, a national assembly was held in the city of Weimar where a new constitution was drafted. A new federal republic (known as the Weimar Republic) was born and a semi-presidential representative democracy overthrew the monarchy of Kaiser Wilhelm II. The new government faced immediately faced a multitude of issues including political instability, reestablishing and maintaining international post-war relations, and severe economic turmoil – most notably the period of hyperinflation which occurred in the early 1920s.
The main reason was that people were discomposed that Germany had lost a war and most of the people blame for the defeat. On the other hand, during 1929-1933, the worldwide Great Depression, which impacted Germany, and there was no leader of Weimar could solve the economic problem.
The Weakness of the Weimar Republic and Hitler's Rise to Power The question directly relates to the idea that the political power of a country can be taken over by ambitious people in different ways. From our knowledge we know there is three ways this can be done…by take over by force, also known as a 'coup d'etat', in a more democratic and just way or by a political deal. In the 1920's and the 1930's Hitler led a right wing political party and was seen by many as a dictator. He wanted to overthrow and control the German government and he tried all three of these ways in an attempt to do so, some methods were more successful than others.
The Weimar years were marked by extraordinary and unrivaled economic, political, and social struggles and crises. Its beginning was marked as being especially difficult in that Germany was wiped out and devastated after four years of the unprecedented warfare of World War I. By 1918 the world had been shocked with over 8.5 million killed on both Allies and Axis sides and many more severely mangled and scarred – body, mind and spirit. This is seen as German Soldier, Ernst Simmel, writes, “when I speak about the war as an event, as the cause of illness, I anticipate something has revealed...namely that it is not only the bloody war which leaves such devastating traces in those who took part in it. Rather, it is also the difficult conflict in which the individual finds himself in his fight against a world transformed by war. Either in the trenches or at home can befall a single organ, or it may encompass the entire person” (Simmel, 1918). For Ernst, and millions of other participants, the war had turned forever changed their world.
This hugley undermined the democratic integrity of the constitution; after all, the Germany had just forced one autocratic leader out of office, only for a new one to take his place. Although these powers were only meant to be used in times of emergency, Ebert used them 136 times during his six years as President. Many of the times, his reason for using them was simply to pass a law that he particulary wanted, but was unable to get through the Reichstag because proportional representation had given such significant representation to such a large number of ideologically opposing political parties. The use of thse powers showed that, even though he disagreed with the way in which he reached the office of President (ie. he had been placed there after the revolutionary actions of both Prince Max, the Chancellor, and Philip Scheidemann, his right-hand man), he was still happy enough to sue his power and authority in very undemocratic, and indeed positively autocratic,
Exploring the Reasons Behind Public's Discontent with the Weimar Government There were a number of reasons why the German people were unhappy with the Weimar government. One of the main reasons for this was the signing of the Treaty of Versailles. The result of this was that Germany has to take the war guilt, Germany had to pay reparations of 6,600 million marks to the allies in particular France, Germany lost its colonies, it lost its air force & tanks, and its soldiers were restricted to 100,000. The Ruhr was demilitarised. Also they lost their colonies and its land was cut up such as the Polish Corridor and Alsace Lorraine.
...After we consider all these points mentioned we begin to see how everything worked and connected to form one huge disaster for Germany. We start to see how all these things played a part, the reparations led to unemployment that led to no money that led to overprinting of money. How the huge consequence of the reparations led to the unsuccessful paying of it leading to the French invasion of the Ruhr which led to strikes and therefore no products to trade with. How the unstable Weimar government led to extremist parties that damaged the economy further and brought inflation to its highest. The effects were probably the worst, the starvation coupled with the disease epidemic that killed people off and the worthless tonnes of paper notes roaming around the nation. It all in all was a very bad time in Germany one that they always found it hard to recover from.
Under the democratic government, censorships were lifted and German people were free to express themselves. Cultural improvements were occurring throughout the country. There was greater production and use of literature, music, and theatre. Germany was beginning to get back on its feet after a harsh war; its relationships between the government and the people, and also with the allies were improving. Although Germany appeared to be recovering and getting prosperous again, there were many underlining problems which threatened its stability.