The Punishment Given To Esther Price Summary

390 Words1 Page

The Punishment Given to Esther Price

I think that as soon as you read the information that is above the source which explains who written about it. The writer, John Doherty, was an active trade unionist which would mean making the mills sound bad was in his advantage. This clearly gives you the impression before you even read it that it's going to be biased against the Greg's and their punishment of Esther Price. In the first sentence it mentions that the mill had apprentices but in this account it is "apprenticed". This shows that he obviously doesn't think that they are treated like apprentices and is being sarcastic. He also makes the Gregg family sound like a mean and uncaring one only interested in profits "…not only …show more content…

After Ester returned after a week we know that she was punished by being kept in solitary confinement. In Doherty's account it claims she was barely fed, had no light, fire or beds either. It also states that the windows where boarded up just to be cruel and that it had no purpose. A few years later Greg also wrote his account of what happened with her and her punishment. He claims that after she came back she was to be put into confinement for a week. She was given two meals a day and the windows where boarded up because she was known for being a nuisance, and this kept her from communicating or escaping. In the room there where many cloaks to sleep on so there was no need for a bed. So far the two stories have been along the same lines but Doherty's also claims that the Greg's are mean people whereas all other sources and more in other places claim they where the kindest and best employers of their time. During Esther's punishment

Open Document