Role of Masculinity in Shiloh and A Streetcar Named Desire

2010 Words5 Pages

Role of Masculinity in Shiloh and A Streetcar Named Desire A Truckdriver Named Shiloh Have you ever felt that men always screw things up? Perhaps it is not men themselves that cause destruction; maybe it is merely the result of the presence of a masculine character. The role of masculinity is an essential aspect in both Bobbie Ann Mason's short story entitled, Shiloh, and in Tennessee Williams' play, A Streetcar Named Desire, although it functions very differently in each story. In Shiloh, we see the detrimental effects that the male role has even in its absence through the interactions that Leroy has with his with wife, Norma Jean. Contrasting this particular perspective, in A Streetcar Named Desire the destructive manner of the male role is unmistakably present, as it negatively affects Stanley and Stella's relationship. In these two works, we see the masculine role epitomized by one man, and abandoned by another, which, in both situations, leads to the destruction of their marriages. Through the examination of the two stories it becomes ironically clear how terrible and yet desirable the male role is to conquer, and what different effects it has on the central characters involved. To begin, an understanding of what the masculine role is must first be acquired. The masculine role serves many functions, and most of them are relatively clear-cut and commonsensical. The male role, for our purposes, is the presence of an authoritative individual that takes charge in precarious situations, makes money, and serves as a provider for a family. Characteristics of the masculine character would include a degree of barbarism, accompanied by great physical strength and a relentless drive to accomplish goals. The character filling the male role must be mentally aware, even if not in a witty sense, and capable of being moderately sensible. All of these characteristics are established and made apparent in different characters throughout both of the stories in discussion. The masculine role serves both works in a very unique manner and provides a glimpse into the extensive influence that it has on other characters. Stanley Kowalski eats testosterone for breakfast. Throughout A Streetcar Named Desire, Stanley is portrayed as a primitive, brutal animal of a man who wouldn't be capable of defining the word "feminine." In the first scene of the play, Stanle... ... middle of paper ... ... negatively affect the characters engaged in many ways. The masculine role seems very hard to conquer in both stories. In Shiloh, Norma can no longer take on the responsibility of acting as the masculine role, whereas in A Streetcar Named Desire, Stanley is overcome by his own barbarian nature; no one seems to be able to handle the role responsibly. It is also crucial to note the bleeding irony in both of the situations. Stella loves having such a masculine role in her life. She would not trade him for any other man, he is just what she desires…that is until he rapes her sister and destroys everything. Norma Jean on the other hand is so consumed with the masculine role, that when she feels that it is no longer existing in her life, she decides to take it on herself. When she does, she finds herself out of place, discontent, displeased, and divorced. The female characters seem to be content only in the presence of a strong male role, regardless of who is maintaining it, even if it leads to disparaging conditions. Bibliography: Works Cited Mason, Bobbie Ann. Shiloh. Harper and Row, 1982. Williams, Tennessee. A Streetcar Named Desire. England: Signet Printing, 1951.

Open Document