Pride And Prejudice Compare And Contrast Essay

1037 Words3 Pages

“The book was better” is the mundane response when inquiring as to books and their respective film adaptations. Pride and Prejudice is no exception. Written by Jane Austen in 1813, Pride and Prejudice reflects the protagonist, Elizabeth Bennett, and her ideal match, Fitzwilliam Darcy, as they struggle to overcome their differences, and obstacles otherwise existing within the accompanying characters (social hierarchy, jealousy, selfishness). Elizabeth’s realization and acceptance of Darcy’s true goodness leads her to overcome her harsh, initial prejudice of him and Darcy’s tempering of his pride throughout the novel allow him to eventually applaud, and love Elizabeth for her strong-character. Hence the title: Pride and Prejudice. The film adaptation …show more content…

The novel is set in 1813, while the film is meant to be in the late 18th century. The backbone (protagonist) of the story, Elizabeth Bennet, varies differently in characterization between the book and movie. In the novel, Elizabeth is written as intelligent, mild, musically talented, and humored; the film adaptation represents her as coarse, with deficiency in musical skill, ill-tempered and rude. For instance, she yells at her parents after refusing Mr. Collins’ proposal, both unbecoming of her and inappropriate for that time period. In addition, the author reveals the closeness that Elizabeth and Jane share, and how open they are to each other: "Indeed, Jane, you ought to believe me. No one who has ever seen you together can doubt his affection. Miss Bingley, I am sure, cannot. She is not such a simpleton. Could she have seen half as much love in Mr. Darcy for herself, she would have ordered her wedding clothes. But the case is this: We are not rich enough or grand enough for them..." (Austen, 106). In contrast, the movie illustrates the sisters keeping secrets from each other, or rather, Elizabeth being secretive and shut off from her entire family. In regards to the other characters, Mr. and Mrs. Phillips are left out of the movie completely (which, as Mr. and Mrs. Bennet are represented as bad parental units in the novel, and the aunt and uncle act more parental towards the Bennet sisters, the absence of these …show more content…

the nobleman falling in love with the very poor girl, the gentleman and the rebel, less romanticized dialogue, etc). The character of Elizabeth Bennett was altered drastically, perchance in an attempt to make her more identifiable with today’s audience of young women; her main characteristics being her fiery, witty, young, judgmental and independent nature. But these drastic changes fail to capture her mysteriousness and allure written in the novel. Some characters were edited out completely, some remained but were not as dynamic as in the novel, and others came to life on the screen (Judi Dench as Lady Catherine and Simon Woods as Mr. Bingley). This 2005 movie adaption holds little, to no similarities to the true plot or characterization of the actual novel (save simple plot overview of a conquering love story and character names), while the differences can be counted with each passing minute. Overall, the themes of ‘love conquering all’ and ‘love transcending all boundaries’, are still conveyed in the movie, as Elizabeth and Darcy finally triumph as a couple; him by overcoming his selfishness, or pride, and her by overcoming her harsh

Open Document