Samurai vs Knight: A Comparative Battle Analysis

621 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Samurai vs knight dbq

Samurai vs knight For year historians have argued over who would win in a one on one battle between the samurai and the knight. This essay gives you a clear view who would win and feels like you're back in time seeing the fighting to the death.While both of these historic figures have many similarities only one can win and i think it’s the samurai and this can be seen why in the essay below. The first way that samurais have an advantage is in armor and weapons.In document D it states many facts about the comparison of the samurai's armor and weapons to the knights. Terry bennett the author of document D claims, ¨A knight armor could weigh 40-60 pounds.¨ The knights had the disadvantage in the situation. For the suits they wear were so heavy the were not able to move as fast as the samurai giving the them the upper hand and a better attack.Another piece of evidence that supports my claim is in document D by Terry Bennett. It states, ¨As more powerful weapons such as , crossbows and longbows became more . In document E written by Yamaga Soko and Le Morte. It says, “He stands in physical readiness for any call to service...keeps weapons ready for use.”The samurais were always ready for battle for this gives them the advantage. The advantage was that they were always physically fit and prepared. Another piece of evidence was found in document F and G written by Christine de Pizan and Yamaoto Tsunetomo. This document claims , “Worse to put yourself in a position to be killed. A knight shouldn’t feel bound by such an oath” A knight didn't feel bound to keep an oath if their life was on the lie even though their religion say they should keep promises. Unlike the knight the samurai thought it was honorable to die if you lived by the code and did everything honorably. So in this case if the samurai ever got the knight in a position to die the knight might back out and lose the

Show More
Related

  • Analysis of Karl Friday's Samurai, Warfare and the State in Early Medieval Japan

    1648 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the book Samurai, Warfare and the State in Early Medieval Japan, Karl Friday focuses on war in early medieval Japan. A central thesis could be the political primacy of the imperial court. (Lamers 2005) This is the tenth through fourteenth centuries, before the samurai became prominent in Japan and were trying to form themselves into more of what we think of them today. Friday focuses on five aspects of war in his book; they are the meaning of war, the organization of war, the tools of war, the science of war, and the culture of war.

    Read More

  • Knights Vs Samurai Dbq Essay

    493 Words  | 1 Pages

    The first way that knights have an advantage is their armor. In document D written by the DBQ project It says that the knights sword was longer and stronger than that of the samurai. The knights would be able to fight from a farther distance, which allows them to strike the samurai without the samurai being able to hit them. Another piece of evidence that supports the claim is in document D, written by the DBQ project. It says, “Knights began to wear complete suits of plate armor, constructed from metal.” None of their body was exposed, whereas the samurai’s arms were exposed. Although armor is important, it isn't

    Read More

  • Dbq Essay On Samurai Or Knights

    631 Words  | 2 Pages

    The first way that samurais have an advantage is with their armor. In document D written by Terry Bennett it says that the knights have pure metal on them which weighs from 40-60 pounds.not only do the knights have tons of weight , but they also put armor on their

    Read More

  • Japanese Culture Dbq

    2205 Words  | 5 Pages

    Japanese Samurai-What did they wear? What weapon did they use? How were they physically and

    Read More

  • Samurai Dbq

    570 Words  | 2 Pages

    The first way that samurai have an advantage in battles are their weapons. In the History Channel Warriors Video by Terry Schappert, A Katana measures about 42 inches of length. The Katana has a slight curve in the blades used for slashing instead of stabbing. The handle is wrapped in sting ray skin and bound with silk or leather so the samurai won’t lose his grip. This shows that the Katana is a strong and is a stable weapon, perfect for a battle. Another piece of evidence that supports this claim is in the History Channel video Warriors Video written by Terry Schappert, A samurai uses the tip of the

    Read More

  • Samurai And Knights Similarities

    667 Words  | 2 Pages

    European knights wore armor that is made of metal. Due to the metal armor, their whole body was protected very well, and yet it was too heavy. In addition, it sometimes even limited knight’s vision and breathing ability because of the large protection of the helmet. In contrast, samurai’s armor was very light compared to the knight’s. “Samurai wore armor that is made of leather and steel laced together with silk cords.” Therefore, samurai was able to move quickly and agilely. However, samurai’s armor had less protection for their body, making them more vulnerable than knights. Their weapons had some differences as well. The primary weapons of knights were the long lance and the sword, but they also used poleaxe, dagger, and mace. The sword was always the foundational weapon of knights, whereas, the sword was not the one of the major weapons for samurais. Samurais primarily used the bow and arrow and the Yari that is, “One of the Japanese traditional blades in the form of a

    Read More

  • Japanese Katana

    1191 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...h their swords. […] All lived by a code that valued death over defeat. They were the samurai, the elite warrior class who ruled Japan for nearly 700 years, leaving an indelible mark on a land [Japan][…].” (O’Neill 101) This quote taken from a National Geographic publication is one of many others that speak of the tenacity of the samurai. Noble and aggressive, the samurai wield their swords with killing intent, confident that a simple strike from their blades can cause certain death to their foes. This was the primary reason the Katana is made in such a way. It is to create a weapon of absolute destruction. An implement comprising of aspects that symbolize elegance and devastation, the Katana not only is the finest weapon ever made, it is also a beautiful work of art (Yumoto n.p.).

    Read More

  • Samurai Rebellion In Japan

    1408 Words  | 3 Pages

    The entire Satsuma Rebellion from start to finish effectively got rid of the samurai class, proved to the country how they needed to modernize, lest what happened to the rebels could happen to them in general if another country decided to attack and set the path down toward, finally, an uninterrupted modern

    Read More

  • Bushido and Hagakure

    1520 Words  | 4 Pages

    A samurai knows that dying is just another part of life, and worrying about it is pointless. This lack of fear is bred into the samurai from birth, and stays with them for their entire lives. Whatever the daimyo tells a samurai to do, he will do it regardless of personal risk. By detaching himself from the thought of risk or of danger or death, and of the worry of morality, the samurai is able to remain more loyal to the daimyo. Complete loyalty is only possible through detachment from personal risk, morality, and thought.

    Read More

  • Samurai vs Knight

    1340 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many people often see little similarity between the country of Japan and Europe. However, there are actually several similarities between these two countries. In fact, Reischauer and Jansen note that Feudal Japan had departed so far from East Asian norms that it was more similar to medieval Europe than it was to China. Thus, the knight of Europe and the samurai of Japan despite a lack of contact with one another shared several common elements. This was a result of many similarities social and cultural influences experienced by the two distant countries.

    Read More

  • Kamakura Period Research Paper

    723 Words  | 2 Pages

    The samurai are a type of warrior class in Japan similar to the European knights. They were not only used as soldiers for combat in war but they also replaced the court government in terms of managing the local government. They pledged to keep the peace and stay loyal to their master. This is how they were used for most of history until the end of the Tokugawa period. Their rise all begins in the Kamakura period.

    Read More

  • Samurai And Knights Comparison Essay

    823 Words  | 2 Pages

    According to Document C “Japan Memoirs of a Secret Empire”, talks about how the samurai and knights both started training at a young ages. The knights started training at ages 4-5 a little earlier than the Samurai who started training at 6-7. The Samurai training only lasted until they were 14 unlike the knights whose training lasted until they were 21. Although, the samurai training was shorter they still covered all the important areas. They also had similar armor and both consisted of metal. The samurai had a little bit more movement in their arms, but the armor was used for the same reasons, protection. Document D by Terry Bennett says, “Samurai did not wear armor on their right arm so they could easily draw their bow.” These similarities were significant because without these things both classes would lose the battle every time, and if they didn’t have armor they would get killed, and these similarities is one of the reasons the two groups are so alike. Both of the classes were so a like that’s it’s hard to acknowledge their

    Read More

  • Comparison of Tokugawa and Manchu

    837 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the 17th and 18th centuries, the Chinese and Japanese faced much internal conflict, but while China faced a combination of economic setbacks and political weakness, the Japanese were riddled with wars along their countryside. First, the Chinese emperor was too weak in comparison to his bureaucracy, which ended up making most of the decisions for the last Ming dynasty emperor. This was due to the emperor’s realization that having a title as Son of Heaven did not mean he had all the power of the empire. Instead he lived a laid back life where the bureaucrats vied for power and wealth amongst themselves and he merely managed them. Like the Chinese, the Japanese also saw elites battling it out for power, but this time on the battlefield with armies of samurai. These battles put Japan in a period much like the Warring States period in early Chinese history, where families fought and fought for power almost endlessly. The political weakness in China contributed to its economic failure as well. With no force to manage to seas, pirates were free to raid trade ships and villages along the coast line, weakening the Chinese economy that relied on a transport system to supply the country. These two major forces led to China’s fragmentation and eventual takeover by the Manchu. In contrast, the battles happening in Japan were not harmful to the economy as much as they were in China. This is due to the fact that the Japanese daimyos were independent...

    Read More

  • Japan and Japanese Culture

    1178 Words  | 3 Pages

    There are many historical aspects of the Japanese, but the most interesting is the history of the Samurai. In Japans history war played a large role in the country. Controlling clans fought for parts of the land and overall control of the country. These clans were powerful families that resided in the country and who all wanted power and control of Japan for themselves. The families that would be in control were known as Shoguns. These shoguns would have warriors that fought for them if any of the other clan families would try to attack him in order to overthrow him and take his power from him. The Samurai followed a code that developed from Chinese beliefs when in battle. The Samurais code was known as the Bushido. This code was also known as “The Way of The Warrior” which was the main belief s...

    Read More

  • Japanese Samurai and European Knights: Were the Similarities Greater Than the Differences?

    1083 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...e respect, honor, and loyalty make this difference for me, but there is something to be said about the comparison. I find that the knights are very efficient, great warriors, and are very similar to samurai’s in a lot of ways. They both wear armor, they both train from a young age, and both are taught about honor, loyalty, and respect; but samurais are taught more effectively in their training, and the Japanese concepts were better. So to answer the essential question of this essay, I would say that there is certainly a large amount of similarities between the two warriors, but if you would consider the samurai’s skills that are better, or enhanced; to be differences, than I would have to conclude with no. The ‘differences’, are far too great in my opinion to say that the similarities are so great that they are almost the same, because they are very different indeed.

    Read More

More about Samurai vs Knight: A Comparative Battle Analysis

Open Document