Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Free essay on Gestalt theory
Essay about truth in documentaries
Free essay on Gestalt theory
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Free essay on Gestalt theory
A famous filmmaker and documentarian, Frederick Wiseman, once stated, “Of course there’s conscious manipulation! Everything about a movie is manipulation ... If you like it, it’s an interpretation. If you don’t like it, it’s a lie — but everything about these movies is a distortion.” There are many definitions for a documentary, but one thing is for sure: a documentary film is a representation of the world we already occupy. It stands for a particular view of the world, one we may never have encountered before even if the aspects of the world that is represented are familiar to us. John Grierson, a pioneering Scottish documentary maker, is credited with coining the term “documentary” in 1926 (Lake and Curthoys 151). Grierson’s principles of …show more content…
Hegel stated that “True reality lies beyond immediate sensation and the objects we see every day. Only what exists in itself is real.” According to “Introduction to Documentary” by Bill Nichols, every film is a documentary. Even the most imaginative of fictions gives evidence of the culture that created it and replicates the likenesses of the people who perform within it. Although the sense of an accurate story depicted within documentaries is sometimes reflected, documentaries are always skewed and incomplete. This is partly because of the way individuals mentally organize perceptions, and partly the agenda of the film itself presented by the author’s inherent bias. Filmmakers impart themes through imagery which lies in the way the audience makes sense out of what it sees through its own bias, history of myths, and the mechanics that affect the workings of the sense of Gestalt’s …show more content…
Gestalt is a psychology term which means unified whole. A tree trunk, branches, leaves and an apple are each separate objects. Yet all of these individual objects are components of an apple tree. However, when one thinks of an apple tree, they do not automatically think of those individual parts. Instead, the person is aware of the overall concept of an apple tree. Gestalt therapist believes that absolute and certain knowledge is a myth. When we realize the multiordinality of existence, we see that no things are exactly like other things. Everything is different in some unique ways from every other thing. Perceptions of similarity and comparison are invented. Comparison does not exist outside the human framework, and without comparison certain knowledge is impossible. The existing “knowledge” of the world is largely based upon such statements as this is bigger than that, less differentiated than those, better than this, more red than that, etc. When we compare, we establish relations. These relations come from the individual. A traditionalist would further assume that there is meaning in things and that a meaning exists. However, Fritz Perls, a German psychiatrist, claims that a meaning does not exist. According to him, a meaning is a creative process, a performance in the here and now. In every case a meaning is created by relating a figure, the foreground, to the background against which the figure
As documentary by its very nature introduces itself as factual, concerns exist as to where the boundary between the truth of subject and the fiction produced by its creator emerges. As anything that has been edited has by definition removed certain aspects and enhanced others, there must be at best an innocent naturally occurring bias formed from individual perception, and at worst purposefully manipulated misinformation. Through researching various sources, I intend to discover the difference (if any) between these two methods making factually based programmes, to determine any variables that lie in the ‘grey area’ between the two extremes, and to ascertain the diverse forms of conduct in which truth (and in turn documentary) can be presented to an audience, and to what effect?
...n a way that allows for analysis and interpretation of our society’s beginnings. The evidence presented builds a foundation for present-day societal practices and beliefs. Rhetorical devices involve the viewer more directly with the story and help to convince that this point of view is accurate and superior to other interpretations of events. The goal of non-fiction documentaries, according to Nichols, is to “instill belief. This is what aligns documentary with the rhetorical tradition, in which eloquence serves as a social as well as aesthetic purpose. We take not only pleasure from documentary, but direction as well” (2). Greeks argues on behalf of the Athenians, using historical evidence to present their side of the story, contending for the viewer’s belief. It provides us with information from the past, relating to the present, that could help us in the future.
Documentary has been heavily associated as a representation of the truth and reality due to its absence of fictional elements and control by the filmmaker (Chapman, 2009). It aims to entice the audience perception of the information presented as fundamental and legitimate (Beattie, 2004). With today's technology, the question of manipulated facts and proclaimed evidences presented in documentaries has heightened concerns in providing the audience with the truth and the real. Hence, with reference to the documentary on "Biggie and Tupac" (2002) directed by Nick Broomfield, we will explore how the documentary has managed to capture the real in terms of structure, style and modes of documentary.
Gestalt therapy is also similar to the psychoanalytic perspective because they both belief that different defense mechanisms influence a person’s relationship with others. It is also similar with the concept that dreams contain messages about a person’s life. Overall, this therapy wants the client to not look so much into what they “should” do, but to live fully without expectations or past habits being an influence (Daniels, 2005). Gestalt therapy does not explore the idea that a person’s thinking as something that needs to be changed (Brownell, 2010).
...ctual roles, or adding in exciting events that revise the storyline. These changes are beneficial to producers because they engage a large audience and generate massive profits. In contrast, they do not always have a positive effect on viewers. Although they are entertaining which is an important aspect of theatre culture, they also are often misguiding. Many spectators take movies at face value, without considering that they may not exactly qualify as primary source material. Even when an historical event is fabricated to teach or enhance a moral message, it still doesn’t compensate for bending the truth. Moviegoer’s may have a positive experience and gain some skewed historical perspective, perhaps better than what they knew before the movie, but they loose out on the truth and therefore, a genuine understanding of the historical event, and its significance.
The most concise way to characterize Gestalt psychology is to say that it deals with wholes and its given data are what have been called phenomena. It is because of their strong phenomenological orientation, which explains that wholes are experienced by conscious man and not in parts. For example, in perceiving a melody one gets a melodic form, not a string or a note, a unitary whole that is something more important than the total list of its parts. This is the way experience comes to man, organizing it into significant structured form.
Gestalt therapy is an experiential and humanistic form of therapy that embraces awareness, freedom and self-direction. Gestalt therapy focus on the “here and now” and allow clients to be more self-aware and to accept their feelings in order to ease distress. Gestalt theory maintains that wellness encompasses taking responsibility for one’s self and being connected to others.
According to the article “The Documentary Film and the New Media” states that a traditional classification of documentaries is related to the ratio in which the publishing material and cinematic substance of the film occur. (The Documentary Film and the New Media) Documentaries are usually shown as a one-way communication receptor to the audience, meaning that there is no interaction between what is being display and the audience. Documentary attempts to portray the impartial truth but instead take a partisan viewpoint and present the truth to the audiences, which ultimately results in social and emotional manipulations. (JFK Reloaded) Documentaries are like movies where is a story being told in a cinematic way.
Gestalt therapy can be described as process active, experiential work and can help shed light on suppressed feelings by helping us focus our awareness on feelings in the present. In working through negative the client can realize negative behavior patterns that may have become ingrained. Understanding the relationship between what we tell ourselves (bad gestalts) and negative thought processes and can become a part of the healing process. Through this form of therapeutic process, individuals can become better equipped to understand themselves and make better or healthier choices, creating a unity of mind, body and spirit.
Gestalt therapy is existential, phenomenological, and process-based approach created on the premise that individuals must be understood in the context of their ongoing relationship with the environment. Awareness, choice and responsibility are the cornerstone of practice (Corey, 2013).
In the film Capturing Reality there is a discussion about how nonfiction documentaries have this very real and raw feelings to them that cannot be captured in fiction films as well. While this is true, there is still the aspect of seeing maybe a stunt or a scene in a fiction film and the viewer understanding what might have had to go into that scene for it to be shot. That thought of thinking about how the scene was captured in the element of documentary that all films have. In reality at some point there had to be a team to design a scene where someone jumped off a tall structure. It is not like in a painting where an artist can paint the scene but no one having actually completed the scene in reality.
The definition of documentary varies between the personal opinions of filmmakers and critics. The term was first devised in 1926 by “The Moviegoer” a.k.a. John Grierson, a Scottish filmmaker and film critic when describing the film Moana as having “documentary value”. Grierson defined the term documentary as “creative treatment of reality”. His approach to documentary film was that the “original” actor and scene are superior to those that are fictitious.
The main goal (though this theory is not as goal-oriented as some other theories) of this theory is to expand a client’s awareness of their here and now. The attempt is to get the client to become more aware of what they are thinking, feeling, and doing. A big saying that is often said when thinking of gestalt therapy is that people are always
Gestalt and TA concept have been widely recognized for their role in psychotherapy. In this context, they provide the therapist with a framework which can be used to help their patients overcome mental problems and issues. As result, personal growth and development is likely to be attained. Their significance is illuminated by the fact that both of them encourage the patient’s ‘here and now’ awareness, which is fundamental in personal development (Brenner 2000).
2. Nichols, Bill. ‘Documentary Modes of Representation (The Observational Mode).’ Representing Reality: Issues and Concepts in Documentary. Bloomington & Indianapolis; Indiana University Press. 1991. 38-44