Court Observation

624 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Crime control vs. due process

Court visits are meaningful enrichments for law students to further understand the Australian court system through actual participation in court proceedings and understanding the justice system works is vital in deepening that knowledge. After attending the Brisbane Supreme court on 6th September 2017, I was able witness and observe a court hearing of some sort and during my confrontation of the supreme court I witnessed sentences and trials which were engaging and model cases at the most. When attending the court, it was visible to me that arrangement of the benches and all spaces drew a layout which distinguished the different roles amongst powers. The courtroom itself was not very large but was large enough for each voice that was spoken …show more content…

All legal procedures set by statute and court practice, including notice of rights, must be followed for everyone so that no prejudicial or unequal treatment will result. People who hold crime control values, on the other hand, believe that the most important function of the criminal justice system is containing and maintaining crime and that laws require strict enforcement. The due process advocate focuses on the need to protect the rights of the citizens and with the Hile hearing and my observation of this case I believe that a combination of both due process and crime control are present in this hearing. The court hearing which involved Shane Hile reflected a due process in a way as after the defendant announced that he was guilty of the crimes he committed, Judge Justice Bowskill took his confession into account later considering this when the decision of imprisonment was to be decided. The defendant did receive a fair trial in my opinion as the judge took into account all of the acts that he took to rid himself of his addiction to the use of cannabis and methamphetamine which had evidence from a doctor that proved that Hile was clean for that time between the sentence and him being custody. The judge has equally given him his rights and a fair case and this displays that due process model of justice which focuses on fundamental principle of fairness. It is not only the due process model of justice element that was reflected in the courtroom but also there was a image of crime

Show More
Related

  • Crime Control versus Due Process in Canada

    1075 Words  | 3 Pages

    One of the benefits of due process is demonstrated in the Belshaw case. The inquisitorial system of justice is based on crime control; the Swiss police had a hard time in Canada with Mr. Belshaw, because of his right to due process, under Canadian law. Both systems of justice share common beliefs, for example, they both look for proof beyond a reasonable doubt. In Canada we fight about facts and laws, where-as the inquisitorial system searches for the facts. The adversarial system has a separation of powers with the police, crown, defense, and the judge. It is quite different for the inquisitorial system of justice, the police do the arrest, then they present the facts to crown, which then decide if they have a case and turn over the evidence to the judge. The only problem is that the judge decides what will lead them to the truth. How any evidence was collected is irrelevant. In due process if the police obtain evidence and violate the law or a persons charter of rights and freedoms the judge will exclude the evidence from the hearing, even if it would help or prove that the person is guilty. These two systems of justice are generated in democratic traditions.

    Read More

  • Criminal Law: The Daniel Morcombe Case

    1231 Words  | 3 Pages

    Just and equitable legal outcomes to evaluate the case include of many expectations that may be met, the outcome of the case was discovered by fair trial which includes correct punishment theories and procedures, Justice Roslyn Atkinson met these through the trial also making it equitable because the punishment theories were applied to the offender Brett Peter Cowan. Punishment options and procedures in Queensland met the current needs of the society throughout this

    Read More

  • Fairness in the Australian Legal System

    1299 Words  | 3 Pages

    Nowadays, the Australian legal system has three powers, which are legislative, executive and judicial. Legislative power is in charge of making the laws; subsequently those laws will be passed to the executive power to administer the laws it...

    Read More

  • Australian Rule Of Law Essay

    1351 Words  | 3 Pages

    The merits of both the adversarial and inquisitorial system will be explored throughout this paper. The Australian rule of law best describes as all law should be applied equally and fairly. The five vital operations of the rule of law includes fairness, rationality, predictability, consistency, and impartially. The adversarial system adopts these operations by having a jury decide on the verdict and the judge being an impartial decision maker. In contrast, the inquisitorial system relies heavily on the judge. This can result in abusive power and bias of the judge when hearing evidence and delivering verdicts. The operations of the rule of law determine why the rule of law is best served by the adversarial system in Australia.

    Read More

  • Criminal Justice

    751 Words  | 2 Pages

    The governance of our present day public and social order co-exist within the present day individual. Attempts to recognize the essentiality of equality in hopes of achieving an imaginable notion of structure and order, has led evidence based practitioners such as Herbert Packer to approach crime and the criminal justice system through due process and crime control. A system where packer believed in which ones rights are not to be infringed defrauded or abused was to be considered to be the ideal for procedural fairness. “I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it.” Thomas Jefferson pg 9 cjt To convict an individual because proper consideration was not taken will stir up social unrest rather then it’s initial intent, when he or she who has committed the crime is not punished for their doings can cause for a repetition and even collaboration with other’s for a similar or greater crime.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Court Observation

    784 Words  | 2 Pages

    For the court observation assignment, I visited the Tolland County Courthouse. I went to court on Tuesday April 4th, 2017 from 11am to 12:30pm. The matters I observed in the courtroom regarded a restraining order from an ex-girlfriend to her ex-boyfriend. The details involved in the case included the welfare of their three-month-old baby and the custody battle.

    Read More

  • Courts and Power Relations

    1420 Words  | 3 Pages

    The architecture of the courtroom establishes clear power disparities within the courtroom setting. The physical dimensions of Courtroom 5.1 were organised in such a way that the hierarchal nature of the court is visually clear from the moment you step into the room. The stratification of power amongst the courtroom actors is displayed through the ‘structural elevation’ of the seating (Carlen, 1976, pp. 50). The magistrate is seated at the uppermost level at the bench facing the defendant, solicitors and public gallery. This particular positioning demonstrates pre-eminence which allows com...

    Read More

  • The Jury and Its Role in the Courts of Trial

    1507 Words  | 4 Pages

    The jury plays a crucial role in the courts of trial. They are an integral part in the Australian justice system. The jury system brings ordinary people into the courts everyday to judge whether a case is guilty or innocent. The role of the jury varies, depending on the different cases. In Australia, the court is ran by an adversary system. In this system “..individual litigants play a central part, initiating court action and largely determining the issues in dispute” (Ellis 2013, p. 133). In this essay I will be discussing the role of the jury system and how some believe the jury is one of the most important institutions in ensuring that Australia has an effective legal system, while others disagree. I will evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of a jury system.

    Read More

  • Police Authority vs Individual Rights

    1076 Words  | 3 Pages

    The overall basis for a democratic society is freedom. We stress that freedom allows us to be individualistic. Herbert L. Packer, a law professor, charted out two ideas in our criminal justice system. The idea or crime control and due process are ideally two separate entities, but have been found in our criminal justice system to overlap (Barkan, 2012). Due to the fact that these two ideas overlap, causes tension within our democratic society. These ideas cause there to be a double edge sword. As stated in our textbook, “the more crime control we want, the less due process we have; the more due process we have, the less crime control we can expect.” (Barkan, 2012). Ideally, we would like to live in a society where everyone is treated equally regardless of race, gender, social class, etc. However, police have the difficult task of making sure arrests are made unbiased.

    Read More

  • The Fairness Of The Jury System In The British Judicial System

    2140 Words  | 5 Pages

    Guidelines and principles are set out as ideals, but these are easily subject to discretion, prejudice and errors at any stage (Greene and Heilbrun, 2011). The due process model aims to safeguard the defendant at each stage within the process. However, the conflicting crime control model encourages policing and guilty verdicts, whatever the repercussions (Newburn, 2007). This contest is marked throughout the CJS, “...the more we learn about the Is of the criminal process, the more we are instructed about its Ought,” (Packer, 1968, p. 150). For example, few suspects receive proficient legal defence, yet this is a contradiction to the ideological proviso. It may be interesting to research if juries have experienced and recognised any unfairness within trials. Too often the ideologies of criminal justice, due process and crime control result in miscarriages of justice (Newburn, 2007). When rigid regulatory processes result in bureaucracy, this can only cause more drain on

    Read More

  • Circuit court

    795 Words  | 2 Pages

    I attended the Circuit Court at 140 Blountville Bypass Blountville, TN on April 24th, 2014. I sat in on Judge Robert Montgomery’s court. Judge Montgomery started court promptly at 9:00 a.m. After going through the metal detectors, I asked the officer working the metal dictator if I could ask to sit in on a criminal court that was going on that morning. He then directed me to the printed docket on the table in the waiting area. The docket is the official schedule of proceedings in lawsuits pending in a court of law. Courtroom 1 had seven pages of cases ranging from violations of probation to rape of a child and Courtroom 2 had one jury trial case of a vehicular homicide that finished the day before. I walked into the administration office and asked if I could get a copy of the docket for when I sit in on court that day for my Legal Process class. I waited until the bailiff called everyone in, and I went in as well and took a seat in the front row in the middle next to another classmate. After waiting a few minutes the bailiff tells everyone to rise while Judge Robert Montgomery entered the courtroom to begin the proceedings.

    Read More

  • Herbert Packer's Due Process, Due Process And Crime Control

    1205 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1968, Herbert Packer was a Stanford University law professor who constructed two models of criminal process, due process and crime control. The due process model was Packer’s view that criminal defendants should be presumed innocent, courts must protect suspects’ rights, and there must be come limits placed on police powers. The crime control model is a model that emphasizes law and order and argues that every effort must be made to suppress crime, and to try, convict, and incarcerate offenders. Packer’s crime control model suggested that most cases ended in guilty please or withdrawals. In contrast, his due process model suggested that cases that go to trail and are appealed were the most influential. The due process and crime control model differentiate in

    Read More

  • The Australian Legal System

    1294 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Australian Legal System has a rich and detailed history dating from 1066. Law is made in Parliament. We have four sources of law and three courts with different jurisdictions that interpret the law when giving out justice. Important doctrines act as the corner-stones of our legal system. There is a procedure in the courts for making appeals. Separation of powers exists between officials in the courts, the parliament and the Executive. Everyone in Australia is treated equally under the Rule of Law, no matter their office or status. The Law is always changing as society changes, but it can never be perfect and cannot please everyone.

    Read More

  • It’s Time to Remove Cameras from the Courtroom

    1602 Words  | 4 Pages

    Some people say that by watching the court system in action, what once was very unknown and unfamiliar, has now become familiar and useful in helping people become more knowledgeable of what happens inside courtrooms. Most people have not been in a courtrooms and only have the perspective that T.V. gives to them. Now they are able to see what really goes on and now can better understand and relate.

    Read More

  • The Work of the Magistrates Court and Magistrates

    1357 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Work of the Magistrates Court and Magistrates In the legal system there are many different types of courts. This essay talks about the Magistrates Courts and the Magistrates themselves. The office of magistrate dates back to the 12th century when Richard 1 appointed "keepers of the peace". They have performed judicial functions since the 13th century and the term, justice of the peace was being used as far back as 1361.

    Read More

More about Court Observation

Open Document