Comparing Zeffirelli's Romeo And Juliet

1117 Words3 Pages

There have been many different portrayals of William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, two of the most famous being Zeffirelli’s 1968 film and Luhrmann’s 1996 film. Of the two depictions, Zeffirelli’s deviates the least from Shakespeare’s intentions. In the 1968 version of Romeo and Juliet, Romeo seems completely overcome by love during the balcony scene. This is congruent with how one would imagine him in the play. It is not common for one to say another is the sun unless they are completely infatuated. To be the sun is to be the center of the universe; therefore, Juliet is the center of Romeo’s world and thoughts. One would believe Shakespeare additionally intended Romeo to be completely entranced by Juliet. This is shown when Romeo says, “She …show more content…

A reader or viewer of the play may imagine Romeo gazing moony-eyed, totally focused on Juliet as he says this, and he was in the 1968 movie. Romeo’s extreme enthusiasm is apparent in his impassioned tone and raised arms as he says “love’s light wings”(Shakespeare 96). As Juliet voices her many concerns, Romeo speedily eases her worries. On the other hand, the 1990’s Romeo seems more eager to see Juliet without her knowledge. Initially, he speaks his lines in a more hushed way and is actively hiding from Juliet. To hide from someone you want to marry seems unusually, especially for bold Romeo. Romeo is a go-getter, and not an observer on the sidelines. Silently creeping is an activity of stalkers in one-way love, not individuals with a mutual love. Later, Juliet sees Romeo and they converse. Smoothly whispering, Romeo is more reserved in the 1996 rendition than the other film. Seeming more serious, the Romeo of the 1996 film abandons the brash personality of Shakespeare’s Romeo. Overall, Romeo’s characterization has greater precision in the 1960’s version of Romeo and Juliet than the …show more content…

Zeffirelli’s film had Romeo and Juliet blocked far away from each other. At first, Juliet is high up on a balcony and Romeo is on the ground, many meters away. Then, Romeo comes closer as he listens to Juliet and when he converses with her, gradually increasing the proximity of the couple. Romeo must overcome many obstacles, such as trees and walls, to reach Juliet. This can be seen as how Romeo and Juliet were originally strangers, and now they have grown close despite the many obstacles in their way. Many writers and directors try to place hidden meanings in character blocking; thus, it makes sense that a famous writer like Shakespeare would intend for the blocking to be such. Blocking Juliet on a balcony seems to be a purposeful choice to keep the lovers separated. After all, it is noticeably more dramatic to place longing, lusty lovers in the star-crossed, “so close and yet so far away” style. Both the lovers want to be together, but they cannot quite meet. In Luhrmann’s 1996 film adaption of Romeo and Juliet, Romeo and Juliet are blocked extremely closely. One would definitely not envision it that way. Romeo follows Juliet in close pursuit, literally inches away from her as she soliloquizes. Romeo has not been portrayed as one who would creep after someone. Being an impulsive individual, one would assume Romeo is more likely to run toward Juliet

Open Document