Compare And Contrast Leah's Symptoms And The Autopsy Findings Consistent With Shaken Baby Syndrome

1909 Words4 Pages

1) Are Leah’s symptoms and the autopsy findings consistent with shaken baby syndrome? Explain your answer.

ANS: Leah, a 4 month old was found to suffer from brain hemorrhage. She was claimed to be fussy and vomited for three days straight. She also suffered from Subdural Hematoma as well as brain swelling. According to her autopsy report, there were multiple hemorrhages in Leah’s brain and right eye. All these symptoms as well as the autopsy report are consistent with Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS).

Shaken Baby Syndrome occurs, when a baby is violently shaken. Not when bouncing a baby or shaking the baby lightly or even when a baby accidentally falls down. The neck muscles, nerves and blood vessels of a baby are unable to take the extreme force …show more content…

The Millers wanted a daughter badly after having 7 sons. And when they had one, they were extremely happy. There was no complaint of child abuse. This suggests that there were no previous cases of child abuse in the Miller Family. All the kids were fine and none of them had unnatural complications to deal with.

Lt. Olson, police officer, claimed to have seen bruises on one of Leah’s brothers. The boy kind of outgrew it. This matches the claim of Dr. Naswani. He claimed that Leah might have had some kind of genetic liver disease. In the Amish families, genetic diseases are quite common since they don’t have much knowledge about modern medical science and practice things that causes them to pass down the diseases without trying to prevent it. Genetic liver diseases inhibit the natural functioning of blood clotting factors. Thus weakening the body and causing easy bruising.

Leah’s brother was active and got bruised easily when he was young. Similarly, Leah, a 4 month old also had the same problem. This suggests that the Millers might have had some kind of genetic liver disease that was passed down to Leah and her brother. Her brother was able to outgrow it but poor Leah’s situation was too severe to outgrow

More about Compare And Contrast Leah's Symptoms And The Autopsy Findings Consistent With Shaken Baby Syndrome

Open Document