Compare And Contrast All Summer In A Day And Harrison Bergeron

438 Words1 Page

At some point or another in everyone’s life they get jealous of someone. When some people get jealous they try to do anything they can, to be the same as other people. Sometimes what they do can hurt others. In the story “All summer in a day” by Ray Bradbury the students lock a girl in the closet so she can't see the sun that she has been waiting years to see. The story “Harrison Bergeron” written by Kurt Vonnegut jr. handicaps are given to people who can do something better than someone else. Through these two stories the author shows jealousy can make a person blind of others. Kurt Vonnegut jr. shows throughout this story that jealousy can make a person blind of others. When George was watching the ballerinas he noticed they were “burdened with sash weights and bags of birdshot,” the ballerinas are handicapped because people were jealous of them. The government did not think of how it would hurt the ballerinas. Hazel was talking to George “ George began to think . . . but a twenty-one gun salute in his head stopped that . . . George was white and trembling and tears stood on the rims of his red eyes.” George is handicapped to stop him from thinking. The government does not know how bad it hurts to have the sound going off every twenty seconds. …show more content…

The other kids are jealous Margot remembers what the sun is like and they don't so they say she is wrong. The kids are making Margot upset. When all the kids came inside after it started raining again “Their faces were solemn and pale. They looked at their hands and feet, their faces down.” The kids finally realised that Margot was right. They are guilty because Margot was locked in the closet while they were outside having

Show More
Related

  • Identity In Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron

    536 Words  | 2 Pages

    Kurt Vonnegut writes, “George was toying with the vague notion that maybe dancers shouldn’t be handicapped. But he didn’t get very far with it before another noise in his ear radio scattered his thoughts” (Vonnegut 70). This quote brings out the theme in many different ways. First, the quote mentions how the government is keeping George from thinking any deep thoughts, they do not want him to think that the handicaps are bad. To prevent the human race from overthrowing the government they just interrupt everyone's brain. The government is also doing major harm to themselves and the whole country because the brilliant people could possibly think of cures for rare diseases and other world conflicts, but they can not even think past what their own name is. Overall, every person should be able to use their brain without every single chain of thought being disconnected by the

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast All Summer In A Day And Harrison Bergeron

    519 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the story it says, “About how it was like a lemon, it was, and how hot . . . I think the sun is a flower, That blooms for just one hour.” This connects back to my idea that outcasts are sometimes the solution to society’s problems. Due to this quote, Margot’s statement about the sun is what makes her an outsider in the eyes of society. Later in the passage, it is revealed that Margot’s statement about the sun was correct and solved the problem of what the children think the sun resembles.

    Read More

  • Inequality In Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron

    571 Words  | 2 Pages

    At the beginning of the story we are introduced to George and Hazel who are an ordinary couple that consequently suffer from handicaps. They are recalling the time when their son, Harrison Bergeron, was taken from his home by the handicapper general. It was an unhappy thought “but George and Hazel couldn't think about it very hard” (Vonnegut 1) due to the mental radio that separated the two from regular functioning emotions. Although Hazel was not affected by the handicap itself, it became a societal norm to act almost robot-like. This tendency provoked Hazel to the point where “there were tears on [her] cheeks, but she'd forgotten…what they were about” (1). The loss of emotion has taken the citizens’ entitlement to experience not only happiness and love but also sadness and grief. These are all traits that people need in order to operate like normal human beings. When George and Hazel witnessed the traumatic murder of their son on television, George automatically forgets due to his mental radio. Hazel, however, reacts to the frightening scene in front of her but forgets the occurrence just as fast. When asked by George what she was crying about the only thing she can recall is that the incident was “something real sad on television” (6). In consequence of the failure to express emotion, the difficulty of evolving society

    Read More

  • Harrison Bergeron Rhetorical Analysis

    532 Words  | 2 Pages

    Moreover, within the text, the significance of symbolism is apparent as there are indications of the presence of different handicaps. Notably, those with above average physical attributes and above average intelligence are required by law to wear handicaps. Thus, the application and enforcement of handicaps are metaphors for sameness, because individuals with advantageous traits are limited and refrained from using their bodies and brains to their maximum abilities, for that is considered to be unfair to those who does not possess the same level of capability. Several main examples of handicaps includes “...47 pounds of birdshot… ear radios… spectacles intended to make [one] not only half blind but to [provide] whanging headaches”. Therefore, the intensity of the handicaps is a sign of the government’s seriousness in the field of administering disabilities onto their own citizens. Unfortunately, in order to maintain the sickly “equality”, the people are stripped off of their freedom. When announcers are unable to speak properly, and ballerinas are unable to dance properly, and musicians unable to perform properly, and people are unable to formulate thoughts properly — it is not a matter of equality, but a matter how low society

    Read More

  • Theme Of Harrison Bergeron

    740 Words  | 2 Pages

    Harrison Bergeron’s mother, Hazel Bergeron, is the definition of the Handicapper General’s “normal” and model for enforced equality. Everyone must be leveled and thereby oppressed to her standards. Hazel’s husband, George Bergeron, is no exception. “‘I’d think it would be real interesting, hearing all the different sounds,’ said Hazel, a little envious. ‘All the things they think up.’” (Vonnegut 910). George suffers from his own comically ludicrous mental handicap. The fact that this incites jealousy in Hazel reaffirms the artificial equality Vonnegut ridicules. The author satirizes oppression in American society through his depictions of misery and restraint exhibited in his characters’ ordeals. “The different times that George is interrupted from thinking, and his inner monologue is cut, we have a sort of stopping his having dialogue with himself. So he can’t have a unique personality, which itself involves his worldviews” (Joodaki 71). Not being able to know oneself epitomizes

    Read More

  • Bad Judgment In All Summer In A Day By Ray Bradbury

    635 Words  | 2 Pages

    One possible main idea is that this short story is about how actions lead to regret. Support for this theme comes at the end of the story, where the children are described as stakes driven into the ground. This regret came after the children denied Margot the ability to be out in the sun after it had finally come out. Another theme is that the allure of rare things or events can induce powerful emotions. Support for this is present during the end of the story, where the kids run around in the sun and experience joy like never before. A final argument for the theme can be made of the idea that people never realize how much things are worth until they are gone. Evidence for this theme takes form in the shape of a depressed Margot, who is always sad and moping in the story, something that the author says is because she misses the sun on Earth. Although all of these themes have some support, none of have enough evidence and backing to be the true

    Read More

  • The Lack Of Equality In Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron

    1098 Words  | 3 Pages

    Taking a look at several of the characters in this story is a key way to see the impact that a lack of individuality can have. The first characters talked about in the story are George and Hazel Bergeron. Hazel is a very average human, but George on the other hand has several above average attributes. His intelligence is hindered by a radio that plays obnoxious sounds every few seconds. He also carried a bag of birdshot around his neck. However, the main handicap he deals with is the sounds. The transmitter destroys his ability to think and analyze events and ideas. One example is shown while they are watching the heavily handicapped and extremely average ballerinas. “George was toying with the vague notion that maybe dancers shouldn’t be handicapped. But he didn’t get very far with it before another noise in his ear radio scattered his thoughts.” (Vonnegut 193) This quotation continues to show how the government is now in an all-powerful place. Anyone with the mental power to realize that the government was wrong would have a distraction that would make them abandon the thought. George and Hazel are the biggest example in the story about the heart breaking measures the government has taken against its citizens. They watch their son get taken away, are sad for a bit, and then forget about it like it was an unimportant event that happens every day. They see their son on television, notice it for a few seconds, and then due to loud noises and incompetency they forget about it. The most heartbreaking event of the story is when Harrison is shot by the Handicap General. George returns to the kitchen and notices Hazel had been crying. He questions her about it and she does not know why she cried in the first place. Vonnegut shows here how complete equality takes people away from their humanity and their ability to be human beings. Characterization plays a key role in several of the other

    Read More

  • Metaphors In Harrison Bergeron

    776 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Tears stood on the rims of his red eyes.” George hears a sharp painful buzzer go off in his headset handicap, which makes him inevitable cry and tremble. This noise is meant to break up George’s mind so he cannot think properly. This restriction enforced by the government allows the government to control it’s citizen’s thoughts. Although it brings pain and misery to George, it does prevent him from forming rebellious thoughts against the government and its system. George, as well as the people imprisoned by these handicaps are incapable of experiencing normal daily activities such as dancing, which is something the ballerinas have trouble doing in this story due to the handicaps. George’s reaction to the painful buzzer results in him to “turn white and tremble” which shows the level of misery the handicaps can impose on someone. Instead of equalizing the society, the handicaps mainly take away the people’s freedom and free will which causes their happiness to dwindle. The handicaps not only restrict the people’s thoughts and actions but also their emotional, physical, and mental

    Read More

  • hARRISON BERGERON

    787 Words  | 2 Pages

    Would a regular citizen enjoy being as skilled of a dancer as a ballerina? Or as intelligent as the next guy? In Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.’s story of Harrison Bergeron, handicaps, such as small radio’s that blast sharp sounds are used to prevent individuals from having more intellectual thoughts than others. The year is 2081 and everyone is equal in every which way. Handicapped George and his wife Hazel are watching a ballerina performance. The show is interrupted by an announcement to watch out for their son, Harrison Bergeron as he is under-handicapped and dangerous. The conflict begins when Harrison enters the studio and declares he is Emperor. He finds his ballerina Empress, and dances with her before being shot and killed by Handicapper General Diana, resolving the conflict. This event is a more specific account of Harrison’s conflict with the current society as a whole, which is reflected through the use of theme, symbolism, and point of view.

    Read More

  • The Giver And Harrison Bergeron

    945 Words  | 2 Pages

    shows this theme by creating a society where extraordinary people are handicapped in order to maintain an extreme version of equality. The setting Vonnegut creates is a place where the government makes the extraordinary people wear physical and mental handicaps in order to keep everyone the same. “They were equal every which way. Nobody was smarter than anybody else. Nobody was better looking than anybody else. Nobody was stronger or quicker than anybody else.” (Vonnegut 1). This shows that in this society, the government eliminates all differences to keep everyone exactly the same. Desperate measures are being taken to make sure that everyone is equal. Later in the text, during a ballet show, the author describes the ballerinas as “... burdened with sashweights and bags of birdshot, and their faces were masked, so that no one, seeing a free and graceful gesture or a pretty face, would feel like something the cat drug in.” (Vonnegut 2). This reveals how the government is stopping them from reaching their full potential and how everyone is becoming identical. This story was created to show how if the people in the society become the same, talent and specialty will meet its

    Read More

  • The Veldt Theme

    473 Words  | 1 Pages

    Margot goes to school with classmates that resent her. They hate her for having seen the sun, something they wanted so badly. This jealousy led to an overwhelming hatred that they were reminded of any time they saw her. Her classmates let their hatred take over and they locked her in a closet as revenge for the pain she had caused them all. But unlike Wendy and Peter from The Veldt, Margot was affected negatively from her classmateś actions.

    Read More

  • Harrison Bergeron Conformity

    570 Words  | 2 Pages

    Anyone who is considered above average mentally or physically, is forced to be handicapped. The short story is centralized around a small family consisting of a mom, dad, and son. The mother, Hazel, is exceptionally average, so she does not wear any handicaps, whereas the dad, George, is an exceptional human being and is forced to have his strength and intelligence handicapped. The 7 foot tall son, Harrison, is immensely strong, beautiful and smart. The story begins with Hazel and George watching a news story about their son, Harrison, who escaped from jail, interrupting a dance. He removed his handicaps and danced beautifully with a ballerina, revealing his exceptionality; Harrison was then shot by the Handicapper General, and everyone who witnessed Harrison’s revolt had their memories erased. After witnessing the murder of their son, Hazel and George expressed immense sadness, but could not remember why, so they went on with their

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Harrison Bergeron

    661 Words  | 2 Pages

    In both Harrison Bergeron and today’s society, people struggle with equality. As shown in Harrison Bergeron the pushing of equality causes consequences. Equality is being pushed onto everyone by having handicaps to make them sure that no one person is better than another. Equality can also cause any type of hurt, both physical and mental. Physical hurt is what occurs with George. George is

    Read More

  • All Summer In A Day

    1049 Words  | 3 Pages

    The story starts off with these children bullying Margot out of jealousy of how she was able to remember and picture the sun, and because she was quiet and continued to allow it to happen. For instance, “when the class sang songs about happiness and life and games her lips barely moved. Only when they sang about the sun and the summer did her lips move as she watched the drenched windows.” It’s clear how this quote shows that her memory of the sun was

    Read More

  • Analysis Of All Summer In A Day By Ray Bradbury

    508 Words  | 2 Pages

    They do this because when the sun is supposed to appear it is almost a minute off, so the children think that nothing will happen. They lock her away because they got their hopes so high, they were so ready for that sweet sunshine. Then they thought that there was nothing so they lock her in the closet. But then the sun does come out and the children all have fun, with one exception: Margot is in the closet.

    Read More

More about Compare And Contrast All Summer In A Day And Harrison Bergeron

Open Document