Beethoven Engelsmann Analysis

2147 Words5 Pages

285 The four ages of Beethoven metaphor into line with the age of modern warfare, Engelsmann closes his article with the following formulation, laying down the law of his title with stentorian capitals: He who is capable of understanding all [Beethoven's] remaining works as having grown in the same sense, will be able -with me - to form this law: EVERY SONATA OF BEETHOVEN IS DEVELOPED, IN ALL ITS PH RASES, SECTIONS, AND THEMES, FROM A SINGLE MAIN THEME OR MAIN MOTIVE.42 If Engelsmann's words articulate a directive that was to keep motive hunters happily motivated for decades to come, the inception and rise of Schenkerian depth analysis was to enjoy a more widespread credibility and respect, at least among Anglo-American scholars. For with …show more content…

Eggebrecht's words, above all, emphasize our sense of distance from Beethoven. They signal a loss of faith in an immediate connection to Beethoven, a recognition that what we have been clinging to all these years is a myth, a construction. What happens when this connection is lost? We might be tempted to answer that it is no longer Beethoven himself who is the subject of our collective scholarly archeology but the Beethoven myth. If we can no longer hope to reach the master himself with our efforts, we can at least console ourselves with the fascinations of two hundred rich years of reception history. Following Eggebrecht, authors as diversely motivated and trained as Ulrich Schmitt, Martin Geck, David B. Dennis, Tia DeNora, and myself have traced this history, with its often nefarious appropriations and constructions of Beethoven. 56 And yet there is much work that continues to flourish in the study of Beethoven's sketches, the clarification and interpretation of biographical issues, as well as interpretative studies that purport to get closer to Beethoven's actual compositional intentions. Thus it is not simply the case that we have collectively forgone the study of Beethoven …show more content…

Beethoven is now often studied 289 The four ages of Beethoven as a cogent element of history-bound cultural practice: William Kinderman, Thomas Sipe, and Maynard Solomon, for example, have argued that Beethoven's music projects certain Schillerian aesthetic values;57 the work of Adorno - who came to light for Anglo-American musicology in the late 1970s, thanks to the brave efforts of Rose Rosengard Subotnik - linked Beethoven with Hegel;58 and some of my own work has situated Beethoven within the value system of the Goethezeit as a whole. All of these authors attempt to find Beethoven within the image of his culture, to bring his music back into the arena of ,cultural practice after years of formalist exemption from the perceived contamination of history. Another symptom of our age is the way in which we attempt to reconstruct an image of Beethoven in the fashion of a mosaic, as we collectively fill in the picture of Beethoven's personal and compositional paraphernalia, the contents of his pockets, the types of paper he wrote on,

Open Document