Analysis Of The Deer At Providencia

869 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Message of annie dillard an american childhood

Life’s Agony[SM1]
In Annie Dillard’s narrative, “The Deer at Providencia,” she reveals her awareness of and confusion regarding suffering by paralleling human and animal anguish and dignity. On a trip to Ecuador with a North American group in the village of Providencia, Dillard witnesses the suffering of a small deer. Her lack of reaction to the suffering deer stuns the travelers; however, Dillard intentionally conditions her awareness of suffering by encountering an article about a burn victim daily in America (M.S. 4) Posting the article on her mirror, Dillard strengthens her realistic perception regarding suffering and divulges her confusion regarding the ambiguity, inevitability, and vulnerability of agony for all beings. Recounting[SM2] …show more content…

Dillard’s inquisitive tone reflects her strife to understand the incomprehensible suffering of others. Confused about the randomness of suffering, Dillard asks, “Will someone please explain to Alan McDonald in his dignity, to the deer at Providencia in his dignity, what is going on? And mail me the carbon” (Dillard, 1984, p.102). (M.S. 8) Dillard indicates her confusion by directly asking for “someone to please explain what is going on.” Dillard’s tone demands for someone to “mail her the carbon” if they discover the answer. She does not phrase her sentence as a question, but as an imperative statement. (M.S. 3) Dillard also implements a tone of exasperation amongst the North American travelers. The travelers expect Dillard to attempt to rescue the deer or at least appear distraught; instead, the travelers perceive Dillard’s lack of reaction as disconnected. However, Dillard’s reaction likewise reveals her intense knowledge of the deer’s suffering as inevitable. Dillard addresses the travelers by asking, “Gentlemen of the city, what surprises you? That there is suffering here, or that I know it” (Dillard, 1982, p.100)? Dillard’s defends her awareness of suffering by straightforwardly affirming her understanding of affliction by her expression, “or that I know it.” Dillard’s tone of inquisition and exasperation throughout her story verifies her …show more content…

(M.S. 5) Dillard and the other tourists watch a feeble deer struggle to escape from a trap. In her narrative, Dillard depicts the deer’s suffering, “The rope twanged; the tree leaves clattered; the deer’s free foot beat the ground” (Dillard, 1982, p.99). Dillard precisely structures the sentence for a verb to follow each noun such as, ‘the rope’, ‘the tree’, and ‘the deer’. The verbs following each noun, separated by a semicolon, includes, ‘twanged;’ ‘clattered;’ and ‘beats.’ This sentence structure decelerates the flow of the passage; therefore, stressing the deer’s slow, long, and painful suffering. Dillard continues to emphasize the deer’s agony to portray her awareness of its suffering. Dillard recalls, “Its hip jerked; its spine shook. Its eyes rolled; ...” (Dillard, 1982, p.99). Dillard’s parallel sentence structure begins by referring to the subject as ‘its’ and ends each sentence predicate with a verb such as, ‘jerked’, ‘shook’, and ‘rolled’. Dillard’s repetition of the subject intensifies the misery the deer experiences. Dillard’s description of the deer also leads to her confusion regarding the unpredictably of suffering; because the deer’s anguish contrasts her comfortable, yet vulnerable

Show More
Related

  • The Grotesque Gem of the American South: Different Approaches to the Okefenokee Swamp

    949 Words  | 2 Pages

    With an evident attempt at objectivity, the syntax of Passage 1 relies almost entirely on sentences of medium length, uses a few long sentences for balance, and concludes with a strong telegraphic sentence. The varying sentence length helps keep the readers engaged, while also ensuring that the writing remains succinct and informative. Like the varying sentence length, the sentence structures vary as complex sentences are offset by a few scattered simple sentences. The complex sentences provide the necessary description, and the simple sentences keep the writing easy to follow. Conversely, Passage 2 contains mostly long, flowing sentences, broken up by a single eight word sentence in the middle. This short sentence, juxtaposed against the length of the preceding and following sentences, provides a needed break in the text, but also bridges the ideas of the two sentences it falls between. The author employs the long sentences to develop his ideas and descriptions to the fullest extent, filling the sentences with literary elements and images. Coupled...

    Read More

  • The Symbolism of Death in Alistair McLeod’s "The Lost Salt Gift of Blood"

    697 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Alistair McLeod’s collection of short stories the Lost Salt Gift of Blood; death seems to be a constant companion. Death is important and perhaps even symbolic in this collection of short stories. It is important because it has the power to affect people and relationships, invokes freedom and even predetermines ones future, through the death of animal’s people and the impending death of others.

    Read More

  • Deer In Wesselman Woods

    244 Words  | 1 Pages

    There are too many deer in the Wesselman Woods. The deer have eaten all the flowers and other flora. There have also been 8 car crashes involving deer, this imposes a dangerous threat to the civilians of Evansville. The deer have been invading people’s yards and eating their gardens. The deer are causing many problems that can’t be solved until the deer population is reduced.

    Read More

  • Leslie Marmon Silko's In The Combat Zone

    898 Words  | 2 Pages

    If the author's father didn’t give her the chance to hunt, and the opportunity to take care of herself and not be afraid, her predicaments would end with probable unfortunate circumstances just like mine. Thankfully her father’s knowledge and words of

    Read More

  • The Lovely Bones Rhetorical Analysis

    995 Words  | 2 Pages

    Photographs capture the essence of a moment because the truth shown in an image cannot be questioned. In her novel, The Lovely Bones, Alice Sebold uses the language of rhetoric to liberate Abigail from the façade of being a mother and spouse in a picture taken by her daughter, Susie. On the morning of her eleventh birthday, Susie, awake before the rest of the family, discovers her unwrapped birthday present, an instamatic camera, and finds her mother alone in the backyard. The significance of this scene is that it starts the author’s challenge of the false utopia of suburbia in the novel, particularly, the role of women in it.

    Read More

  • Flannery O’Conner: Deep South Scribe

    979 Words  | 2 Pages

    Dead at the age of thirty nine years young, Flannery O’Conner lost her fight with lupus, but had won her place as one of America’s great short story writers and essayist. Born in Savannah, Georgia, within the borders of America’s “Bible Belt”, she is raised Catholic, making O’Connor a minority in the midst of the conservative Protestant and Baptist faiths observed in the Southern United States. In the midst of losing her father at the age fifteen, followed by her diagnosis and struggle with the same physical illness that took him, as well as her strong unwavering faith in the Catholic Church are crucial components of O’Connor’s literary style which mold and guide her stories of loss, regret, and redemption. Flannery O’Connor’s writings may be difficult to comprehend at times, but the overall theme of finding grace, sometimes in the midst of violence or tragedy, can be recognized in the body of her works. O’Connor’s stories are written about family dysfunction, internal angst towards life or a loved one, and commonly take place on a farm, plantation or a family home in the American South. Her stories of ethical and moral challenge blur the boundaries between her Catholic faith and values, which also include the values of the other religious faiths surrounding her in her youth, simply writing of the pain and struggles which people from all walks of life commonly share.

    Read More

  • Literary Analysis Of Mary Hood's 'How Far She Went'

    895 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Why? Why? The girl gasped, as they lunged down the old deer trail. Behind them they could hear shots, and glass breaking as the men came to the bogged car” (Hood 414). It is at this precise moment Hood’s writing shows the granddaughter’s depletion of her naïve nature, becoming aware of the brutality of the world around her and that it will influence her future. Continuing, Hood doesn’t stop with the men destroying the car; Hood elucidated the plight of the two women; describing how the man shot a fish and continued shooting the fish until it sank, outlining the malicious nature of the pair and their disregard for life and how the granddaughter was the fish had it not been for the grandmother’s past influencing how she lived her life. In that moment, the granddaughter becomes aware of the burden she will bear and how it has influenced her life.

    Read More

  • Freaks of the Core

    592 Words  | 2 Pages

    Kimberly Tsau, for example, follows De Quincey's lead in her analysis of T. S. Eliot's The Waste Land, suggesting that among the violence, apathy, and disjointedness of the poem is a call to face and learn from suffering. Her essay, "Hanging in a Jar," examines how Eliot collects a variety of "cultural memories," cutting and pasting them together to form a collection that is both terrifying and edifying.

    Read More

  • Bystander Open Book Reading: Questions On Figurative Language

    635 Words  | 2 Pages

    6. What form of figurative language does the author use in line 12 of page 212 to make his writing more interesting?

    Read More

  • Peace at Last?

    735 Words  | 2 Pages

    Terrible heartbreak plagues the reader: “And the mother’s shrieks of wild despair / Rise ...

    Read More

  • Asphyxiation

    1936 Words  | 4 Pages

    The hikers never knew the two indigenous people, except for what they wore that night, what booze they drank, and what side they slept on. And those simple details were just enough to make the dead bodies Human: capable of joking, singing, fighting, and eating. So the sudden termination of these lives confused the hikers, for they weren’t sure what they should feel about the death of two strangers. The hikers stared and stared at the bodies, perhaps feeling sadness for the friends, parents, and lovers of these men, but feeling only emptiness for the men themselves. They were just two more anonymous faces, frozen in their final dreams and nothing more than dead.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Nirvana Principle

    1434 Words  | 3 Pages

    In The Nirvana Principle by Lisa Bird-Wilson, the narrator often describes a particular image of a body in the river that is used to help her work towards this healing process with self-therapy. Throughout the story Hanna gradually reveals more in her narrative as the reader’s progress further to the truth. As the story advances, the reader’s can identify a development with the narrators healing process by the imagery used of the body in the ravine. In the end, it is revealed the true representation and meaning behind this imagery. Ultimately, this discovery exhibits alleviation in the narrator distress from her trauma

    Read More

  • Explication of Mary Oliver’s “The Black Snake”

    1158 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Mary Oliver’s poem “The Black Snake,” the narrator contemplates the cycle of life with the unpredictability of death. Mary Oliver’s work is “known for its natural themes and a continual affirmation of nature as a place of mystery and spirituality that holds the power to teach humans how to value one’s life and one’s place” (Riley). In the poem, The Black Snake, the narrator witnesses a black snake hit by a truck and killed on a road one morning. Feeling sympathy for the snake, the narrator stops, and removes the dead snake from the road. Noting the snake’s beauty, the narrator carries it from the road to some nearby bushes. Continuing to drive, the narrator reflects on how the abruptness of death ultimately revealed how the snake lived his life.

    Read More

  • Emily Dickinson 1489 Analysis

    1304 Words  | 3 Pages

    One of Emily Dickinson’s greatest skills is taking the familiar and making it unfamiliar. In this sense, she reshapes how her readers view her subjects and the meaning that they have in the world. She also has the ability to assign a word to abstractness, making her poems seemingly vague and unclear on the surface. Her poems are so carefully crafted that each word can be dissected and the reader is able to uncover intense meanings and images. Often focusing on more gothic themes, Dickinson shows an appreciation for the natural world in a handful of poems. Although Dickinson’s poem #1489 seems disoriented, it produces a parallelism of experience between the speaker and the audience that encompasses the abstractness and unexpectedness of an event.

    Read More

  • The Butterfly Effect Essay

    981 Words  | 2 Pages

    When tragedy strikes, it is normal for individuals to go through stages of grief. In some situations, people become cemented in one stage of emotional instability. They focus so much on their anger over the inevitability of the unfairness of life, that it eventually makes them go mad. This theme composes the synopsis of Joyce Carol Oates’ book We Were the Mulvaneys. The rape of Marianne Mulvaney catalyzed the disembowelment of the Mulvaney family due to their inability to move on from their grief; each family member coped in unique manners.

    Read More

More about Analysis Of The Deer At Providencia

Open Document