Analysis Of Andrew Carneige's The Gospel Of Wealth

Andrew carneige was a poor scottish immigrant who came to America at a young age. During the nineteenth century Carnegie helped build America's steel company. Which help a poor scottish immigrant turn into the riches man of america. Growing up being poor Carneige understood the struggle of making ends meet and it influenced his viewpoints on wealth in America. Retiring at the age of sixty-six Carneige had a lot of wealth , he decided he would become a philanthropist, someone who gave away money for good causes. In contrast, there was William Sumner who had a different take on the wealth and classes of America. Sumner grew up in America , on the East Coast and he saw things different than Andrew Carnegie. Sumner believed that the rich had

Known for his contributions he devotes his earnings to making America a better place for all to live. However, he is very strict on how these contributions should be made. He believes all disruption should be made when the millionaire is alive. That after the millionaires death his contribution does nothing to benefit the society. “The miser millionaire who hoards his wealth does less injury to society than the careless millionaire who squanders his unwisely, even if he does so under cover of the mantle of sacred charity,” (p. 32) In some degree I agree with him. What does it say when contribution is made after someone death? Personally, it says that the cause wasn't important enough and now that the millionaires dead, they try to make it seem like they care and still keep their name on the radar by donating to society. Carnegie saw wealth as something that a person had to work for, and as a constant battle to maintain. Carnegie came from a poor family and worked hard to achieve his wealth.I began to learn what poverty meant," Andrew would later write. "It was burnt into my heart then that my father had to beg for work. And then and there came the resolve that I would cure that when I got to be a man." Also he said that he felt that he was given an opportunity when he was young and felt it was his duty to give others the means to be successful as well. This is important to Carnegie as someone who does come from struggling background; he doesn’t want to see the inequalities that are created in America due to a number of many factors. He wants to see society as a whole