Vouchers and School Choice are Bad

  • Length: 949 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

School Choice and Vouchers are Bad


I have spent considerable time reading the literature on the topic of school choice and tuition vouchers.  I was initially in favor of the idea simply because it seems to be common sense. After just a little reading, I am now an advid supporter. After all, our entire standard of living is based on the idea of choice. The more choices we have, and the means to pursue those choices, the higher the standard of living we enjoy. In our lives, simply stated, choice means everything. When it comes to public schooling is there a choice? David Kirkpatrick, in his book, Choice In Schooling, argues that choice already exists de facto in our system and it is not regulated. It is because of this lack of regulation such inequality exists.


Let us not kid ourselves, education may profess to be about equity and equal opportunity, but this has never been the case in America or any other country. Education is about power. Power is a tool guarded by those who have it. Those with the means in this society already have exercised their choice and have built their own schools based on choice and in turn new opportunities. The masses have then been left to the confines of a limited system. Make no mistake, in a capitalist society, this is by design.


I remember reading the America at Risk report on Education in America, there was one line in there that summed up the educational system in this country and the lack of effort to change it. "If this current educational system was instituted in America by a foreign nation, it would be cause for a social revolution and a formal declaration of war." Yet it is accepted by those in power and justified for its existence through laws and coercion of the masses.


Why then do schools stay relatively unchanged? The article, A School for Choice, by Debra Viadero, outlines some "red flags" that are meant to caution for school choice. In my opinion, taken together, these make a weak argument at best to counter the need for choice. The concern of parents being good consumers is a good example of a ridiculous red flags. I suppose it is better to have no choice than to have any choice? Given time, parents will become savvy to the market and make good consumer decisions.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Vouchers and School Choice are Bad." 123HelpMe.com. 19 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Vouchers and School Choice - The Use of School Vouchers Essay - Use of School Vouchers There has been a lot of debate recently over the use of school vouchers. Voucher programs offer students attending both public and private schools tuition vouchers. It gives taxpayers the freedom to pick where their tax dollars go. In theory, good schools will thrive with money and bad schools will lose students and close its doors. Most people feel that taking taxpayer money from public schools and using this money as vouchers for private schools is a violation of the constitution....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Essays] 603 words
(1.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay about Just Say No to Vouchers and School Choice - Private School Vouchers: Just Say No The basic idea behind vouchers is for the government to use taxpayer money to encourage the transfer of a student from a public school to a private one with the expectation that his performance will improve. That any government official would actually support a program that essentially encourages parents to remove their children from public schools shows that they have no commitment to public education. Consider these arguments: Improved Scores The expectation that a bad student in a public school will turn into a good student in a private school is not only absurd, it is yet another slap in the face of public school teachers....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 663 words
(1.9 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Parents Want Vouchers and School Choice Essay - Parents Want School Choice Choice-based reforms, such as vouchers and charter schools, depend on the idea that schools will have to satisfy parents to keep their customers. Thus the wisdom of choice-based reforms depends on what parents want. If parents place a high priority on academics, then schools with strong academic programs will do well under school choice. If parents want their children to learn disciplined work habits, then schools that teach such habits will thrive under school choice....   [tags: Persuasive Argumentative Essay Examples] 501 words
(1.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on The Boondoggle of Vouchers and School Choice - The Boondoggle of School Choice The summer before my freshman year of high school, my suburban school district decided to implement a new school choice program developed for the state of Massachusetts. It is a program-limited choice similar to many others around the country. Schools offer a certain number of spaces in each class for "choice students," that is, students from other towns who wish to attend the school. Students apply and enter a random lottery system. If they are chosen, they become legally-enrolled students at the new school....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 1027 words
(2.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Vouchers and School Choice Meet the Needs of Parents Essay - School Choice Meets the Needs of Parents Parents are requesting the ability to choose a school for their children as a means towards legitimate objectives. "The parents are saying that they are not going to tolerate their children being miseducated any more, and that they are the ones who ultimately responsible for what happens for their children". (Milwaukee Parental Choice program). "Parents are using the scholarships to meet a number of needs, including high academic standards; safety; discipline; and moral environment".(Following The Teachers' Lead)....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 791 words
(2.3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Free Essays on Vouchers and School Choice - The Power of School Choice I am for the concept of Choice because no child should be forced to go to a bad school against his or his parents' will especially when there is a better school nearby. Parents not only freely choose any kinds of school but also allow to work with others to create new independent schools. Nowadays, we cannot ignore the reality that choice already exists for some privileged, rich people. It is fair to give our children a impartial chance at life through a better education....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 638 words
(1.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Pros and Cons of School Choice Essay - Benefits and Disadvantages of School Choice The purpose of this research paper is to investigate the benefits and drawbacks of school choice with respect to the impact on the students involved in the process. Over the years, school vouchers, school choice and charter schools have been grouped into one umbrella category known as school choice. The three types of school choice are very different yet very much the same and each topic will be discussed in depth and analyzed with examples and opinions from other authors....   [tags: Research Education Educational Essays]
:: 8 Works Cited
3542 words
(10.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Vouchers Are Not the Solution for Improving Public Schools Essay - “Vouchers lead us away from the basic American tradition of a free, quality public education for every student and undermine the kind of comprehensive, systemic school reform that is working […]” (Tirozzi, 1997). This quote taken from Gerald Tirozzi, the assistant U.S. secretary of education for elementary and secondary education, sums up the issue of vouchers. Milton Friedman, a free-market theorist, introduced vouchers, which funnel public funds to private schools, more than forty years ago (Resnick, 1998)....   [tags: essays papers] 1700 words
(4.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay about Educational Vouchers - Educational Vouchers Are children in the environment unhappy with the school that they attend. Do some children want to attend private schools rather than public schools. What should be done with these children that have these thoughts and feelings towards the school that they are attending. People should want to help children with their happiness, wants, and needs. The answer to all of the questions would be to use educational vouchers. Educational vouchers are programs that give money to benefit schools....   [tags: Papers] 600 words
(1.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
School Vouchers: Parents Need a Choice Essay - The 14th Amendment in the United States Constitution forbids states from denying any person life, liberty and property without due process of the law. It further states that any person, within a state’s jurisdiction, cannot be denied equal protection of its laws. This amendment protects all people. Chief Justice Clarence Thomas, in a 2002 ruling, stated reasons why school choice should be protected under the 14th Amendment. Justice Thomas wrote in defense of school choice, “Whatever the textual and historical merits of incorporating the Establishment Clause, I can accept that the Fourteenth Amendment protects religious liberty rights....   [tags: school choice, school reform]
:: 15 Works Cited
4616 words
(13.2 pages)
Term Papers [preview]

Related Searches

Another argument against school choice is that it will create inequalities. HELLO, look around, where is the equality now? Bottom line, parents of white middle class suburbs, with a wealthy tax base do not want black or other minority students with low incomes in their schools period. Let's not pretend here, this is fact and as long as there is choice for the few, and the ones with the power, they are not going to give that up.


It seems that in the literature the theoretical foundation for choice is strong, it is the design that would need to be examined and modified to avoid some issues. The question remains, is choice for the few ever going to solve inequalities or will it just foster it? I argue it will prevent any reform or systemic change and only widen the desparity we see in today's schools. Systemic change requires a catalyst, those in power will never provide it, it would be unrealistic to ever think they will.


School choice will provide that catalyst, initially there might be some problems, but in time adjustments could be made to even out the difficulties. I feel the system has reached critical mass and those at the bottom are aware of their situation more so than ever. The weak arguments against choice are just attempts to preserve the status quo and maintain the current power structure and limited access to choice. There is no evidence that I could see, in the history of school reform, even segregation, that has made a significant systemic change and leveled the field. Because of the lack of choice and free or regulated market forces, those with the means have always found a way to limit the access and strengthen their position. I contend that "hey what have we, the masses, to lose? Anything is better than this mess were in." The answer, "Nothing." However, what do the few or the privileged have to lose?


When I read the articles on the web about choice that were done by Harvard, I had to laugh. If there was ever an example of the inequality of education, it is the elitist position of schools like Harvard that should be the last to say anything on choice, talk about research bias. Harvard embodies the very fundamental ideas of access for the few. Give me a break, if anybody knows about the value of choice it is those attending or teaching at Harvard. This school values its position of elite education for the privileged, enough said, think abut it...


In conclusion, I challenge any and all arguments for choice. With these arguments, I look forward to the theoretical foundation for any plan that says if you have no choice but the few do, you are better off. If there is any other way to release the majority of people from the massive inequalities within the current system, I'll be the first in line, but remember, you are trying to convince me that our entire standard of living is not based on the ability of the masses to choose. Good luck.


Note: This poor-quality essay was written by a high school teacher!  Just another example of how pitiful our educational system has become.


Return to 123HelpMe.com