Vouchers and School Choice are Not Necessary

  • Length: 1169 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

The issue of "choice", like so many other novel educational reform attempts, serve once again to highlight the fact that something is desperately wrong with the current educational system. While everyone seems to be fully aware of the need for change, no one really knows where to start. In the process of making sense of this need to pin down the problems that beset education, many end up latching on to any novel idea that even vaguely offers the hope of finally bringing that educational calm and success everyone so desperately longs for. The problem with this hit-and-run approach is that it almost always ends up fragmenting the communities and societies that should in fact be pooling their energies and resources on the issue of educational reform. Name me ANY reform movement, and I'll show you at least two camps for each of them - one "for", and one "against".

The proponents of educatonal choice have, over time, carefully built up their pool of arguments in support of its implementation. To fully understand this perspective, and before I share mine, I have selected a collection of quotes from various proponents of educational choice which should present, albeit statically, the central issues underlying the concerns of these and many other students, parents, and teachers. In the process of reading them, please try to focus on the issues they represent rather than the emotions that presently drive them.

"It is time to develop political muscle for parents and children. We know that our urban public school systems are hopelessly broken. We know that unless the parents of children in public schools are able to threaten to enroll their children in competing private schools, the public schools will never be held accountable."

"Lessons must be learned from Voucher Bill Defeat", Joseph Walsh

"The most recent National Assessment of Education Progress reading test reports that 30% of high school seniors, 31% of eighth graders, and 42% of fourth graders couldn't reach "basic" reading levels. Those students who have spent from four to thirteen years in school, don't have even "partial mastery" of the reading skills expected at their grade level."

"The High Cost of Rationing Literacy", Martha C. Brown

"There is no more important issue today than the education of our children. We could possibly disagree that our society - crippled by gang violence, teen pregnancy, and welfare dependancy - would experience a Renaissance if every child received quality education?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Vouchers and School Choice are Not Necessary." 123HelpMe.com. 23 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
School Vouchers are the Solution Essay - We, as human beings, irrespective of our backgrounds, traditions and cultures, believe in certain fundamental ideals. We want all our children to have access to a good, overall education regardless of family income; we want to make sure that they are prepared for times to come; we want them to be responsible adults; and expect that these qualities are fostered in them through learning in their familial environments, friend circles and most importantly through the institution called school. The growing idea has been that these ideals may only be achieved through a universal centrally planned system of tax-funded schools, commonly known as “public schools”....   [tags: School Choice]
:: 6 Works Cited
1685 words
(4.8 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
School Vouchers The Wrong Choice Essays - School Vouchers: The Wrong Choice Susie is a young girl who lives in Florida. Since kindergarten, she has attended a nearby private school. Her parents willingly pay her tuition, even though doing so forces them to cut other corners. They do not mind these sacrifices, since they know that their daughter is getting the best education they can give her. Jesse lives downtown, in the inner city. She attends the local public school and struggles through her classes. Her mother would like to send her to a private school, where there is less violence and a calmer atmosphere, but cannot afford it....   [tags: essays papers]
:: 5 Works Cited
1484 words
(4.2 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on School Choice is the Future of Education - As a proponent of school choice, I see it as one of the reform movements that has a real chance of changing education for the better here in the United States. School choice, if implemented correctly, would give parents and children the opportunity to choose the type of school that they feel best meets their educational needs. They would also be in a position to demand excellence in every way from that school. School choice is a much debated issue and has respected educators gathering on both sides of the issue....   [tags: School Vouchers Essays] 786 words
(2.2 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Vouchers and School Choice - Vouchers are Not the Solution Essay - School Vouchers: Not the Solution     As standardized test scores continue to plummet and our nation falls farther behind such industrial rivals as Germany, England, Australia and Japan in comparable education, parents are questioning the current system of education. After being kicked around the national agenda for decades, the school voucher issue is finally being emphasized in several state legislatures, as well as in Congress. In the website titled "Vouchers: No, but...Taxpayer Help to Parents will Advance Separation", David Bahurlich reinforces his support of school vouchers, both publicly and privately funded, in an attempt to show that vouchers will lead to a better quality of educ...   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]
:: 7 Works Cited
1307 words
(3.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Vouchers and School Choice Now! - School Choice Now.       This is America the Free, the leader of the free world. I have choice in many aspects of my life. For one of the most important concerns I have - the education of my children - my choices are limited. The government's rigid control over public education choice has got to stop. While it is true I can send my child to a private school, I must incur costs above and beyond what I already provide to society for public education through taxes. I can afford this; many people cannot....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]
:: 3 Works Cited
775 words
(2.2 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Free Essays on Possibilities Offered by Vouchers and School Choice - The Exciting Possibilities Offered by School Choice        We are in the midst of an unprecedented attack on public schools in the United States. What is causing this attack. Since schools are public institutions, they are by their nature subject to close scrutiny in a democratic society such as ours. All would agree that public schools must be willing to change to meet the changing needs of the greater society. It just seems that in the past decade, the mudslinging has gotten out of hand.   Only now is evidence emerging testifying to the fact that much of the criticism leveled at public schools is exaggerated and misplaced....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]
:: 3 Works Cited
957 words
(2.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
An Argument in Opposition of Education Vouchers Essay - An Argument in Opposition of Education Vouchers Why would anyone wish to withhold support for a program that has the potential to revolutionize the, often, insufficient American education system. This question has undoubtedly entered the mind of proponents of education voucher systems across the country. However, despite the pressure placed on legislators everywhere, close scrutiny of the real issues should not be clouded by public fervor. It is my belief that, after a thorough examination of the merits of such programs, school vouchers would be a gross detriment to both the American education system and the nation itself....   [tags: Voucher School Argumentative Persuasive Essays] 1794 words
(5.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Vouchers and School Choice - First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System - School Vouchers:  The First Step Towards a Discriminatory Educational System On November 9, 1998, Jennifer Marshall, Education Policy Analyst for the Family Research Council, declared in a press statement: "Parental choice in education just got a green light from the Supreme Court." Her statement came as a response to the decision made the same day by the Supreme Court to deny a petition for a writ of certiorari in Jackson v. Benton, a case in Wisconsin which challenges the constitutionality of vouchers in public education....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics] 1923 words
(5.5 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Vouchers and School Choice More Effective than Affirmative Action Essay - School Choice More Effective than Affirmative Action If America is to become an equal society, then the direction of affirmative action must be changed. Rather than continuing to focus the brunt of our efforts on helping those individuals near the top succeed, we must implement policies designed to provide opportunities to those individuals at or near the bottom. Specifically, affirmative action must return to its original purpose--helping minorities move into the middle class through programs based upon equality of educational opportunity and job creation....   [tags: Persuasive Argumentative Essay Examples] 788 words
(2.3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Separation of Church and State is Necessary for Freedom of Choice Essay - Separation of Church and State is Necessary for Freedom of Choice We in America have the right to be free, so why not listen to the words of Thomas Jefferson and build a “wall of separation between church and state?”  The wall of separation was Jefferson’s interpretation of the first amendment; however, the idea was actually founder of Rhode Island Roger Williams’.  Jefferson’s belief was that religion was a personal relationship strictly between a man and his God and the government should not be allowed to restrict anyone from practicing their religion....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Argument Essays]
:: 2 Works Cited
866 words
(2.5 pages)
Better Essays [preview]

Related Searches


"Statewide the dropout rate is approximately 20%. Even those who graduate are often unprepared for college and must enroll in "remedial" courses or not attend college at all. Graduates from Illinois best public high schools are ill-prepared to compete with students from other states and countries for admission to the nation's top universities"

" The way to return power to parents and local communities is through school choice: giving tax dollars to parents in the form of a scholarship or "voucher" and allowing them to purchase tuition at the schools of their choice."

"Revitalizing Public Education in Illinois", Joseph Walsh

"The resulting choice plan is fully constitutional and a big step toward religious tolerance, religious freedom, and better education."

"School Choice: Church vs. State", Harold Hotelling

"The fact is, education consumers - parents and students - in Chicago's inner city are nearly helpless to make the system provide what they want and need. Private school teachers don't strike, and public school teachers in affluent suburbs do only rarely. In these environments, services to the education consumer takes priority."

"Competition, Not Money, Works Wonders in Education", Steve Sailer

"But, our growing impatience also has come about because the schools remain in a financial quagmire, test scores and graduation rates are almost unchanged, and children do not seem to be learning any more under decentralization than before."

"Replacing Dwarfs with Giants", Sam Redding

These are not nebulous, arbitrary concerns. They are real issues that demand real solutions. Discipline, literacy, powerlessness, and the lack of standards are at the heart of the fears of parents, students, and teachers.

I want to propose that these individuals, and many others, are asking all the proper questions, but are misdirected in their focus.

The extent to which one reform process is charismatically applauded by some and battered into submission by others is symptomatic of the inability of many to look beyond the individual trees in order to focus on the forest. By latching onto the first plausible option and blindly allowing it to navigate the course is tantamount to stripping oneself of, ironically, ones freedom of choice and control over the reform process. I suggest that the answer lies outside the novelty of alternative reform processes and is to be found in dysfunctional processes within the current educational system. If the 85/15 Rule is anything to go by, it would serve us well to shift the blame from those "for" and those "against" to the real culprit - the processes within the current educational system.

Let us for a moment consider one of the more pressing issues at the heart of the choice debate - discipline. As was highlighted in the aforementioned statements and mouthed so often as part of the choice rhetoric, gang violence and disruptive behavior constitutes the "number one concern" for parents, teachers, and pupils. Who, in their sane state, would chose to wake up every morning of the week and send their precious children into a battlefield? What teacher wants to walk into a classroom, powerless to protect the innocent students from violent and disruptive behavior because the system insists on the "rights" of the "disabled student" perpetuating these terrible deeds. Name me one administrator that can sleep at night knowing that every step taken to extricate the gangrenous growth of violence and disruptive behavior from their schools almost always end up with courts routinely returning the offending students to the school. This is the reality of the processes that constitute our current educational system. Given this context, one cannot blame parents for crying out for the choice to remove their children from these situations.

It is at this point, however, that we need to take just one step back and look at the facts before we all run for cover. The facts are that only two or three percent of the student population constitute the violent or chronically disruptive group! Does it therefore make sense to sacrifice public education simply because we refuse to take action on the two or three percent who are violently or chronically disruptive? Why should ninety-eight percent of our children be forced out of public schools because of a marginal minority? Does it make sense to destroy twenty-five or more students because we are trying to "rehabilitate" one? (Shanker, 1995) The answer is a resounding NO! What we should be doing is consolidating the energy we are expending on novel alternatives and use it to, not only to rid the public schools of this disruptive 2%, but also to address the other pressing issues of educational standards, literacy levels, and community involvement - within our existing public schools.

Return to 123HelpMe.com