ENLIGHTENED SURRENDER
How many essays have been written about American culture? How
many books dedicated to the intense scrutiny of every aspect of our
modern society? Countless thoughts, countless theories—many of them
lost in the very chaos that the authors spent 300 pages explaining. There
are always solutions, which their creators seem entirely convinced will solve
this mess, but the truth is that these ideas are often impractical and unrealistic.
But no one writes an entire book complaining without offering us
something at the conclusion. Sociologists parade around with their own
superfluous speculations, conflicting and contradictory, but this must be
better than unresolved pessimism, right?
Thomas de Zengotita doesn’t seem to think so. In his essay, “The
Numbing of the American Mind: Culture as Anesthetic,” he discusses the
perceptual overload of Americans and the differing and indistinguishable
levels of reality in which we exist. He claims that most people don’t know
and can’t recognize what is real what is not. There are so many different
kinds of reality—he lists sixteen out of many—and they have all become
so intertwined into our lives that they bleed together. As a result of these
discrepancies, we can no longer appreciate the differences between what is
important and what isn’t. Using modern examples like the events of
September 11th and the media’s response to them, de Zengotita explains
how we’ve become numb to things “so enormous, so horrific, so stark, that
[we believe] the great blob of virtuality that is our public culture would
be unable to absorb it” (342). It is a typical review of American society—
pessimistic and daunting—though his sarcastic humor and nonchalant
attitude are...
... middle of paper ...
...ous diagnosis of a serious
condition. Would we rather not know about it because it happens to be
incurable? This goes much deeper than subject matter, or political bias,
the usual folder. It determines the way we frame everything . . . the attitude
we bring to living in this world of surfaces. (de Zengotita 350)
No amount of truth can ever bring about change on the grand scale, but
the way you chose to function within it will define the difference between
prisoner and progressive. In expressing a helplessness to do nothing, de
Zengotita has accomplished more than all the theories in the world.
“It was to have been the end of irony, remember?” (de Zengotita 340)
Works Cited
Zengotita, Thomas de. “The Numbing of American Minds: Culture as Anesthetic.” 2002.
The Text Wrestling Book. Eds. Donna LeCourt, et al. Dubuque, Iowa: Kendall Hunt,
2005. 340-351.
The Coddling of the American Mind, by Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt, is an article published by the Atlantic Journal about the negative effects trigger warnings and microaggressions have on students in college. Trigger warnings are disclaimers about any potential emotional response from a class or its material. (44) Microaggressions are words or actions that have no sinister intentions, but people take as such. (44) Greg Lukianoff is the president and CEO of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education. (47) As the leader of the foundation, Greg Lukianoff has witnessed and fought many legal occasions of trigger warnings and microaggressions resulting in the masking of freedom of speech. Coauthor Jonathan Haidt is a professor at New
In the text, “The American Cultural Configuration” the authors express the desire of anthropologists to study their own culture despite the difficulty that one faces attempting to subjectively analyze their own society. Holmes and Holmes (2002), use the adage “not being able to see the forest through the trees” (p. 5) to refer to how hard it is for someone to study something they have largely taken for granted. The Holmes' article focuses predominately on paradoxes within our own culture, many of which we don't notice. In a paradox, two contradicting statements can appear to be true at the same time. This essay looks at two paradoxes commonly found in everyday life: the individual versus the family and religion.
In the Article “The Coddling of the American Mind” by George Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt were very specific examples of college students who were demanding protection from words and ideas they don't like, and seeking punishment to those who give even an accidental offense. When this becomes a problem for education and mental health on campus, many different problems become relevant in our generation of students then what the baby boomers and the Gen X generations had to deal with. The article was explaining how words, subjects, and ideas may affect students, along with these ideas were Microaggressions: small actions or word choices that seem on their face to have no malicious intent but that are thought of as a kind of violence
Cultural norms play a function in the way individuals view the world. Although, some individual’s experience social dilemmas between their heritage and being American. As United States citizens, individuals should go beyond ethnicity and see everybody as an American. America was established by immigrants from all over the world, which turned the nation into a collage made of a number of diverse cultures. With these different cultures come the laws and religions that govern their behavior. In, Mind Reading an Anthology for Writers by Gary Colombo presents a number of remarkable essays on cultural customs. In “Hidden Culture” by Edward T. Hall, he describes culture as well as, how an individual’s culture effects their capability to understand another person’s cultural customs. In “Mrs. Cassadore” by Mick Fedullo, explains his life experience while educating the Apache students on the reservation. Fedullo overcomes cultural obstacles. Fedullo helps his students to realize that it is acceptable to be Apache. Fedullo teaches his students that one should never transform who they are. “The Self and Society: Changes, Problems, and Opportunities by Roy F. Baumeister make use of labels to explain selfhood. Baumeister discuss the history of selfhood to rationalize selfhood. For example, how changes in the society and culture affect selfhood. Two other articles that give some insight on American culture are “A Quilt of a Country” by Anna Quindlen, and “Communication In A Global Village” by Dean Barnlund. Culture is something people are born into. The way people view culture is how they are raised around it. Throughout history, our country has experienced social revolutions. When there are social revolutions, bringing about structural...
Rereading America: Cultural Contexts for Critical Thinking and Writing written by; Gary Colombo, Robert Cullen, and Bonnie Lisle, Eighth Edition, published April, 2007 by Bedford/St. Martin’s, is a textbook about writing and critical thinking. In the first chapter of Rereading America: Cultural Contexts for Critical Thinking and Writing, “Thinking Critically, Challenging Cultural Myths”, the Authors begin by setting a relatable scene of what it’s like for a college student. How a new found independence can be overwhelming, especially with regards to critical thinking, showing that what we have learned, needs to be re-evaluated and that an open mind in essential. "What Is Critical Thinking" In this section of the chapter the editors explain what it means to be a critical thinker. They explain that critical thinking is not just studying dates and facts, but rather taking those facts and examining them. The editors then proceed by explaining how having an open mind, and taking others' perspectives into account when formulating our own opinions on what the author is trying to say to us is important. A critical thinker takes all aspects into account and reflects on personal experience as well. The editors also point out that different cultural experiences bring different opinions. They suggest that we need to become active learners, continuously questioning the meaning behind everything, testing not only the theories of others but also our own experiences and analyzing the text rather than going for the obvious. They show that thinking outside the box is the epitome of critical thinking. Basically, we need to step outside our comfort zones and what we have always been taught. The editors also suggest that we need to re-evaluate our per...
An article in The Atlantic, The Coddling of the American Mind, the author talks about how the mindset of younger generations has changed on sensitive topics. The author attributes a lot of this new sensitivity to generational changes. Older generations had more freedom from their parents but with the increase in reported crime these children grew up to be more protective of their children, and what they were exposed too. In this way, the new generation has come to be over sensitized and thinks that adults will always try to protect their feelings. This affects the quality of education that students are getting in a college setting when professors have to censor information in order to prevent emotional distress for some students. Many students
The question of whether or not college students have become too “sensitive” is one that is currently being debated in the United States. This issue, which has seemed to increase in the past few years, is one that has angered many due to the fact that what this world needs is straight-forward commentary. In “The Coddling of the American Mind,” by Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt, the issue of college students being too “coddled” is discussed in many different aspects. Similarly, an article published by Scott Stump in Today Parents shows an example of how the effect of political correctness on these students has caused a realization that we are in dire need of some desensitizing. Validating one another, these two articles prove that the coddling
Anxiety and affluence are terms that are often applied to the post war decades in an attempt to define them. The newfound wealth that Americans enjoyed after World War II wrought changes on the American social landscape that many may not have been able to predict. The push for heavy consumerism that accompanied the sudden upswing of the U.S. economy gave way to concerns about the decay of moral character in the American home. Increasingly filled with anxieties over the ever-present threat of Communism, which most Americans were aware was an issue they themselves could do little about, the population instead turned towards new distractions, such as television, to attempt to reclaim some sense of dominance in a world they no longer quite recognized. The failure of the device to soothe the nerves of anxious Americans can easily serve as a symbol for any case in which American prosperity increased, rather than alleviated, post war fears.
The reading for this week that I thought was very interesting was “The Coddling of the American Mind.” I thought this article was interesting because I did not realize this type of issue was happening at certain universities and colleges. I think that it is crazy how students at these universities will not take certain classes or will ask their professors to not talk about certain issues in class because they are offended by it or feel uncomfortable talking about it. College is supposed to be the time that allows us to be open and express our opinions. We should be able to talk about issues like racism and same sex marriage without being offended. People may not agree with your opinion, but we should not stop talking about those issues because
Folklores are stories that have been through many time periods. Folklore include Legends, Myths, and Fairy Tales. Legends are traditional tales handed down from earlier times and believed to have a historical basis. Myths are ancient stories dealing with supernatural beings, ancestors, or heroes. Fairy Tales are fantasy tales with legendary being and creators.
Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt claim in their article “The Coddling of the American Mind” that the “vindictive protectiveness” to protect the college students by avoiding “microaggression’ and the usage of ‘trigger warnings’ are not going to help the students adapt to ‘the world with potential offenses.’
Tension between racial groups has been around in the United States for years and although the tension changes in presentation, it does not seem to be disappearing anytime soon. Nevertheless, to many Americans the majority of theses issues were solved during the Civil rights movement. Be that as it may this is not the society that was formed after the civil right movement. Our society runs on the idea of having a dominate group in power and all the rest being oppressed, with their voices being distorted or muted. When Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt wrote “The Coddling of the American Mind” in 2015, tensions between racial groups were starting to become tenses everywhere but especially on college campuses. People were becoming fed up with
When one first moves to a completely new and unfamiliar cultural environment, assuredly he or she will experience cultural shock and disorientation. Culture shock can be from many different aspects, for examples, climate, foods, language, custom, social etiquette, environment and etc. Culture shock might cause depression, homesickness, confusion, sadness, frustration, in which one has to overcome when arrived in a new country. Personally, I had experienced culture shock when I first arrived in America from FuZhou, China; I felt lost and confused. Similarly, Tanya, who is from Kharkiv, Ukraine had experienced cultural shock and had felt unsuitable because of foods, school, and living habits when she came to America one and a half years ago.
It holds that, as a matter of fact, moral beliefs and practices vary between cultures (and sometimes between groups within a single society). For instance, some societies condemn homosexuality; others accept it; in some cultures a student who corrects a teacher would be thought to be disrespectful; elsewhere such behavior might be encouraged. The rules, principles and standards that constitute a morality differ in different religions, and cultures, just as they differ historically. The morality of ancient Greece was not the morality of feudal Europe or contemporary American; the morality of the Trobriand Islanders is not the same as the morality of the Kwakiutl Indians (Barnet, 2008). In this paper I intend to argue that moral reasoning
For instance, the way that psychology is taught as an undergraduate and a graduate program in China verses America. Chinese students tend to choose to study abroad for psychology in America for the benefit of the numerous undergraduate and graduate programs that are offered all over the country. Not only does America obtain so many different programs, there is also an abundance of developing and available jobs in the field of psychology that are readily available in China. The two Universities that are being compared is the PeKing University (PKU) in Beijing and the University of Mary Hardin-Baylor (UMHB) located in Central Texas. Some of the more obvious differences include that UMHB offers not only a Bachelors in Science for psychology, but