How, If at All, Is Freedom Valuable?

1467 Words3 Pages

It is important to distinguish between freedom’s kinds of values, because in defining a system of government, the attitude towards freedom is a key component. If freedom has no independent value, different schools of political thought might have the standpoint, that we should not value freedom at all, only the things that it is means to. Some might think that they know better what is good for people, and feel justified in constraining people’s freedom. We intuitively value freedom, and usually do not even notice, that we have it, because it woven through so much of our everyday life. We take freedom for granted, even though in some countries it is not so trivial. It is not enough to feel that freedom is our basic right, but to understand why it is so important, and why freedom can not be replaced by the specific ends one might think it is means to. I will argue, that freedom does have independent value. First I will talk about the non-independent value of freedom, and look at the different independent values, then concentrate on the non-specific instrumental value. I am going to look at claims where Dworkin and Kymlicka were wrong, and evaluate Ian Carter’s standpoint. We can define freedom in a positive or a negative manner. The former would be related to self-realization and being free from internal obstacles, while the latter definition concentrates on being free from external constraints, that is no one interfere with our freedom, at least not arbitrarily, since we need some rules to live in a society. In this essay, I will assume a negative concept. Philosophic value may be split into two types of value. Non-independent value, which is specific instrumental value. If something has non-independent value, it is valuable in re... ... middle of paper ... ...t of the condition of the mankind, it involves learning, and the outcome is discovering the yet unknown. And it seems that progress is the highest when freedom is present, in other words we can not get the most out of ourselves if we have constraints. So by the definition of progress we are unable to say what good is it going to make us, but it will do something generally valuable. So freedom is indeed valuable. Not many argues against the nonindependent value of freedom, since there are a lot of values for which freedom is essential. In my view, freedom is independently also valuable, because we might not know exactly what good is it going to do for us, but Works Cited The Independent Value of Freedom Ian Carter Ethics Vol. 105, No. 4 (Jul., 1995), pp. 819-845 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Article Stable URL:http://www.jstor.org/stable/2382113

Show More
Related

  • Defining Freedom in Eric Foner's The Story of American Freedom

    1177 Words  | 3 Pages

    Foner focuses, specifically, on how the definition of liberty has been molded over time. He describes how other factors played a role in the change of liberty using three interrelated themes. The first theme, as he describes it, covers the dimensions or meanings of freedom. The dimensions include “political freedom, or the right to participate in public affairs… civil liberties, or rights that individuals can assert against authority…[and] moral or ‘Christian’ ideal of freedom,” the freedom to act morally or ethically good (Foner xvii). It also includes personal freedom or being able to make individual choices free from coercion, and “economic freedom…[which covers how] the kinds of economic relations constitute freedom for… [individual’s working lives]” (Foner xviii). All these dimensions are looked at individually as they play a role in reshaping the definition of freedom or liberty.

    Read More

  • Progress in American History

    1357 Words  | 3 Pages

    The word progress has several different meanings. These definitions played a vital role in American thought. From the initial immigrants to the first government, progress was always on the American mind. Wars were fought on the grounds on progress. The first United States president represented progress. Everything America stands for is based on the progression of its people.

    Read More

  • Obedience: The Odyssey to Freedom

    645 Words  | 2 Pages

    The word freedom is often associated with the idea of an unfettered liberty to select from a range of alternatives coupled with a sense that our actions will not affect our natural state.

    Read More

  • Gender Stereotypes In Thomas Jefferson's The Giver

    1120 Words  | 3 Pages

    If we knew how freedom would be used, the case for it would largely disappear. We shall never get the benefits of freedom, never obtain those unforeseeable new developments for which it pro­vides the opportunity, if it is not also granted where the uses made of it by some do not seem desir­able. It is therefore no argument against individual freedom that it is frequently abused. Freedom necessarily means that many things will be done which we do not like. Our faith in freedom does not rest on the foreseeable results in particular circumstances but on the belief that it will, on balance, release more forces for the good than for the

    Read More

  • Freedom

    1307 Words  | 3 Pages

    Freedom remains the sole basis for American society as we know it. Without freedom the great nation of America would have never been founded. To understand the true principles of freedom, one must understand the scope of the word. Philosophical freedom encompasses the ability to make choices without restraints, while political freedom is the state of being free rather than in physical confinement. Despite the importance of these ideas to our founding fathers, freedom has lost much of its importance in modern American society. The failure to stress the importance of freedom has diminished the quality of life for the entire American populous

    Read More

  • Comparing John Locke, John Stuart Mill, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau

    2030 Words  | 5 Pages

    John Locke, John Stuart Mill, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau all dealt with the issue of political freedom within a society. John Locke's “The Second Treatise of Government”, Mill's “On Liberty”, and Rousseau’s “Discourse On The Origins of Inequality” are influential and compelling literary works which while outlining the conceptual framework of each thinker’s ideal state present divergent visions of the very nature of man and his freedom. The three have somewhat different views regarding how much freedom man ought to have in political society because they have different views regarding man's basic potential for inherently good or evil behavior, as well as the ends or purpose of political societies.

    Read More

  • Locke's Impatibilist Argument Of Free Will

    1157 Words  | 3 Pages

    The topic of free will has been greatly debated by philosophers. It is important to understand freedom especially in terms of responsibility. Whether our actions come from our complete free will or our actions are caused by external factors is vital to our judiciary systems. In this essay, I will firstly discuss Locke’s compatibilist argument as well as his analysis that we are free if we do what we will. Secondly, Hume’s analysis that with better definitions of freedom we will all conclude that the world is necessary. Thirdly, Kant’s argument that freedom cannot exist in the empirical world, but can coexist with necessity if we consider it as in the world of things-in-themselves. Finally, I will compare then analyze their arguments of freedom

    Read More

  • The American Revolution: The Definition Of Freedom

    1558 Words  | 4 Pages

    Freedom is a forever changing concept. For each individual, the definition of freedom is solely their own. There is no way to define freedom in a concrete way, but instead it can be looked at individualistically such as “the freedom to” or “the freedom from”; the freedom of certain rights, self-definition, and religion or the freedom from oppression, prejudice and judgement. Throughout history, freedom’s definition has molded itself into the life and society of those of that specific time, but as we look at the preceding and succeeding years, there is a developmental aspect that integrates itself into those meanings tied to freedom and what it means to those people. In history, we see the ideas of freedom connected to many groups of people

    Read More

  • The Many Faces of Freedom?

    1192 Words  | 3 Pages

    Freedom is a concept that people are often willing to die for and it is the cause of much fighting. However, few people ever claim to dislike freedom. This raises an interesting question: how can people fight over what is generally considered to be a positive idea? Does this mean that someone must be against freedom? The answer is that people cannot agree on what freedom is, thus numerous groups can claim to be "for freedom" while strongly disagreeing on the means by which to achieve it. These groups often argue vehemently and passionately, trying to convince the majority that their side is right. However, emotion is only one part of deciding who is more persuasive. I offer two examples of disagreements regarding freedom, as proof that freedom is neither tangible, nor a singular idea.

    Read More

  • The Definition Of Freedom In The United States

    965 Words  | 2 Pages

    The history and meaning behind the word "freedom" has been a topic of controversy. There are many different perspective of what freedom truly means and what influences it has on the nation we lived in. According to the Oxford Dictionary the word freedom means "The power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint." To me, the word freedom is being able to act and express anyway without causing harm.. Many questions have been asked about whether we are truly free of being restraint or if everything is control by higher authority who swear to protect us. Some believe that we are not free, that nothing happens freely, and that nothing happens by chance. We have this constitution describing our freedom but the

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Freedom In America

    383 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the time we live in now, my generation seems to overlook the many amazing gifts America has given to us. Unfortunately, many people in my generation choose to ignore all of the privileges we have been provided with. One of those many privileges being our freedom. Freedom is something the entirety of America has taken, and will most likely, continue to take for granted. It has been around for so long that we feel entitled to it. Although a plentiful amount of people don’t fully appreciate everything freedom in America does for us, it will continue to be So many amazing things have been able to come out of living in a free country. There are four main types of freedom that not only my generation, but all of the United States benefit from

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Freedom In The United States

    274 Words  | 1 Pages

    “ As Abraham Lincoln would say, ‘Those who deny freedom to others deserves it not for themselves’.” Something that would hold little meaning to those politician who do not agree to freedom being something you are born with, but more of a privilege if anything. With the arrival of President Trump and his bills, the current populace of the United States are being divided on whether or not every individuals has the right to their own freedom. Something the government has been trying to limit by giving in hopes that you take the protection it grants.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Freedom In The United States

    526 Words  | 2 Pages

    Freedom is a very sacred privilege, which in some countries is a right that a lot of people take for granted, while in many other countries there is no freedom and the people are ruled by a dictator. Freedom is what people desire for and it is one of the main reasons that many people yearn to come to America, it is a subject in which you must demand and fight for, freedom is never just handed out, you must fight many cases of countries that have freedom rights got them from revolutionary and civil wars.

    Read More

  • Explain What Freedom Means To Me

    390 Words  | 1 Pages

    Freedom is what makes Americans, Americans. Two freedoms that have left an impact on me are Freedom of Religion and Freedom of Speech

    Read More

  • Positive And Negative Freedom Essay

    1714 Words  | 4 Pages

    Comparison of the Implications of Negative and Positive Freedom for the Relationship Between the Individual and the State

    Read More

More about How, If at All, Is Freedom Valuable?

Open Document