paper

788 Words2 Pages

Edgar Allan Poe has been debated to be the author of the most dark and horrific pieces of literature. He was favored by many for his complex pieces of literature that have ultimately impacted the world of literature today. However, Poe’s pieces of work did receive harsh criticism before and after his death. Because Poe was generally known for his thought-provoking short stories, his short stories often received mixed reviews. One of Poe’s most arguable short stories is “The Fall of the House of Usher”. This short story was “regarded as an early and supreme example of the Gothic horror story” (Plot Summary: "The Fall of the House of Usher"). Poe himself described this piece as “arabesque” due to its ornate prose (Plot Summary: "The Fall of the House of Usher"). However, many critics disagreed with each other on their views of “The Fall of the House of Usher”. Carl Mowery stated that this short story was “the most cerebral [because] there [was] little action to carry the plot, no trips into a catacomb, no descent into a whirlpool, [and] no crimes to be solved” (Overview of "The Fall of the House of Usher" change to last name). Unlike Mowery, I thought that this short story was relatively interesting. I found that the use and significance of the supernatural theatrics in this story were quite capturing. I do see why Mowery stated his critique possibly because this story had more of a low story line compared to the higher action short stories Poe has written. I think Poe’s character choice of twins and a narrator kept the short story simple, but left enough room for character development through the supernatural effects. Poe’s readers may have had different expectations from this short story, but I found “The Fall of the House of Ush... ... middle of paper ... ...he Madman as an Artist OR name idk change it). Personally, I do not agree with Marmon’s theory. I never at all thought that she was a vampire, and after rereading the short story I still do not think she is a vampire. The vampire motif does create an even more eerie mood to the story, but I still think otherwise in Madeline’s character. I do believe that her character was important in adding to the supernatural tone of the story. Madeline’s fate at the end of the story did provide the story more room for interpretation; I understand the criticism of readers who believe the vampire theory, but I think otherwise. Madeline’s character really strengthened the story by providing the unknown of sanity and purity in the story. “The Fall of the House of Usher” revealed Poe’s style in writing to be a part of the Gothic style, and people see this story as one of Poe’s works.

Open Document