Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Analyse similarities and differences between macbeth and hamlet pdf
Compare and contrast adaptations of Shakespeare's Macbeth
Comparative analysis of MacBeth
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Macbeth Movie Review Do you crave power and authority? In the Shakespeare play Macbeth, the audience gets to see the inner workings of the mind as Macbeth deals with the consequences of knowing your future. The movies I am comparing from Macbeth were directed by Justin Kurzel and Rupert Goold and will be referred to by their names. In the Macbeth films, one can compare the use of low-key lighting, the effectiveness of dialogue, and the overall pace of the story. While the use of lighting in any movie is important to the mood, in Macbeth, it is crucial to use. In the Goold film, using low-key lighting allowed them to emphasize what the characters can or cannot see while also creating a mysterious atmosphere. By doing that it allows the audience to see the sudden changes in the mind with Macbeth and the evil rituals the witches perform without being seen. While in Kurzels …show more content…
interpretation he also uses the dark lighting to create an evil and uneasy mood when lady Macbeth is summoning spirits. Both films understood how important the lighting was in creating an unusual point of view and eerie feeling. One interesting piece about the two movies were their dialogue.
Because it is based on Shakespeare's play the language used is old english. The fascinating part is how the directors chose to utilize that, both choosing to stay with how it was originally. This creates a conflict in Goolds film because it is set in 20th century, and the dialect is not cohesive. While set in Medieval Scotland Kurzel has no difficulty convincing the audience and creating an illusion of traveling back in time. Although, Goold's film has a new twist to the play, Kurzels film is easier to accept allowing the audience to immerse themselves in the film. In the play Macbeth, the timeline of the events unfolding move quickly. Act to act the time jumps make the play concise enough to be exciting without cutting crucial aspects of the plot. In the film by Kurzel the pace of the story is consistent and easy to follow. While in the Goold movie, it is hard to distinguish when a day or week has passed because almost every scene is indoors and the lighting is consistent. This makes it difficult for the audience to follow the
plot. In conclusion there are similarities in both movie interpretations of Macbeth using lighting, both differ in effectiveness of dialogue and pacing. In both movies they use lighting to create a mood that would be difficult to meet without. In Goold's film is in the 20th century, this makes dialogue appear unnecessary and out-of-place while Kurzel maintains an effective dialogue by keeping the original setting of Macbeth. Finally, the pace of Kurzel is superior to Goold’s because he is able to keep the speed consistent. And as quickly as Macbeth took power his betrayed friend took it back.
Often times, directors take timeless works of literature and make them more relatable to modern audiences. Creating a good adaptation is very difficult, the new product must be different from the original to make it relatable, however still be similar enough to recognize as the first edition. Due to changing times, many of Shakespeare’s plays have been adapted into movies. One of the most adapted plays by Shakespeare is Macbeth. This classic sets a high standard to live up to, however the film Scotland, PA comes close.
The film remains faithful to the themes of Macbeth. It does not dilute the eternal qualities of evil and treachery that are so viscerally expressed in the play.
...th allows for much more accessibility in understanding the movie due to its rich and detailed text. The two mediums of exchange share a lot of similar aspects, but many of them are better understood in the context of the movie with having read and understood the play. Although the movie stays true to many occurrences in the play, however small changes have been made. The words or phrases used in each are the greatest difference because of the separate time frames. Phrases that are brought up from one to the other are for the purpose of better understanding the text. For example, the witches refer to Macbeth’s presence as “something wicked this way comes” which is altered in the movie as “It’s wicked out there.” Even though they have different meanings, the word “wicked” ties them together. The overall action of the movie follows right along with that of the play.
The most important emotions that we see in Macbeth are ambition, remorse, and fear. They are significant because they provoke Macbeth to do evil and cruel things. Ambition takes control of him earlier in the play when the witches tell him he is going to be king. After he already has done the deed, killed Duncan, he is remorseful for his actions. Out of fear for himself, Macbeth murdered Macduff’s family and killed Banquo.
“O worthiest cousin, the sin of my gratitude even now was heavy on me!”(I. i. 347) the king cannot repay him for what he has done for their kingdom. Macbeth is a highly respected warrior because he is loyal, trusted, and honest man. Macbeth is a vulnerable man; he is weak. Letting other people make decisions for him, he becomes more incapable of resisting how people will view him as a “loyal” soldier since he cannot follow through. In the film Macbeth the setting is right in the middle of war. Macbeth has held the enemy facing him, but he hesitates and looks at his soldiers for the okay to kill the enemy. With that being said, he is seriously self conscious and lets others makes the decisions for him. Before he is going to kill King Duncan, he speaks to himself in the If soliloquy. “If it were done when ’tis done, then ’twere well It were done quickly.”(I. vii. 343) in this quote it shows that he is truly evil since he wants it done quick and easy.
What is depression? According to MacGill (2015), depression is a mental health or mood disorder that triggers a constant feeling of unhappiness and loss of interest. In William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth, the main protagonist named Macbeth is subjected to depression after committing the crime of killing King Duncan with the aid and persuasion of his ambitious wife, Lady Macbeth. As the story progresses, Lady Macbeth also discloses her despair regarding the wicked and evil deeds that she gets involved in. Near the end, upon learning that his wife and young son are brutally slaughtered, the Scottish nobleman Macduff shows his melancholy as well. Similarly, in William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet, the leading character named Hamlet experiences loneliness
Noah Webster, author of Webster’s Dictionary, defines mood as the “temporary state of the mind in regard to passion or feeling“ and “a morbid or fantastic state of mind.” E. L. Thorndike and Clarence L. Barnhart, authors of Scott, Foresman Advanced Dictionary, define mood as “the overall atmosphere or prevailing emotional aura of a work.” Shakespeare’s Macbeth, especially the pivotal and ominous second act, exemplifies both denotations of mood. The act has an “overall atmosphere,” even though the mood shifts, while this mood places a sense of cliff-hanging anxiety at the beginning, an ambiance of hysterics towards the middle, a feeling of tragic realization directly following, and an unsure aura of occult extractions. Shakespeare cleverly uses six key elements to further shape and add to the mood: the characters, the imagery, the setting, the sounds, the characters’ actions, and the characters’ dialogue.
leads you with no doubt about what the plot of the story is to involve
Macbeth chooses the wrong path to accomplish his ambition. Killing Duncan is wrong and he knows it but can’t help himself. An example for dominance of power in addition to Macbeth can be presented in Brian De Palma’s movie Scarface. Al Pacino as Tony Montana creates excessive wealth from distributing cocaine because he thrives for power. As the movie progresses, the drugs make him crazy and he kills more and more people who die in violence followed by the main character. Similarly, Macbeth’s ambition for power becomes his weakness which finally brings tragedy to his character. He is a tragic hero because he can’t seem to help himself even though in the beginning he was good and was a hero in Scotland. Similarly to Dr. Mathur, Faith Nostbakken argues that “The witches do not completely determine Macbeth’s actions. If they did, Macbeth would simply be a victim rather than a tragic figure who suffers the consequences of his own choices. As he wades deeper and deeper into his own darkness, pulling the kingdom down with him, the weird sisters spur Macbeth to his own corruption…In the service of evil rather than good, they equivocate in their prophecies, encouraging destructive behavior.” (Understanding Macbeth
Within Macbeth the tragedy and demise of Macbeth is an important factor in determining his character as a tragic hero. However in order to elucidate on this point we need to define what is a tragedy. Aristotle within ‘Poetics’ highlighted what characteristics he believed to define tragedy these being;
One of the most important themes in Macbeth involves the witches' statement in Act 1, Scene1 that "fair is foul and foul is fair." (Act 1, Scene 1, Line 10) This phrase aptly describes the macabre status quo within the character Macbeth and without. When Macbeth and Banquo first see the weird sisters, Banquo is horrified by their hideous appearances. Conversely, Macbeth immediately began to converse with these universally known evil creatures. After hearing their prophecies, one can say that Macbeth considered the witches to be "fair" when in reality their intentions were quite "foul." Macbeth's possession of the titles of Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor and King of Scotland came by foul means. Macbeth became the Thane of Glamis by his father Sinel's death; he became Thane of Cawdor when the former namesake was executed for treason; and he was ordained King of Scotland after murdering the venerable Duncan. Thus, Macbeth has a rather ghastly way of advancing in life.
There are many differences in the novel and Rupert Goold's movie Macbeth. The differences in the movie plot and character development cause the audience to feel less sympathy with Macbeth than they do in the original tragedy. Rupert Goold's was unsuccessful in expressing the true tragedy to the audience. Macbeth is a very brave, strong and wise man, although in the movie he is portrayed as arrogant, shameful and barbarous which is why the audience does not have sympathy for him.
At the beginning of the film the Scottish have won a war and you see a
show Macbeth that if she is man enough to not be scared he should not
There are many questions concerning the atmosphere in William Shakespeare's Macbeth that this essay will answer: Is it realistic or unrealistic? Are there two atmospheres - one of purity and one of black magic? And many other questions.