What Are The Similarities Between The Haunting Of Hill House And Mise En Scene

1728 Words4 Pages

The memory of the past can bring pride or guilt, no matter which one it is, dwelling in the past for too long will entrap one into one's own illusion and lose the ability to distinguish fantasy and reality. In The Haunting of Hill House and Sunset Boulevard, the Gothic settings and characters in the stories draw out the deepest nightmare of Eleanor and Norma. While both characters of the novel and film share similar impact of Gothic settings and characters, they are different in terms of the contrasting experience of their illusion; specifically, what benefits and detriments their illusions have brought to them. This is important because dwelling in one's past isn't only harmful to oneself, it is also harmful to the others. The first similarity …show more content…

John Montague and Max von Mayerling, their influences further entrap Eleanor and Norma into their own illusions. Beginning in Eleanor's case, Dr. Montague controls the behaviour of all the character in the story since he is the one who gathers everyone to the haunted house to aid him in his research or investigation of the mystery behind the supernatural activity. His bedroom colour is yellow indicates that he acts as the beacon of light that guides the people around him in the darkest time which makes him the leading figure in the story. In some degree, Eleanor is controlled by Dr. Montague considering every step she takes is under the instruction of him from beginning to end. For instance, when she can't find the way to the Hill House she follows the direction provided in Dr. Montague's letter “as though he had been guiding her from some spot far away, moving her car with controls in his hands, it was done” (Jackson 16). And when he forces her to leave, once again he gives her precise instructions to where to go “You'll go to Hillsdale... In Hillsdale turn onto Route Five going east; at Ashton you will meet Route Thirty-nine, and that will take you home” (Jackson 178). It is clear that Eleanor's constant dependence on Dr. Montague exposes her vulnerability which suggests weak willpower. Eleanor's weak …show more content…

In order to fully understand the different outcome of Eleanor and Norma, the internal issues of the characters should also be considered; specifically, how their pasts affect their psychological and mental states in the present. Prior to Eleanor's invitation to the Hill House, she is forced to spend eleven years of her life looking after her invalid mother, this frustrates her because it prevents her from having a normal societal life like the others with the same age. In some degree, the confinement of her mother interrupts her natural psychological development at that time when she is twenty-one years old. While living in the Hill House, Eleanor is constantly haunted by the dream of the former distressing experience with her mother. Regardless whether there are ghosts in the story, these negative psychological implications of Eleanor suggest that she blames herself for the death of her mother even though there is no direct evidence pointing to her. With this in mind, Eleanor's illusion is the only tool that brings her peace and hopes to sustain in this world of despair. The moment when she is banished from the Hill House, she loses hope because she has nowhere to go, no place to feel home. In the story, she tells the readers that “what I want in all this world is peace, a quiet spot to lie and think, a quiet spot

Open Document