Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
The media, weight and body image
Overweight as a social problem
Stereotypes about overweight people
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
The article Weight Bias in the Media: A Review of Recent Research by Rheanna N. Ata and J. Kevin Thompson was about how the media tends to stigmatize overweight people. There are two terms that come out in literature very often weight bias and stigmatization. In a culture that seems to emphasize thinness, weight bias has become a form of prejudice that seems to be widely accepted by many people. The media has a lot of influence on the beliefs, attitudes, and social norms that deal with weight. The media tends to stereotype obese characters and idealizes body types. Usually in the media body types for males and females are different, females are always shown to be thin, while males are portrayed as muscular and in good shape. In cartoons characters …show more content…
that were overweight were associated with being unattractive, mean, and unhappy. In sitcoms for children overweight characters are portrayed in a more favorable light. However, when a character was considered to be unattractive or friendless it was usually a overweight character. Compared to other shows children sitcoms are at least making an effort to have realistic body weight portrayals. Kids who use more media like play video games, and read magazines more than other kids tend to have more stigmatized beliefs about overweight kids. Overall whether it be reality television, newspapers, magazines, cartoons, sitcoms, or video games they all tend to stigmatize overweight people and can lead to biased stereotypes. The article mentioned how overweight people are often portrayed as unhappy or unattractive in the media.
However, the article was more broad than specific, I feel that the article could have focused on the differences between overweight people of different ethnicities more and how they were portrayed in the media. The organic activity we did in class about the magazine ads was a good example of portrayals of people in the media. Both of the ads I found had young skinny women advertising the product. The one overweight looking person in one of the ads was doing an ad for a type of medication. This ad just further encouraged the stigmatization that overweight people tend to be unhealthy which is not necessarily true. I agree with the article that the media does have an influence in the way that people see overweight individuals. While, the paper was only about how the media affects peoples stereotypes against overweight people I believe there could also be an influence from friends and family. Friends and family can have a very big psychological effect on a person especially if they get made to feel bad for being overweight. Much of the negative comments that affect a persons self esteem come from friends and family and that has a big effect on their self esteem. I feel that the article focused more on the effect the media has on children than adults I think a good idea would have been to focus on adults as
well.
Hargreaves, D.A., & Tiggemann, M. (2003). Female "thin ideal" media images and boys' attitudes toward girls. Sex roles, 49(9/10), 539-544.
At first, I agree with Goodman’s argument and I think that due to the impact of media, people's aesthetic standard began to change and more and more people begin to pay more attention to lose weight nowadays. And in my opinion, the most obvious part that women are affected by the impact of media, especially for the actors. For example, as Goodman points out, 15% of high school girls who vomited for weight control increased 5 times. It shows girls were worrying about their weight, and it lead to make them to suffer eating disorders. From my personal experience, I also would like to use media to find what is the most fashion hairstyle or cloth brand every month. And it will make me to decide what stuff I want to buy. Also, I think I am a member of control weight, because every day I would like to keep a good image to others. So as a result of control weight, I have the same problem of eating disorders as well. Besides, the...
Robinson, T., M. Callister, and T. Jankoski. "Portrayal of Body Weight on Children's Television Sitcoms: A Content Analysis." Body Image 5.2 (2008): 141-51. Web. 30 Sept. 2013.
Interest in the social aspects of obesity is nothing new. Jeffrey Sobal has written extensively about the social and psychological consequences of obesity , including the stigmatisation and discrimination of obese and even overweight individuals (Sobal 2004).
Moon, Amy. "A Culture Obsessed with Thinness Propagates Misconceptions About Obesity." SF Gate (8 Apr. 2008). Rpt. in How Should Obesity be Treated? Ed. Stefan Kiesbye. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2009. At Issue. Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 14 Apr. 2011.
Nio, T. (2003). Cultivation and social comparison of the thin-ideal syndrome: The effects of media exposure on body image disturbance and the state self-esteem of college women. School of Journalism in the Graduate Scho, 105-113.
Media has more of an effect than people realize on how people think about themselves, especially body shape. Social media, television, and magazines all encourage low self-esteem regarding body image and eating disorders. The media is a major factor in young boys and girls developing eating disorders; when surrounded by media for hours a day filled with commercials encouraging weight loss and models that are unhealthily skinny, it is inevitable to feel insecure about your body shape and self image and in some cases, results in developing an eating disorder. The frequent use of media also contributes to the fact that people become influenced by what they see in the media. 8 out of 10 Americans watch television on a daily basis.
From newspapers, magazines, television, movies, and the Internet, people are connected to the media in so many ways every day. Media plays a huge impact on daily life, telling the public what the newest trends are, events that are happening in day-to-day life, and scandalous stories of elite individuals involving politics, fame, and money. From young children to middle aged adults, people are constantly fixated on the images the media portrays for how they should look. “Body image is defined as “perceptions of and attitudes toward one’s own physical appearance” (Burlew & Shurts, 2013, p. 1). The media has an impact on how society and individuals view themselves and each other.
Greenberg, Bradley. Eastin, Matthew. “Portrayals of overweight and obese individuals on commercial television” American Journal of Public Health 98.3 (Aug 2003): 1342-8. ProQuest. Web. 12/26/2013
People react differently depending on their own traits. Studies have shown that women identify the media as the major source of the perceived social pressure to maintain a thin body image. Male body image suffers as well. When men are exposed to unrealistic male bodies, they can suffer from the same symptoms as females. People should not let the media negatively influence their bodies. The public needs to view the media for what it’s worth…pure entertainment. Media’s depiction of a “normal” body type portrays a standard of beauty that is unattainable. Both women and men are suffering from trying to reach these unattainable goals and are suffering from low self-esteem, depression and eating disorders. This is a huge epidemic and hopefully one day it will change. The media needs to promote healthy lifestyles and show men and women of all shapes and sizes that they can feel good about themselves. The “real size” people in the world, will then be able to stop feeling pressured by the media to obtain a certain standard body
In society today the media misrepresents a lot of things giving people the wrong impression and false beliefs that something is what it isn’t or gives them the belief that they might be able to achieve something that is not very likely to be achieved. Media today is all about making money and trying to persuade people to consume as much as they can. The paper that you are about to read focuses on how the media incorrectly portrays weight lifting and working out in the gym in general. They show misleading photos and advertisement that could give a person the false impression that working out is easy and idea of the perfect body is only a couple pushups away. And also gender stereotype weightlifting makes females seem weaker and inferior to men in the weight room. After reading this paper there should be a better understanding of how the media incorrectly portrays these ideas.
Nio, T. (2003). Cultivation and social comparison of the thin-ideal syndrome: The effects of media exposure on body image disturbance and the state self-esteem of college women. School of Journalism in the Graduate Scho, 105-113.
Herbozo, Sylvia, Stacey Tantleff-Dunn, Jessica Gokee-Larose, and J.Kevin Thompson. “Beauty and Thinness Messages in Children’s Media: A Content Analysis.” Eating Disorders 12 (2004): 21-34. Print.
The elimination of media bias is pretty much impossible due to the fact that large corporations head the media, and the heads of most large corporations are white men, but by the implementation of certain strategies it would be a move in the right direction. Media bias is a problem, though it may not be blatant, it is serious because it could be helping to form people?s beliefs about others. People are scared of the unknown, and by giving them a certain portrayal of someone they have had no interaction with; it can have detrimental effects. Who knows actually what impact media bias has had on the nation as a whole. How do we know whether or not media bias has made an individual not get or even lose a job? How do we know how many friendships media bias has stopped from even being initiated? Hopefully one day we will be able to recognize what media bias is, only then will we be able to begin the process of fighting to put an end to it. Only then will we be able to create a fair, unbiased media that is diverse and one that encompasses the ideas of an ideal media.
Stereotypes are widely held ideas that are able to affect the way we think, which is part of who we are. The media is able to influence a large number of people easily due to its wide reach and large audience. Some examples of stereotypes that are shaped by the media include racially discriminating stereotypes, gender stereotypes and the perception of beauty, which affects body image. However, I will only be analyzing one of the stereotypes that the media has shaped, body image. The media often presents messages and images that tells us ‘we can be content only if we are slim’ for instance, by presenting models that are photo-shopped to look slimmer than they actually do in order to attract more consumers and present the ‘ideal’ image of a person’s size. Statistics show that