Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparing good people to hills like white elephants
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Comparing good people to hills like white elephants
In “Good People” by David Foster Wallace and Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants,” two young couples are faced with an unplanned pregnancy. Sheri Fisher may be sympathetic because Lane Dean Jr. gives her little input in a decision within their discussions, he is unsure as to whether or not he loves her, and because Sheri has made big plans for her life ahead before the unplanned pregnancy. I contend that Jig deserves more sympathy because the American is persistent in his persuasion toward the operation, his love is unjustified, and because Jig has not made plans for her life with or without the child.
Sheri Fisher, on the other hand, has little idea on how Lane Dean Jr. feels toward her decisions. gaining some sympathy. She has little clue because he is unsure, therefore he tells her nothing. Lane Dean Jr. “did not know what to do” (218) which is understandable because he is young. Both families (Sheri’s and Jr.’s) come from very protestant religious backgrounds. Sheri and he have prayed on numerous occasions about the abortion, yet still, he was unsure. Lane Dean told her again and again “that he’d go with her and be there with her” (216). But after reassuring her a second time she laughed because he could not actually be there in the operating room; he would be in the waiting room the entire time. This is the one part of the story where Lane Dean makes it apparent that he wants the abortion. But “he pretended that not saying aloud what he knew to be right and true was for her sake, was for the sake of her needs and feelings” (217). Sheri has made plans for her future and he is afraid the bringing a baby up in their lives will ruin her chances of becoming a nurse. Because Lane Dean Jr. does not speak up on his opinio...
... middle of paper ...
...she doesn’t want to. She tells him that she will have the operation done because she doesn’t care about herself (592). Jig for her unsaid want for the world (593) and her desire to not be alone, but because she feels she can not have both, I sympathize for her.
Although Wallace and Hemingway envision two young couples facing an unplanned pregnancy, only one couple gains my sympathy. Wallace’s Sheri Fisher in “Good People” is making her decision based off little insight from Lane Dean Jr., a feeling of lack of honest love from him, and her plans for her future of success. Jig, in Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants,” is making her decision based off a persistent American who claims he loves her, but it appears otherwise, and because she hasn’t made plans for her future other than being with him. Being the naive young girl that she is, Jig deserves my sympathy.
In Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” the character Jig is submissive to her counterpart The American Man, who is encouraging her to have an abortion. While Jig is not sure what she wants, she does not wish to press the subject of the operation because The American Man is intent upon persuading her to go through with the procedure. Throughout this story Jig’s helplessness, indecisiveness, and her lack of education become apparent, although by the end of the story she becomes confident, decisive, and ultimately takes back control of her decisions and life.
The main characters’ conflict over not wanting the same things in life is the root of the women’s disillusionment. The theme is furthered by the complication of the antagonist manipulation of the Jig’s feelings for him. Similar to Cisneros’s written work, Hemingway uses the narrative point of view to illuminate the growing disillusionment the women feels about not being able to have everything if she terminates the pregnancy. Hemingway leads the audience to this conclusion when the protagonist states “no, we can’t it isn’t ours anymore… Once they take it away, you never get it back” when referring to her disappointment that the antagonist will not change his mind and they can no longer have everything they ever wanted
.... The American was pushy and stubborn and Jig would not stand up for what she really wants in life. Towards the end of the story the author leaves the reader wondering if she did follow through the operation. And if she did, did their relationship went back to normal?
‘Hills Like White Elephants’ is a short story authored by Ernest Hemingway about an American and a girl named Jig. In the story, the two are sitting in a train station waiting for the train to Madrid. While they wait, they have an intense ongoing debate on whether or not to abort Jig. At the end of the story, the train is about to arrive and the man carries luggage on the tracks as they prepare to leave. The end of the story does not clearly define the outcome of its decision. She said I feel good at the end of the story - happiness is a central theme of the story, but we wonder if she went through with the operation. The paper discusses the manner in which symbolism has been employed in the story to communicate about an abortion, the couple is considering to go through.
The theme of physical and emotional burdens has a strong connection to Hemingway 's life. Hemingways alcoholism was more of a physical burden as it caused him to have liver disease whereas his fight with depression was more so of an emotional burden. However, the physical and emotional burdens in “Hills Like White Elephants” is focused around a completely different topic than depression or alcoholism. “Hills Like White Elephants” main focus is on a woman named Jig and her lover whose name is never told. All the readers know it that he is an American man. Jig is currently pregnant with what seems to be an unplanned and unwanted child, at least from the point of view of Jigs boyfriend. The couple begins to talk about the pregnancy and, at first, it seems that they have both agreed that the child should be aborted. However, as Jig and her boyfriend continue their conversation about the baby it becomes painfully clear that Jig does not want to have an abortion. Instead, the only reason that she is even considering the abortion is because her American lover does not want the baby and continuously tries to persuade her into having the abortion by emphasizing how simple the procedure will be. Jig’s boyfriend notices how apprehensive she is and tells her that if she truly doesn’t want to do it he’ll support her decision but also tells her that her having the abortion will make their relationship happy once again. Once again insinuating that it is the best decision. Jigg agrees to the abortion but only because she says she “does not care about herself”. Jiggs agreement to the abortion while also saying that the reason she is agreeing is due to her not caring about herself shows just how heavy of an emotional burden she is carrying. Jig loves her boyfriend and wants him to be happy, however, she wants to keep her baby. This causes
The subtle manipulative control that the American has over Jig’s thoughts and actions transforms itself into a complete control over her decision. After finding out that she is pregnant, Jig has a difficult time weighing her options because of her dependence o...
Jig asks her lover if he will worry about the procedure, and he responds by saying he considers the treatment simplistic. In response Jig states, “Then I’ll do it. Because I don’t care about me.” This statement further asserts that Jig is just looking to appease her male counterpart and put her own feelings aside in order to remain with her lover. Jig doesn’t want to lose her current relationship, and in order to do this, she is attempting to withhold her true emotions and avoid seeming hysterical. Additionally, Jig is continually pressured to not worry by her overbearing lover, because all their problems will be solved after the operation. The man states early on in the story that, “[they’ll] be fine afterwards. Just like [they] were before,” and claims that the only problem that exists between them is this decision about whether or not Jig should have an abortion. At this point, Jig does not want to face the decision to either not receive the treatment, which could destroy her romantic relationship, or to go through with the operation. Due to the societal gender roles telling Jig she is a sentimental woman, Jig agreeably states, “I’ll do it,” in order to end the conversation and keep her true feelings deep within herself. She even goes on to argue that she “feels fine,” although it is
The plot of this story revolves around a decision that two characters, Lane Dean Jr. and Sheri, are forced to make. Lane and Sheri are both Christians who are not an official couple, but clearly haves feeling for each other, sitting in a park bench analyzing the choices they must make. Sheri “ was serious in her faith and values” (Wallace 217) and already has a stereotype towards her on how she must be a good person. Sheri and Lane although not a couple or married, become pregnant. With Sheri being very smart and serious about school abortion is the decision she is leaning towards with an appointment already set. As Lane and Sheri sit at the “ picnic table at the park by the lake”...
We learn that the woman in this story is called Jig is worried about an operation, and she is making the effort to talk her way into it or out of it. Her male friend, on the other hand, is out to give her support. The story presents the theme of loss of love. In spite of the transparent assertions of the man assertions, it is clear that he needs Jig to abort so that they can continue living their life as before. The approach that Hemingway uses the theme of love and hate is the loss of love. The “Hills like white elephants” may be referring to the baby who is the risk of death though abortion. The couple also seems to be looking at the hills as the lady defines them as being clean and beautiful. Also, white elephants can mean an expensive and great gift. So about this story the white elephant is the baby who is a joy and wonderful gift as well as a burden. The woman views the baby as an expensive gift because she will have to lose her boyfriend in the exchange of the gift. The baby also means a huge price to pay and also to care for the baby alone requires hard work. Through the story does not provide the topic of sexuality in the case of the other two poems I have discussed above, the effects of desire rein this story. The jig is convinced that she can have the world as she looks out to the mountains. The man represents a fear and restriction that are within
We all have expectations, something that we expect as a result of something we did, but what about the unexpected something that we did but never fathomed the consequences? We often times call the unexpected a “curve ball” and that’s exactly what happened to the couples in the short essays “Hills Like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway and “Good People” by David Foster Wallace, they were thrown a curve ball. The couples in the short stories have extremely hard decisions to make. The woman have the most important decision to make and the men have to decide to support the women in the lives or make a decision to move on. Sheri will most likely have her baby because she cancelled the abortion and she has bonded with her baby in her womb, and Lane Dean Jr. will marry her because he realizes he loves her. On the other hand Jig will most likely have the abortion because she fears the American will leave her if she doesn’t, and the American will stay with her because now they can travel without a baby spoiling his plans.
In the short stories, “Popular Mechanics” by Raymond Carver, and “Hills Like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway, the employed settings, protagonists, and conflicts create a common yet distinct storyline between the characters of incompatible existence. The male roles in each story play the victim in their personal belief. During the plot of “Hills Like White Elephants” the female protagonist has inner conflict of actually wanting to follow through with an accidental pregnancy, but is pressureed by her husband/boyfriend’s selfish decision of wanting an abortion performed on her. The male role in “Popular Mechanics” was not loyal to his wife, and when the wife snapped back he did not take it well and argument broke out over their young baby.
“Hills like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway is about a couple, the American and Jig, who contemplate whether or not to have an abortion. The premise of the story seems simple enough, but the outcome is highly debated. Critics argue that the baby was kept by the couple ( Renner ) and others claim the baby was aborted.( Fletcher ) Others have even simplified the story, claiming that the issue was not resolved because the couple was drunk by the end of the story. ( Sipiora ) Although the conclusion is in questions many have agreed with the idea that the couples relationship would be changed and would end prematurely. ( Wyche ) Dialogue is the main technique in conveying this argument but we can only understand the complexity of Hemingway’s work by looking at the story as a whole. By looking at the many symbols, intrinsically and
In the story, "Hills like White Elephants" written by Ernest Hemingway, the main character Jig faces a life changing event, abortion. The struggles with the complications of abortion concern and desire Jig to want to keep the baby. Bringing a new life into the world is a long time commitment and it is something Jig feels she can treasure forever. However, her companion attempted to persuade her in another direction, to proceed with the abortion. As naïve as he is, he feels his persuasion can overcome Jig's desires. Jig is a sarcastic yet reserved woman, who desires to bring a new life into the world, even if her companion does not approve; she knows what is best.
When a woman gets pregnant, she and her partner make a serious decision whether they should give birth to the unborn child or abort it. However, sometimes every couple can have a different outlook about giving birth or aborting because every male and female has his or her ways of thinking. In “Hills Like White Elephants,” the author, Ernest Hemingway tells a story of an American man and his girlfriend, Jig, who have a disagreement in the train station on the subject of whether to keep the unborn child or to abort. However, the author uses binary opposition of life and death to portray the polemic argument a couple encounters regarding abortion. As a symbol for the binary opposition of life and death, he represents the couple’s expressions, feelings, and the description of nature.
Another issue that is discussed in this story is abortion and two opposing views. When the conversation turns from the hills to the operation one is able to comprehend the mentality of the woman. "Then what will we do afterwards?" (465) shows the woman is concerned about what will occur after the operation. "And if I do it you will be happy and things will be like they were and you will love me" (465). Here, the woman implies she wants the reassurance that he will still be there after the operation, because an abortion places an emotional strain on the on the woman.