Trope In 'Clotel, Or The President's Daughter'

1106 Words3 Pages

William Wells Brown’s Clotel, or The President’s Daughter could read as a pure romance if it were not a slave narrative; some parts still strongly resemble typical mid-nineteenth century romances, meant to appeal primarily to white women. All of the protagonists are women, the most prevalent being the eponymous Clotel and her sister Althesa, both of whom are mixed-race and born to Currer, a “bright mulatt[a],” and Thomas Jefferson (Brown 49-50). Clotel has “a complexion as white as most of those who were waiting with a wish to become her purchasers’ her features as finely defined as any of her sex of pure Anglo-Saxon” and, though Althesa’s color is not as explicitly described, she presumably has an appearance similar to her sister’s. The novel …show more content…

Spiers, a white man, who is entirely oblivious to this phenomenon. He insists that sun and outdoor play would be beneficial to his daughter Natalie despite Mrs. Spiers’ objections. When Mrs. Spiers tells Natalie to “call [her] daughter Miss Olivia,” as she “requires that of all inferiors”, Mr. Spiers is not present (34). I he were, he may not have been as concerned about Olivia tarnishing the image of her white femininity, and have subsequently talked Mrs. Spiers down again. Later, Mr. Spiers’ absence opens the door for Natalie to jump in and save the day. When this ordeal is over, he allows Natalie to have a continued relationship with the Spiers for nearly a decade, referring to her as “the plucky little girl who rowed [his] wife and daughter out of a death-trap, by Jove!” (38). Mr. Spiers is not uncomfortable with Natalie in the same way Mrs. Spiers is, quite possibly because he does not recognize her version of womanhood, or her femininity in any form, as a threat to Olivia’s white feminine heterosexuality. This falls into a historical pattern of white men in the 18th and 19th centuries either simply not realizing that their wives and daughters have erotic relationships with other women or accepting these relations as entirely harmless (Smith-Rosenberg). Though Mrs. Spiers seems to believe

Open Document