Equal Society or Dictatorship?
As the people we are now, we take everything for granted such as freedom and our individuality. But what if we lived in a restrictive society like Ayn Rand's Anthem. Would we be broken down until we could no longer think or be able to do anything for ourselves? Would they keep us so exhausted to the point they knew we wouldn't have the energy to rebel and form a new society better fit for man? What had to have happened in Ayn Rand's Anthem to make the people abandon everything of the past civilization and burn every piece of its existence? Why is everyone treated equal except but the few who run the society? As far as I'm concerned and having read all of the book, I get the impression that Ayn Rand's Anthem
…show more content…
is more about a dictatorship than a true utopia. So what have the leaders of this new society forced people to live by?
From the moment they are born, the children are placed in homes with other kids their age. They are taught that "we" is the only acceptable word to use when speaking about themselves or their brothers. They are punished when they act out or do transgressions against their brothers. Those who the leaders know are more intelligent and surpassing than the average citizen are treated with cruelty so the will in them is shattered and they think they can't do anything without others with them.
Even though it wasn't really mentioned in the book, I believe there may have been handicaps placed on people who were too intelligent, tall, and beautiful. For example Equality was a very handsome, tall, intelligent man that the leaders knew would be dangerous if he ever figured out he could do tasks on his own, so that's why they gave him the job as a Street Sweeper rather than appointing him to a position on the Council of Scholars. But is this a fair thing to do to others just because they might be better? No it's not but they did it to protect the society from any
…show more content…
change. Mentioning change in such a society is like a transgression all on its own. But why is change such a bad thing? Everybody needs a little bit of switch up here and there, but in a society of equality, change is made of pure evil to them. They worked so hard in demolishing everything of the past world that they won't risk any chance of them possibly becoming like the society of the past. Granted sometimes change isn't always the best for everyone, but when something as big as electricity is brought to people who only use candles you'd think they might want to try this new form of light. They may have if numerous people had invented this together, but since only one person made the device by themselves, it was shot down immediately due to individuality being one of the greatest transgressions. So why is individuality so frowned upon?
In the leaders minds being alone to yourself could allow you to be able to think on your own and form ideas that could possibly ruin the society. So the leaders decided that since some people are so curious to be alone and do things on their own, they would be punished. But some citizens pushed their limits even more. Those that showed too much individuality and decided to learn the forbidden word were burned at the pyre in front of the whole town so that everyone could see what might happen to them if they step out of line. Children were brought to these as well so they could learn to be proper citizens and have fear in their hearts to not act out against the society that "cares" and "cherishes"
them. So why do I think this society is like a dictatorship? From a young age everyone is taught to fear almost everything, especially change. Fear is stricken in their hearts when they are taken to see people burned for the transgressions they have committed. And just like a dictatorship everyone is put into a specific role so they can't mess up the society or over throw it if they have too much power. They also don't like individuality just like in a dictatorship because it could ruin the "perfect" community. But this is not not how mankind is suppose to be, they need freedom and individuality in order to develop themselves and form a healthy society where everyone can express their feelings. But just like in a true dictatorships people can't do this; those who do try to be individuals are either killed or they try to escape due to the horrible cruelty they were forced to live in. Would you try to escape if you were forced to live with these horrors or just try to continue living in these conditions? Well if it was me, I would personally try to escape and face the dangers of the wilderness because it couldn't be as bad as living in a society full of brain washed people. In the book, people who ran away were immediately doomed to an inevitable death. But is that true, no but it's what they taught the, as children that they can't survive alone and must always be in a group in order to survive.
Ayn Rand, in Anthem, illustrates a futuristic, socialist society. In the novel, Rand destroys any sense of individuality and describes the social setbacks endured after living ‘only for the brotherhood’. The individual person fails to exist and is but a ‘we’ and recognized by a word and a series of numbers rather than a name. Additionally, she describes the horrors encountered within this different system of life: from reproduction methods to punishments. Through the life of Equality 7-2521, Rand demonstrates a person’s journey from obedience to exile in this socialist society. Throughout the entire novel, Rand criticizes Marxist theory as she demonstrates socialism’s failure to suppress revolution, thwart material dialectic, and its detriment to humanity.
The book Anthem is a book that can be perceived many various ways. To me, Anthem is about an outstandingly smart young man, named Equality 7-2521
A captivating novelette in which a man’s priority is to serve only for his brothers, Ayn Rand’s Anthem illustrates a society that has suffered the ghastly consequences of collectivism. She depicts an oppressive culture in which the word “I” is unheard of and men belong to the collective “We.” Men’s lives are determined through the Council of Vocations, a group that maintains a powerful dictatorship by subjugating the public from the beginning of their lives. The idea that “If you are not needed by your brother men, there is no reason for you to burden the earth with your bodies” (Chapter 1) has been forced into average mindset of the vehemently maintained society. In contrast, Rand mocks the totalitarian civilization through the main character Equality. Since he was born, Equality possessed a quick mind and constantly strayed apart from his peers. Through his life, he shows an unwilling behavior to conform not only to his name, but also to the rules of society. After he is found guilty of independent thought, he is sadistically beaten and dragged into the Palace of Corrective Detention, an unguarded jail that castigates the public of their wrongdoings. Shackles are unnecessary as a result of the brainwashed society and their compliance to obey orders, which consequently allows Equality to escape. In a collective society, citizens are denied their inalienable right of individualism, which ultimately eliminates all thoughts of opposition. Through their submission, the presence of their souls vanishes and society deems the collectivist tenet true. The lack of guards and old locks in the Palace of corrective Detention symbolize the evils that result from a collectivist society.
Ayn Rand’s Anthem is a politically satirical novel is set in a future society that is so highly collectivized that the word “I” has been banned. The world is governed by various councils who believe that man’s sole reason for existence is to enforce the Great Truth “that all men are one and that there is no will save the will of all men together” (Rand, 20). Any indication of an individual’s independent spirit is swiftly and brutally put down, with the transgressors being punished with severe prison sentences or even death.
The dystopia depicted in Anthem could quite easily be considered Ayn Rand’s commentary on society. It puts into perspective the downfalls of societal trends and putting others above oneself. The novella itself is a satire of Collectivism, which can be seen in examples of Communism. Rand’s philosophy of Objectivism includes ideas of immutable facts, rationalist mentality, self-prioritization, and a capitalist society (ARI, n.d.). Her ideas are shown in a variety of aspects throughout the novella. Oppression felt due to the collective mentality is the most prominent of the ideas shown. Another aspect that is important to note is Equality 7-2521’s natural tendency to struggle against the restrictions set upon
The government’s authority over several aspects of society displays its corruption and causes more people to become conformists who lack egotism in Ayn Rand’s novel Anthem. The government chooses the occupations of all of the citizens. It is the Council of Vocation’s position to decide everyone’s job, thus suppressing the right of the people to freedom of choice. The teachers, who had been appointed by the Councils, inform the students to “Dare not choose in your minds the work you would like to do when you leave the Home of the Students. You shall do that which the Council of Vocations shall prescribe for you. For the Council of Vocations knows in its great wisdom where you are needed by your brother men, better than you can know it in your unworthy little
People in every Society are placed in categories according to gender, religion, race, and age from which one of these categories includes social class. In the novel Anthem by Ayn Rand, people are placed in social classes according to the government's liking and instead of race, age, gender etc their social class depends on the job they are given by the government. This was done to treat everyone equally in order to keep peace in the society. However, sometimes equality can cause rebellion and this idea is portrayed through the protagonist of the novel, Equality 7-2521. Ever since the unmentionable times had caused destruction to the society of Anthem, the government had taken away all the free will and individuality of its people.
Why can a plant not grow in the shade? When a population is kept in the dark, no progress is made. One example of a community kept in ignorance is from the novella Anthem by Ayn Rand, a place where there is total control by the government. This technology deprived world insinuates that science and technology can spur rebellion, division, and change, showing that technological progress develops from the freedom of oppression.
Anthem is a book full to the brim of symbolism. Some of it is clear to see and others you have to really pay attention to capture. Anthem is not a hard book to understand, but it can still be difficult to grasp the full meaning of it. The meaning of which is elusive at points, slipping between your fingers and resting on the pages in plain view. Unity, we, I, Ego, it all plays a major part in this book along with the symbolism of things.
Ayn Rand's Anthem shows us her view of our world united under what seems to be communist rule. For example their view of right and wrong; which Anthem portrays is a system of very strict rules which mainly make sure that everyone is involved in a collective role within the society in this system no one is considered an individual or that they can even think as an individual.
The word collectivism often makes people cringe. Overall, there is a general fear of not being able to make personal decisions in America. According to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, collectivism can be defined as; emphasis on collective rather than individual action or identity (“Collectivism”). In Anthem, Ayn Rand describes an extreme collectivist society. Although Anthem’s society seems extremely surreal, aspects of its collectivist society closely mirror today’s society.
in his world it was believed that ?What was not thought by all men cannot
It is a rare conception where a human being is completely and utterly alone. One problem we tend to overlook due to our primitive ideals of staying as a group, is the fact of us becoming solely to that group. In the book Anthem ,by Ayn Rand, a man named Equality 7-2521 sees this problem evolve and how it becomes a nuisance to his society. The book has made me open my mind up to the ideals of doing things for yourself and not always for those around you. The feeling of the story showing a world where many are brought down for being unique and talented hurts me as I imagine a time where all are mere specs of the world. The book hits the hard points of what can easily go wrong with our society if we decide to go over the line. I can see a life
Throughout the book “Anthem” the city has many rules and controls. Such as, not loving any person over another. Not saying the forbidden word “I”. Not stealing from another. With these rules and controls, Ayn Rand created a collective society, but with the idea of a utopian society.
The infamous author Ayn Rand dedicated her life wholly to the study and furthering of her political dogma, Objectivism, the uniting theme throughout all of her published literary works. One of the most obtrusive examples is her novella Anthem, which is set in a futuristic yet inept dystopia that is entirely founded on principles of collectivism. Page by page Rand’s sentiments become glaringly obvious, subsequently causing the reader to question her motivation behind this story, their own agreement with her egocentric philosophy, how Christianity aligns with every aspect of it, and if, overall, it was adeptly written.