The Tempest: Is Prospero Good Or Evil?

981 Words2 Pages

Tempest: Is Prospero Good or Evil? To be able to answer this question we must first understand why see Prospero as good or evil. It is fair to say that Prospero is a main protagonist to the plot of Shakespeare’s Tempest. It is due to Prospero's role as a key figure in the play that has put him under so much scrutiny. Many different Shakespearean critics have their own view of Prospero and those that read or see the play also have their own opinion of how they would have seen Prospero. Supporting either argument there must be evidence that backs up each of the analysis of Prospero's character and why they see it in such a way. Having been usurped and wrecked on an Island Prospero and his young daughter Miranda has to settle. It is here …show more content…

Again it is not clear to see if Prospero's intentions are for his own good or the good of his daughter. Throughout the play Prospero it seems is seeking revenge for what has been done to him in the past. We see that Prospero sees himself as an 'instrument of judgement', being able to pass sentence on those who have done him harm in the past. Prospero, with the aid of Ariel, can reach anyone he wants and cause them the most terrible pain, be it physical or mental torture. In act 2 scene 2 it appears to see that Caliban the native that had helped Prospero to survive on the Island has now become Prospero's slave. Caliban is tortured by Prospero so much that he is scared when he sees Stephano and Trinculo and mistakes them for Prospero's magic spirits that have come to torment him again, 'Do not torment me prithee. I'll bring the wood home faster' (A2 Sc2 …show more content…

However, he has what seems valued reasons for doing such things. In Caliban's case Caliban had tried to have sex with Miranda and Prospero was simply punishing Caliban for the crime which he had committed. For Alonso the King of Naples, his son was not lost Prospero was using him in another 'game' opposite of the Island and Prospero had reason to let him suffer for a while as Milan and Naples had always been enemies, and Alonso had helped Prospero be usurped. Prospero uses people to get the end result that he wants. In the case of Miranda and Ferdinand Prospero is playing them off against each other in order to get them to act how he wants them to. Prospero strictly orders Miranda not to tell Ferdinand her name knowing that she will just to disobey his

Show More
Related

  • The Tempest Quotes About Vengeance And Justice

    610 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prospero sought for vengeance toward his brother for many reasons. A reason would be that how Prospero’s brother expelled him and his daughter to sea so his brother instead could rule and because Prospero can perform magic. One evidence that they were exiled toward the sea is the ship they arrived on and the reason why is because Prospero’s brother wanted to be the heir. Prospero sent his spirits to play and torment his brother and his comrades; in addition to the slave who turned on him later on in the story. But as the days pass on, Prospero ends up feeling bad for what he has been doing upon his rivals.

    Read More

  • The Tempest Prospero Revenge Quotes

    275 Words  | 1 Pages

    Prospero is a very powerful man who is out for revenge. At this point in the play, and in his life, he seems to only care about himself and his daughter. He is bitter at the loss of his Kingdome from his own family and she has been the only one who is there for him which isn’t exactly by choice. It is easy to see how hurt he is from what has been done to both him and his daughter. For the first time he is telling Miranda about the journey that led them to the island, “I pray thee, mark me /I thus neglect worldly ends, all dedicated / To closeness and the bettering of my mind” (1.2.107-110). While he is telling his daughter this story he is making sure he is being seen as innocent, saying he was just trying to better himself when this happened.

    Read More

  • Prospero, S Use Of Epiphany In Shakespeare's The Tempest

    1062 Words  | 3 Pages

    Prospero’s relationships with others prior to his personal epiphany were highly unpleasant to say the least. It was imperative that Shakespeare wrote these relationships this way to emphasize Prospero’s inner angst. Prospero’s angst stemmed from being betrayed by his brother.

    Read More

  • The Tempest And Julio Cortazar's 'The Night Face Up'

    1016 Words  | 3 Pages

    This is presented through the emotive language of Miranda “I have suffered with those that are suffering”, through the empathy that is displayed by Miranda the violent action of Prospero on the ship that carries Antonio and the royals are demonstrated. Through this violent action Prospero demonstrates his desire to get revenge on all the people that have harmed him and his daughter. However, Prospero also commands Ariel to protect the people on board, coupled with this, the metaphor “The government I cast upon my brother and to my state grew stranger” shows that he is on the path to self-enlightenment due to his acknowledgement of his own downfall. Prospero through the order to protect the people and the use of the personal pronoun in the metaphor displays that he has identified his own role in his downfall. By accepting his role he is able to start to forgive Antonio and progress on the path to enlightenment. However, he is presented to not have reached complete self-enlightenment through his vengeful treatment of Caliban seen through the metaphor “A devil, a born devil on whose nature, nurture can never stick”. Through this metaphor, he illustrates that he

    Read More

  • Vengeance and Forgiveness in Shakespeare's The Tempest

    1049 Words  | 3 Pages

    Here, the imaginative sympathy for the sufferings of others leads to an active intervention based upon "virtue" rather than "vengeance." This is a key recognition in the play: virtue expressed in forgiveness is a higher human attribute than vengeance. And in the conclusion of the play, Prospero does not even mention the list of crimes against him. He simply offers to forgive and accept what has happened to him, in a spirit of reconciliation. Unlike other Shakespeare plays, the ending of The Tempest requires neither the death nor the punishment of any of the parties.

    Read More

  • Prospero’s Abuse of Power in Shakespeare's The Tempest

    1318 Words  | 3 Pages

    He takes advantage of his authority over the people and situations he encounters while wearing a facade of integrity and compassion to disguise his wily intentions and to retain love and respect. In Act I of the play, Prospero finally tells Miranda the woeful story of how she and he arrived on the island. From the beginning, Prospero plays his subjects and his sympathetic audience as pawns in his game of manipulation. He explains that twelve years ago he was the Duke of Milan, but being enthralled with his studies, he left most of the governmental responsibilities to his brother Antonio. Antonio, hungry to be "Absolute Milan" himself (1:2, p.6), proceeded to betray him with the help of King Alonso of Naples.

    Read More

  • Oppression In Gilgamesh

    683 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prospero enslaved the spirit Ariel or other-worldly figure of sorts. And in-turn Ariel causes a violent storm that causes the shipwreck in the opening scene, due to Prospero's request, thus bringing those back that caused Prospero to lose his dukedom. After which Ariel asked for his freedom having done his deed for Prospero, but Prospero denied his request, saying to Ariel time must be served first. Prospero continues with something of a guilt-instilling speech, reminding Ariel that he had freed him and Ariel becomes submissive once again saying, “all hail, great master, grave sir, hail! I come to answer thy best pleasure; beat to fly, to Swim, to dive into the fire, to ride, on the curled of clouds”(1,2,189-190). This shows Ariel’s language is that of someone being oppressed imprisoned or enslaved and such is the relationship that of a slave and a master. Prospero does not only oppress Ariel but also enslaves Caliban the once ruler of the island simply because Prospero believed his new ideas were much better meaning slavery over freedom, which he did impose on Caliban by saying “Dull thing, I say so; he, that Caliban, Whom now I keep in my service.” (Act. I, Sc. II, Ln. 285-286). Furthermore Prospero makes it even clearer what he thinks of Caliban the native that had helped Prospero to survive on the Island has

    Read More

  • Shakespeare's The Tempest - Is Prospero Good or Evil?

    1001 Words  | 3 Pages

    Having been usurped and wrecked on an Island Prospero and his young daughter Miranda have to settle. It is here in Prospero's past that it first clear to see where any confusion about his character may appear. As a learned and powerful man Prospero is able to take direct control of the island, he frees a trapped and tortured spirit (Ariel) and befriends the inhabitants (Caliban). Prospero 'helps' Caliban, he tries to educate him and teaches him to communicate, in exchange Caliban helps Prospero to survive on the Island. But in taking power of the Island Prospero is committing the same act that happened to him as Duke of Milan, now Prospero himself has become the usurper. In this act of goodness Prospero has unknowingly shown his evil side.

    Read More

  • Relationship between Prospero, Caliban and Ariel in The Tempest

    1503 Words  | 4 Pages

    Prospero appears to be a ruthless tyrant that strikes fear into Caliban to make him work but further on in the text we learn that this is not the case. Caliban's foul-mouthed insults,

    Read More

  • The Power Of Love In Shakespeare's The Tempest

    1136 Words  | 3 Pages

    Prospero does have power over others in many ways though. He has obtained his subjects through the powers that his books give him, but he cannot make his subjects be pleased about it. Caliban clearly does not love Prospero and

    Read More

  • The Abuse of Power in Shakespeare's Play, The Tempest

    986 Words  | 2 Pages

    This time however, Prospero used his daughter as bait in order to draw Ferdinand closer in the hopes of getting them married. He wants to regain his title as the Duke of Milan. Prospero presents himself as a victim of injustice, however his belief of justice and injustice is somewhat contradicting. He takes advantage of this authority over other people and situations he encounters while using his integrity and compassion to mask his dangerous plans and to retain love and respect. The Tempest in the end suggests that love and compassion are more effective political tools than violence, hatred or even abusive magic.

    Read More

  • Revenge in Shakespeare's The Tempest

    3160 Words  | 7 Pages

    But why the tendency toward revenge in the first place? What was it about the personality and mental disposition of Prospero that caused him to lust for revenge against his brother, Antonio? And Caliban. Why couldn't Prospero overlook his social naïveté when it came to handling a woman? (1.2.350) In this portion of the website, I will examine those questions and attempt to provide an answer and an insight into the psychology of Prospero.

    Read More

  • Themes of Forgiveness in The Tempest by William Shakespeare

    627 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prospero goes through the motions of forgiveness, but his sincerity is lost to us. Moreover, there is clearly no reconciliation amongst Prospero, Sebastian, and Antonio. Prospero still considers Antonio a "most wicked sir" (5.1.130) and Antonio, focused on slaying the island fiends, will not even acknowledge Prospero.

    Read More

  • Ariel And Caliban In Shakespeare's The Tempest

    969 Words  | 2 Pages

    A master servant theme can be seen throughout the whole play. Prospero has a this relationship with both Ariel and Caliban clearly, but it is the way he goes about the relationship. He prefers Ariel because he is more compliant than Caliban and has more uses. Prospero’s relationship with Caliban is more toxic. These show what kind of person Prospero really is. He is a manipulative person that is willing to whatever he needs to get what he wants. This is compared to how the colonists interacted with the Native Americans. They would trade and help each, and were able to tolerate them. Eventually the colonist learned what they needed and then turned their backs on

    Read More

  • Theme Of Power In The Tempest

    753 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prospero’s trust is broken with Caliban because he tried to rape Miranda. There is no evidence of rape, however Miranda was the only female on the island practically supports the idea. Caliban being a natural creature he would not know the different in societies rule against sexual engagement. Prospero learns from his second betrayal, apparently tyrannical state is revealed in verbal abuse ...

    Read More

More about The Tempest: Is Prospero Good Or Evil?

Open Document