The Pros And Cons Of The Child Welfare System

1317 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Racial discrimination in the criminal justice system

It is true that sometimes the Child Welfare system lets its children down and ends up raising offenders. However, that is not to say that what they do is simply or even mostly a failure, I am merely attempting to turn random stars into constellations. There are great changes that are made in this system. I have witnessed cases progress from being supervised visits to becoming monitored visits. I have seen mothers taking home their babies and children returning home because the parents have met their return conditions. I have seen parents who were hopeless drug addicts reach milestones by staying clean. I have heard cases of mothers who were repeat domestic violence victims set limits to their ex-abusers and seen a father learn how to hold a …show more content…

It can be easy to see how Child Welfare fails over and over, and how even though the ideal is to return the children to their homes a year after their removal often times parents end up losing their rights permanently. Nevertheless, it is imperative to keep in mind the population with which they are working. Essentially DHS is working with the same population that the rest of the CJ system is working with. In the CJ system we know that recidivism rates are high. We also know that there is a demographic that tends to get caught more easily than any other in the system: the poor and uneducated. If the rest of the CJ system has not been able to figure out how to improve success rates, it does not make sense to expect that the relatively young DHS Child Welfare system has perfected theirs. Moreover, it is important to realize that that any system, no matter how tight or secure it seems, can have holes that lead to …show more content…

The parents are going to be mad for the intrusion in their lives, and the children might resent them for their role in their new struggles. They might be heroes, but they better not expect any thank-you cards, because they are often not going to get that. They have to be prepared to look into a child’s face and accept their hatred as a payment for their services. The job itself is already emotionally taxing, but adding a victim who is mad for your intervention takes everything to the next

Show More
Related

  • The Daniel Pelka Serious Case Review

    1723 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hendrick, H. (2005) Child welfare and social policy: an essential reader. Bristol: The Policy Press.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of DYFS

    1378 Words  | 3 Pages

    Is DYFS always capable of changing children’s lives or can they put them into more danger? Although DYFS is in place to help children and families, some agency workers cause more harm than good. DYFS has cooperated with many children and families but their worker’s aren’t showing trustworthiness. DYFS stands for Division of Youth and Family Services, it is New Jersey's child protection and child welfare agency within the Department of Children and Families. The purpose of this service is to ensure the safety, permanency and well-being of children and to support families. DYFS has helped many families in New Jersey, when it came to drug abuse or domestic violence as well but in some cases these children weren’t safe at all. However, some workers failed to provide early services that could have kept the kids safe and at home. People reach out to others for help and when they do call, that person is to take responsibility in their hand to accomplish the goal of supporting the family with a better environment. Some of the workers help is not always conducive.

    Read More

  • Prison Foster Care And The Systematic Punishment Of Black Mothers Summary

    1053 Words  | 3 Pages

    This article describes the similarities and parallelism of the foster system to the prison systems and how they perpetuate and are influenced by each other. It describes how these systems commodify and dehumanize these human beings, especially women who receive long, severe sentences for minor offenses and are thus denied ability to parent their child from behind bars. This, thus, affects the child in the short and long term because these children are taken from their mothers by the state, often put into foster care, in which the state then refuses to take care of these motherless children. This then leads to social workers developing more aggressive and hostile tactics when dealing with these types of cases, because often the children must scavenge the streets in order to survive and become troubled by the social realities they face. The author then begins to discuss how the welfare system becomes heavily involved with these families, along with the stigmatizations government assistance is attached with. . It is unfortunate that this article only very briefly discusses pregnant, black incarcerated women, and the lack of prenatal care they are provided with during

    Read More

  • The Pros of Welfare Reform

    364 Words  | 1 Pages

    The current system has not been good for children. In 1965 there were 3.3 million children on AFDC; by 1992, that had risen to over 9 million children despite the fact that the total number of children in this country has declined. Last year, the Department of Health and Human Services estimated if we do nothing, 12 million will be on AFDC in 10 years. Instead of working up, we find more and more children being trapped in a system and into dependency on welfare. 90 percent of the children on AFDC live without one of their parents. Only a fraction of welfare families are engaged in work. There are always the sad accounts of how, again and again, women would get off of welfare, they would be doing well on their own, but their child-care would fall apart just as they were getting back on their feet. The new bill provides $3.5 billion more than current for that needed child care.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Indian Child Welfare Act

    909 Words  | 2 Pages

    Supreme Court Justice John Roberts once said, “It’s a sordid business this divvying us up by race.” (Will “Blood”). In 1978 an act was passed in congress to preserve Indian tribal populations; it allowed tribes to terminate adoptions and place Indian children in Indian homes. The Indian Child Welfare Act has many positive impacts, including the promotion of strong Native-American identity, but there are also drawbacks, such as the lack of concern for the children’s safety and how they’re used as pawns to keep the tribes intact, no matter what the cost is for the kids.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Privatizing The Foster Care System

    1236 Words  | 3 Pages

    The foster system intends to place children in homes where they will remain until they can find permanent residence with an adoptive family. Sadly, this is often not the case with children placed privatized homes and they end up bouncing from home to home until they eventually age out of the system forced to enter into adulthood with no permanent family ties. Over the past decade the number of teenagers aging out of the system without a permanent family has risen from 19,000 to 23,000 per year. These teenages enter into the world without emotional, relational, or financial support and therefore possess a greater risk of poverty as well as low academic achievement. This causes many of these teenagers to rely on government benefits during their adult lives which places a heavier burden on taxpayers. The National Council for Adoption reported that the 29,000 teenagers that aged out of the system in 2007 will cost over one billion dollars per year in public assistance and support. These teenagers who age out are also found to be at greater risk of concerning behaviors, such as: creating disciplinary problems in school, dropping out of school, becoming unemployed and homeless, becoming teenage parents, abusing alcohol and drugs, and committing crimes. The privatized system does not have the best interest of the children in mind and

    Read More

  • California Youth Authority

    1402 Words  | 3 Pages

    The CYA is clearly not working the way the way that it was designed to run. For instance, three out of four wards who end up in the California Youth Authority are arrested on new criminal charges within three years of their release, which proves the institution's failure to rehabilitate the state's most troubled juvenile offenders. Experts say the high number does not address how much California could gain from approaches used in other states (like Mississippi) such as housing wards in smaller facilities, providing intensive treatment programs, and offering more supervision and assistance after a ward is released. “In smaller, rehabilitation centers, youth would be under the supervision of trained social workers and mental health experts – not prison guards.(LAO Report, pg. 7).” This would allow the offenders to be in closer contact with their families, as well as a variety of services.

    Read More

  • Child Welfare Policy in Canada

    1047 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ideological, social, political, and economic factors of a given period play key roles in developing and maintaining any social welfare policies in which the area of child welfare is not an exception. Throughout the history of child welfare legislation in Canada, Acts have been passed and modified according to the changing concept of childhood and to the varying degree of societal atmosphere of each period.

    Read More

  • The Failure of Child Protective Services in America

    1449 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many children across the country are wrongfully removed from their homes everyday by workers with an anti-family mindset, who use removal as a first resort not a last. It is not only detrimental to the child’s well-being, but is also immorally abusive to the child. The goal of the child welfare system is to promte safety, permanency, and wellness among all children.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Foster Care

    946 Words  | 2 Pages

    Some parents in the world do not discipline their children and do not care what the children. All they care about are them selves. At that point the social workers take the child and put them in foster homes with complete and total strangers. Some companies just put kids with people who do not care about the children just what they get paid. They just let the children go off and do what they want and do not supervise the children’s activities. The social workers should do more thoroughly background checks. There should also be more supervision in foster homes instead of little supervision, and the workers should visit the home and the children more often than they actually do.

    Read More

  • Child Welfare System Case Study

    1752 Words  | 4 Pages

    The child welfare system originated with the goals that social workers would try and alleviate poverty and its impact; however, as the years have passed, the child welfare system turned into a child protection system directed toward investigating abuse and neglect, and removing children from families and placing them in foster care, and is no longer prepared to assist in resolving the problems of child poverty (Lindsey, 2004). A child welfare system has been developed around the residual approach, which demands that aid should be given only after the family is in crisis or other support groups have failed to meet a child’s minimal needs. However, over the years, there have been different focuses for the child welfare system, whether it involved addressing the issue of abandoned and orphaned children or the increased demand for child protection, resulting in the decrease of child welfare services (Lindsey, 2004). Police are sometimes stereotyped to be rugged, single-minded enforcers who are insensitive to families in their most vulnerable state (Cross, Finkelhor, Ormrod, 2005).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Adoption And Safe Families Act

    2801 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the United States there are approximately 397,000 children in out-of home care, within the last year there was about 640,000 children which spent at least some time in out-of-home care. More than 58,000 children living in foster care have had their biological parental rights permanently terminated (Children’s Rights, 2014). Due to the rising number of children in foster care and the growing concerns of the safety, permanency, and well-being of children and families, the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997 was signed into law. On November 19, 1997, President Bill Clinton signed the Adoption and Safe Families Act of 1997, to improve the safety of children, to promote adoption and other permanent homes for children who need them, and to support families (Child Welfare League of America). The Adoption and Safe Families Act also promotes adoption by offering incentive payments for States. During the FY of 1999-2003 the payment to states which had exceeded the average number of adoptions received $20 million (Child Welfare League of America). The ASFA improved the existing federal child welfare law to require that the child’s health and safety be a “paramount” concern in any efforts made by the state to preserve or reunify the child’s family, and to provide new assurances that children in foster care are safe (Shuman, 2004).

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Welfare In America

    1259 Words  | 3 Pages

    The welfare of the people in America is put in the hands of the public administrators and political leaders of the United States. These public administrators and political leaders are voted into office to promote new bills and come up with solutions that will be in the best interest of the public’s welfare. When the subject of welfare is debated the first thought that comes to mind is giving underprivileged and disadvantaged people money to help them get out of a financial predicament and/or temporary unemployment. The welfare of the middle and upper class is not as common because the fact that people collect financial support from their employment. There are several biased assumptions about the welfare program in America that leave the subject open for discussion. Such as food stamps, and how low-income Americans are given our taxpaying money to provide food for their households. I’m against the Supplement Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and what toll it’s putting on the taxpayers of America.

    Read More

  • Abuse in Government Care

    2380 Words  | 5 Pages

    Government statistics, newspaper articles, and thorough research projects have been completed to answer the question, “is there a problem in the foster care system?” The results have revealed that a serious problem exist within foster care in the United States. At any given time there are approximately 542,000 children in the foster care system (Dept of Health). This number continues to rise each year. In 2001, 290,000 children entered into foster care, while only 263,000 children left the system (Dept of Health). Of the 263,000 children that left foster care in the year 2001, 31% were in care for over two years (Dept of Health). Nineteen percent of those children were in foster care for one to two years (Dept of Health). Two years is an unacceptable amount of time when taken into consideration that between the ages of 8 and ten are critical developmental years in a child’s life. The average age of the a child leaving the foster care system in 2001 was 10.2 years old (Dept of Health). The amount of children per foster home at any given time is another problem. The average number of children per home in the foster care system is 3.7, which is up from 1.4 in 1983. Although 3.7 children is an average per home, there are claims that tens of thousands of homes have 5 – 8 children at once (C...

    Read More

  • Better Mental Health Outcomes for Young Foster Children

    909 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...(as discussed previously), attentiveness for the need of such an intervention is a step in the right direction. Furthermore, Wotherspoon, Laberge, and Pirie (2008) indicate that the “… rapid increase in the number of requests for a consultation from our child welfare partners…” (p. 391) demonstrates the positive benefits of their CMHC program. This program has built a relationship with Child Welfare and included opportunities for those workers to enhance their knowledge (Wotherspoon, Laberge, & Pirie, 2008) on child development, mental health and trauma implications. As highlighted in Bass’s et al. (2004) report, the policies and practices for child welfare agencies are varied between different states, hence their contribution towards alleviating and preventing mental health problems in young foster children is unbalanced and hard to measure in terms of success.

    Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of The Child Welfare System

Open Document