The Joy Luck Club Rhetorical Analysis

523 Words2 Pages

Motherly behaviors
Mothers always want the best for their daughters, it’s a given feeling for a mother. Amy Chua’s Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mom is written in her perspective as the mother. In The Joy Luck Club, Amy tan writes the novel through her eyes as the daughter of the relationship. Both passages portray the harsh emotions between the mother and her daughter. These emotions are caused by the mother pressuring her daughter to achieve expectations. The two excerpts have similar stressful tones but Amy Tan’s novel is much more intense and displays a uglier relationship.
In the excerpt the “Jing-Mei Woo”, diction and tone are portrayed throughout the passage. For an example, in the excerpt Amy Tan uses clear diction creating an overwhelming tone. She uses words like “yanked” and “sobbing” making the tone very obvious to spot. In The Joy Luck Club, Amy Tan let her emotions go to a whole nother level, “Then I wish I’d never been born!’I shouted. “I wish I were dead! Like them”(Tan 141-142). Tan had gotten to her mother’s soft spot. The spot where she knew was most …show more content…

For an example, Tan uses word diction like “yanked”, while Chua uses words like “squeeze”. The word squeeze and yank share a similar meaning, but portray a totally different diction. Unlike Tan’s excerpt, Chua uses irony to illustrate a tone: “‘RELAX!’ I screamed”(Tan 47-48). The irony Chua uses creates the innocent tone. The innocence is created by the mother because she is trying to help her daughter relax, but then she screams, making it only more difficult for her daughter to do so. Although Chua’s excerpt illustrates a stressful tone, some diction portrays a good side of their relationship. Amy Chua says her daughter said “Stop it, Mommy. Just stop it”(Chua 47-48); the term “Mommy” is a word that illustrates love and care, showing the reader that there is still a good side to the

Open Document