The Great Transformation Analysis

1395 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The great transformation essay

The Great Transformation, although not a recently published piece, still presents many values and truths that still hold water today. Polanyi’s piece has held up very well over time, giving the reader a very profound understanding of the issues facing global societies at the dawn of the 21st century. I believe the author is trying to describe to the readers his view on the importance of self-regulating markets and the role they played on global economies (Polanyi pg. 3). Polanyi further adds to that statement by providing his thesis to this paper on pages 3-4, Polanyi states that:
“Our thesis is that the idea of a self-adjusting market implied a stark utopia. Such an institution could not exist for any length of time without annihilating the human and natural substance of society; it would have physically destroyed man and transformed his surrounding into a wilderness. Inevitably, society took measures to protect itself, but whatever measures it took impaired the self-regulation of the market, disorganized industrial life, and thus endangered society in yet another way. It was this dilemma which forced the development of the market system into a definite groove and finally disrupted the social organization based upon it.” (Polanyi pg 3-4)
The purpose of the remainder of his book is to try and answer that proposed thesis, the importance being that Polanyi believes that markets are not a natural feature in human society, he points out that nearly all other societies used different, non-market instruments to deliver goods. I believe this is important because at the time of his writing, Polanyi’s views went against the grain, which I believe plays a strong part if why this book has stayed popular throughout the years.
To summari...

... middle of paper ...

...red today as the creator of substantivism, which incorporates his embeddedness views of economies into society and culture.
In conclusion, I enjoyed this piece by Karl Polanyi. Although it is not my favorite book to have read or summarized thus far (the Gladwell book was my favorite so far), I found in intelligent and interesting. It was also quite thought-provoking for me as most of my studies and teaching s have been traditional economics. I had never really read anything else that proposed the critique of the self-regulating market theory like Polanyi does in this piece. I think it is even more profound when thought of in the context of the time in which this was written. As previously stated, this was written in the early 1940’s, right in the middle of WWII and all the upheaval that war brought to the globe and makes it even more a substantial economic piece.

Show More
Related

  • Enuma Elish Tiamat's Transformation Analysis

    1283 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Enuma Elish myth begins with gender equality, with both sexes, contributing equally to the creation of the gods. However, throughout the myth there is a continuous battle between the feminine and the masculine roles. Ultimately, the masculine role wins the battle with the feminine role, Tiamat, paying for it with her life. Tiamat’s transformation is the basis of this struggle between the traditional feminine and masculine roles. Tiamat’s main transition is from motherly into monstrous. When Tiamat fails to meet her role as a wife and a mother she is transformed into an evil figure meant to be hated. In the conclusion of the myth, Tiamat’s body is used in creation by Murduk. This shows how femininity and masculinity both have a place in creation myths.

    Read More

  • Kingdom of Matthias by Paul E.Johnson and Sean Wilentz

    907 Words  | 2 Pages

    Foner, Eric. "Chapter 9: The Market Revolution." Give Me Liberty!: An American History. Third ed. Vol. One. New York: W.W. Norton, 2012. 332-33. Print.

    Read More

  • Contrasting Friedman and Lindblom on Economic Systems

    1124 Words  | 3 Pages

    The current issues that have been created by the market have trapped our political system in a never-ending cycle that has no solution but remains salient. There is constant argument as to the right way to handle the market, the appropriate regulatory measures, and what steps should be taken to protect those that fail to be competitive in the market. As the ideological spectrum splits on the issue and refuses to come to a meaningful compromise, it gets trapped in the policy cycle and in turn traps the cycle. Other issues fail to be handled as officials drag the market into every issue area and forum as a tool to direct and control the discussion. Charles Lindblom sees this as an issue that any society that allows the market to control government will face from the outset of his work.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Sandel's 'What Money Can T Buy'

    840 Words  | 2 Pages

    Almost without realizing it, argues Sandel, we are gone from “having a market economy to being a market

    Read More

  • Andrew Carnegie Free Enterprise Importance

    703 Words  | 2 Pages

    Overall, free market is a necessity if there is to be any forward movement and progression of society. In a controlled system nothing ever changes, and while this can prevent change for the worse, it also stunts change for the better. In free enterprise systems, people with brains and determination, such as Andrew Carnegie, are able to take advantage of new opportunities. While this system will not help individuals float along, and they are liable to sink (into debt and/or remorse), those who have the courage to try will find that success is only a risk

    Read More

  • The Shift from Traditional Societies to a Market Society

    1020 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Polanyi, a market economy becomes a market society when all land, labour and capital are commodified (Polanyi, 1957). A market society is a structure, which primarily focuses on the production and distribution of commodities and services. This takes place through a free market system, which allows the opportunity for individuals to engage themselves in the market place, through trucking, bartering or exchanging. Polanyi’s fundamental idea of a market society is that all social relations are rooted in the economy as opposed to the economy being submerged in social relations.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Communist Manifesto

    1573 Words  | 4 Pages

    It has pitilessly torn asunder the motley feudal ties that bound man to his ‘natural superiors’, and has left remaining no other nexus between man and man than naked self-interest, than callous ‘cash payment’. It has drowned the most heavenly ecstasies of religious fervor, of chivalrous enthusiasm, of philistine sentimentalism, in the icy water of egotistical calculation. It has resolved personal worth into exchange value, and in place of the numberless indefeasible chartered freedoms, has set up that single, unconscionable freedom-Free Trade. In one word, for exploitation, veiled by religious and political illusions, it has substituted naked, shameless, direct, brutal exploitation. The bourgeoisie has stripped of its halo every occupation hitherto honored and looked up to with reverent awe. It has converted the physician, the lawyer, the priest, the poet, the man of science, into its paid wage-laborers.

    Read More

  • Emergence of Market Society

    1722 Words  | 4 Pages

    The main objective of this essay is to understand how market society emerged, but first the defintion and characteristics of a market society must be understood. According to Polanyi, “Market economy implies a self-regulating system of markets.... it is an economy directed by market prices and nothing but market prices”(Polanyi 43). Similarily, Heilbroner explains how the market “allows society to ensure its own provisioning”(Heilbroner 12). Both of these explanations describe how the market economy is self regulated, meaning that this “economic system is controlled, regulated and directed by markets alone...

    Read More

  • Exploring the Evolution of Economic Thought

    1669 Words  | 4 Pages

    Robert Heilbroner (1996, 11-13), in Teachings, drew upon the insights of Thomas Aquinas who had attempted to provide room for capital accumulation and economic activity beyond the “stringent” moral requirements of Aristotle. In what was known as “the commercial revolution,” an economic ideology known as “mercantilism” dominated the minds of the foremost economic thinkers. According to Heilbroner (1996, 17-18) the system of serfdom and feudalism had eroded behooving society to come up with a new way to structure its economic activity around a labor force that now had more opportunity than in the past. This new market, and with it a newly kindled desire for accumulation, ran in opposition to the Christian values of the time, something that Aquinas (Heilbroner, 1996, 12-13) attempted to address in the Summa Theoligica [1485]. This began a long and rich tradition of economic thinkers attempting to “make peace” with the seemingly amoral activities of an emerging merchant class and the inequities that occur as a result of an evolving market based system; furthermore, this debate continues into the 21st century, and could be seen as the most integral question that faces

    Read More

  • Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations

    3049 Words  | 7 Pages

    Smith's formulation transcends a purely descriptive account of the transformations that shook eighteenth-century Europe. A powerful normative theory about the emancipatory character of market systems lies at the heart of Wealth of Nations. These markets constitute "the system of natural liberty" because they shatter traditional hierarchies, exclusions, and privileges.2 Unlike mercantilism and other alternative mechanisms of economic coordination, markets are based on the spontaneous and free expression of individual preferences. Rather than change, even repress, human nature to accord with an abstract bundle of values, market economies accept the propensities of humankind and are attentive to their character. They recognize and value its inclinations; not only human reason but the full panoply of individual aspirations and needs.3 Thus, for Smith, markets give full expression to individual, economic liberty.

    Read More

  • Summary Of The Globalization Paradox

    1436 Words  | 3 Pages

    The first point that Rodrik makes is that markets are limited by the scope of governance or regulation. He argues that markets and governments are most effective when they are operating in accordance with one another. This theory seems to stem from a theory earlier developed by the famous economist Adam Smith, which was that “the division of labor is limited by the extent of the market.” Rodrik expands on this theory by saying that not only is labor limited by the market, but that markets are limited by government.

    Read More

  • Proponent and Opponents of Globalization

    1294 Words  | 3 Pages

    Proponents have a strong belief in free markets and limited governments intervention. According to Preble (2010), globalization has led to the creation of jobs, higher living standards and a higher variety of goods available to consumers. International trade is one of the driving forces behind globalization. Countries specialize in specific goods wherein it has a comparative advantage. This results in a higher efficiency and productivity and ultimately leading to an improvement of the living standards. As a consequence, export increases. Hereto, more jobs are created, a higher variety of goods are available and international competition has increased. This results in lower prices, keeping the inflation in check (Preble, 2010). Furthermore, Preble (2010) states that the increase of trade in goods and services, foreign direct investment and cross-border investment have been important for the success of globalization. Other important benefits, mentioned by the proponents of globalization, are the promotion of information exchange and high understanding of a variety of cultures. Globalization has led to a world where “democracy has triumph over autocracy” (BBC News, 2000, as stated in Preble, 2010, p. 334).

    Read More

  • Socialism - The Best Economic System

    1465 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today, more than ever, there is great debate over politics and which economic system works the best. How needs and wants should be allocated, and who should do the allocating, is one of the most highly debated topics in our current society. Be it communist dictators defending a command economy, free market conservatives defending a market economy, or European liberals defending socialism, everyone has an opinion. While all systems have flaws and merits, it must be decided which system is the best for all citizens. When looking at the financial well being of all citizens, it is clear that market economies fall short on ensuring that the basic needs of all citizens are met.

    Read More

  • Market Failure and Government Intervention

    1410 Words  | 3 Pages

    The concept of perfect market allocation of resources was in W. Baumol's (1988,631), view largly theroretical. Baumol believed that economic models relied upon the concept of the invisible hand first discussed by Adam Smith. In these models, the perfectly competetive economy was able to allocate resources efficiently, without the need for market intervention by outside agents, including governments. However, there were significant weaknesses in these models particuarly in the area of ensuring equity of acess, social objectives and in the provision of public goods.

    Read More

  • Globalization: The Path to Destruction

    1766 Words  | 4 Pages

    ... policies. People will continue to suffer in silence because of the world’s greed. So, while we enjoy our cheaply made goods and over consume the planet into demise, we never know of choose not to know the pain that went into the productions of those goods. Globalization may be championed as a gateway to financial growth for all nations, but only certain nations benefit from it. Global trading and integration has a negative effect on undeveloped nations and developed nations in many ways including; political systems, sovereignty, economy, way of life and much more. Earlier in the essay I asked ‘do the pros outweigh the cons when it comes to globalization’ and from my research I don’t see any real benefit. I don’t believe we should eliminate global business, but better the already lacking regulations and probably increase the standard of living equally for the world.

    Read More

More about The Great Transformation Analysis

Open Document