More handpicked essays just for you.
Compare and contrast books and movies
Critical appreciation of "the giver
Critical appreciation of "the giver
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
The story, The Giver, is an engaging and adventurous tale about a boy named Jonas who learns all about the past and all the things that were taken away to create a ¨perfect¨ society. Lois Lowry published The Giver in 1993 and later on during August 11th, 2014, Phillip Noyce fabricated the novel into a movie. Jonas is an inquisitive individual who is selected as the new Receiver of Memory as his life assignment. The adjustments that are constructed to the original story’s plot and characters made the movie’s visual and understanding more entertaining and exciting for the spectators, yet, some attention grabbing details were kept. The plot in The Giver was changed for the better display the story’s seriousness while retaining the story’s idea For instance, in both the film and book, Jonas is selected as the Receiver of Memory at the ceremony of the twelve. Page 60, paragraph 7 clearly states, “ Jonas has been selected.” “He blinked. What did that mean? He felt a collective, questioning stir from the audience. They, too, were puzzled. In a firm, commanding voice she announced, “Jonas has been selected to be our new Receiver of Memory.” “Then he heard the gasp-the sudden intake of breath, drawn sharply in astonishment, by each of the seated citizens.¨ Based on this evidence, people are not often selected. This fact is known because everyone in the audience was questioning what that meant. This evidence also shows that everyone was very astonished because of the way they all gasped. Likewise, in the movie, Jonas is also selected to be the new Receiver of Memory by the Chief Elder and everyone is in awe by the selection. It is a good thing that Phillip Noyce kept this the same because the whole book is about Jonas being the new Receiver of Memory and learning about the past, so without him having that job, the book couldn’t go on from chapter 7. Also, if Jonas hadn’t become the new receiver of memory, he wouldn't have wanted to figure out the truth, so the community would always be stuck in a life of lying and misery. Though there are many For instance, both plots have a part where the Giver shows Jonas a video of his father releasing an infant, which helps Jonas understand what the meaning of release really means. The plot in the movie and novel differ however, because in the movie, Jonas begs Fiona not to take the injection on purpose, but in the book, he doesn’t. Because he does in the movie, she listens and developes very strong feelings of love for Fiona, but in the book, Fiona never experiences love at all. Jonas is also compared and contrasted between the film and publication. For example, in both the movie and book, Jonas is selected to be the new Receiver of Memory, which impacts the story because without Jonas, everyone would have to live a life of Sameness. Although, in the movie Jonas actually sees the house at the bottom of the hill at the beginning, but in the book, he doesn’t until the very end of the book, which is crucial the the production, because Jonas actually knows what love and family are at the beginning of the production. Overall, the plot and Jonas were changes for the better in the movie, yet some crucial details remained the
Movie adaptations can sometimes be accurate, but in this case, the movie for The Giver was not. Most of the changes made were minor and didn't affect the story. One of the minor changes was that The Giver, Jonas, and Gabe did not have pale eyes but had marks on their wrists instead. Some changes completely affected the plot. The major changes, Fiona’s job being different and the characters taking injections instead of pills, made the whole movie more dramatic and different from the
For example, Mama goes to the bank in the movie and is given a hard time about paying her mortgage, but this did not happen in the book. Another major difference is that the school bus scene, where the Logan kids played a trick on the white kids, was not shown in the movie, even though it was an important part of the story. There are some character changes as well. Lillian Jean, Jeremy, R.W, and Melvin are Simms’ in the book, but in the movie they are Kaleb Wallace’s children. However, the main plot difference is how the movie starts in the middle, summarizing everything from the first part of the book very briefly. Additionally, many scenes are switched around and placed out of order. Altogether, the plot and character changes contribute to my unfavorable impression of the
In both the novel and movie focus on the war. The war influences the characters to enroll.Also, the main setting is at the Devon School. However, in the novel Gene visits Leper at his house but in the movie Leper lives in the woods.In the novel Gene is coming back to the Devon School 15 years later.However, in the book he is coming to Devon as a new student.Therefore, similarities and differences exist in time and setting in the novel and the movie.In the novel and the movie there are similarities and differences in events, character, and time and setting.
Overall, the movie and book have many differences and similarities, some more important than others. The story still is clear without many scenes from the book, but the movie would have more thought in it.
During Jonas’s selection to become the next Receiver of Memory, the Chief Elder states that the previous selection was a failure. When Jonas questions his parents about the results of the previous selection, they inform him that “[they] never saw her again (Lowry 85)” and they do not know what happened to her. As well as being informed of a failure in the past, Jonas’s rules state that he is not allowed to apply for medication related to his training or release. These clues hint that Jonas will suffer to the point that he may want to apply for release or there is a chance that he will fail. Later in his training, Jonas experiences memories of pain and suffering, such as injury, war, and hunger.
The Giver is about a boy named Jonas who was chosen to be the community’s next Receiver of Memory. He lived in a community where everything was chosen for the citizens, and everything was perfect. During Jonas' training, he realized that the community was missing something and that there was more in the world. Jonas wanted everybody to know that. The Giver book was then made into a movie.
One example from the text is, “But it’s the ceremony I’m apprehensive about. It’s almost December.” (9)This shows that Jonas is not sure of what his assignment will be and is not sure what he wants it to be. He can relate to lots of people who don’t know what the future will hold and are nervous about it. Another passage from the text is, “He had never recognised it as a game of war.” In this scene Jonas is shocked when he realizes that one of his childhood games is really a game about war. This shows that he is changing and is realizing the truth about more things each day. The characters in the book help the reader to connect to the text and keep the story
The Giver provides a chance that readers can compare the real world with the society described in this book through some words, such as release, Birthmothers, and so on. Therefore, readers could be able to see what is happening right now in the real society in which they live by reading her fiction. The author, Lowry, might build the real world in this fiction by her unique point of view.
I can assure you that reading this book will make you take valuable lessons with you. Jonas is a really wise, curious and a positive 12 year old boy. I think we should learn to be like him more because in the story Jonas shows how he follows what he thinks is right and not what the society thinks. This helps portray the importance of individuality.
So all the memories everyone had from the past has now created a world that is today, enjoyable. “Call me the Giver.” (Lowry 110). Quoted by the only old man who holds all the memories from years and years of the past to give to the new Receiver, which is Jonas. It is not just the happiness of past memories holding on throughout lives. But pain is the biggest part of memory that anyone will have to endure. It is not just the mental pain we suffer through, it also could have a pain in the physical body and mind that the elderly man had to be tortured with throughout his life. Lois Lowry is a powerful writer inflicting and teaching in the minds of all and how most important and delicate memory is in the novel, The Giver, and how it must not be forgotten or fade away as it will determine your future and fill the gaps of mistakes individuals have
Dear Germanna English Professors, I had been flipping through the movie channels recently and had come across a familiar title. This title brought me to remember my eighth grade year when I was just about to read an unfamiliar book called, The Giver. The Giver is a story by author Lois Lowry about a boy named Jonas, who just happens to live in a futuristic society. In this futuristic society, no one has any emotions or freedom to do what they would like. In the society at a certain age, everyone is assigned a certain job based on their limited interests and skills. The job Jonas is assigned to be the Receiver of Memory, which makes him the keeper of all the memories of before the society. These memories are given to him by a person called the
When Jonas receives memories from The Giver, such as a memory of war, he can see how the rules have made a big impact on his life. In fact, when Jonas’ groupmates are playing a war related game, Jonas interrupts the game and pleads, “ ‘Don’t play it anymore’ ”(Lowry 168). Jonas is having flashback of the war memory he was given and remembering the pain he went through receiving it. If Jonas’ society enforces Sameness, then no one disagrees; therefore, there won’t be war and pain in the community. Because of the knowledge that Jonas and The Giver hold from the memories of the past, it comes into play a lot during the novel. For instance, when The Giver is explaining the importances of his and Jonas’ assignment of handling the memories, The Giver explains to Jonas that, “ ‘when I am called by the Committee of Elders, I appear before them, to give them counsel and advice’ ”(Lowry 130). Since The Giver and Jonas are the only people who have the memories, when the Committee of Elders, the head of the community, needs advice about something they go to them since they don’t have the knowledge of the past to fix a certain
The movie the giver is a series of short scenes of the book and it is not necessarily cover the full book sequences, however it is expected by the readers to contain the same plot. Therefore, when Jonas received his task being “receiver of the memory” the elder skipped his number so she can announce it later and that moment showed both reader and viewer the importance of his character and the beginning of the next events, another similarity the elsewhere scene which how Jonas
The Movie and the book had two main big similarities that were noticed the most. During The Graduation ceremony to receive your assigned job Jonas the main character was skipped and filled with nervousness and fear. In the book “The Giver” it states, “He was sitting in seat marked nineteen but she had skipped him.” This statement from the book “The Giver shows jonas was skipped in the book. In the movie it is a sense showing jonas standing along the stage with all his other classmates and as the chief elder gets to jonas number she skips to number twenty. Similarity number two,as jonas runs away to release all memories jonas goes to the nurturing center and kidnaps baby gabe to take with him along the way. In the text of “The Giver”,the book, it states “And he had taken Gabriel,too.” This shows Jonas took baby gabe along with him on his journey.
Be the change you want to see in the world.-Mahatma Gandhi. In the book and the movie “The Giver”,by Lois Lowry Jonas (the main character) makes the change he wants to see in his world. He does something considered wrong in his world to make something right happen. In the movie “The Giver”, did a very good job of keeping the plot of the movie similar to the book it was based on, rising action, climax, and falling action wise. The name of the book that the movie was based on is "The Giver". This book's rising action, climax, and falling action are very similar to the movie. The book's rising action is where Jonas starts receiving memories from the Giver that changes the way he thinks about his community. The climax would be when Jonas realizes