Synthesis Essay: The Failure Of Prohibition

1823 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Prohibition and why it didn't work

The Failure of Prohibition
Source Based a) One way in which source A and source B agree concerning the consequences of prohibition. When it was introduced it caused a lot of illegal activity. Source A shows how by saying, "It (prohibition) created the greatest criminal boom in American history and perhaps in all modern history." Source B shows this because it says, " by 1928 there were more than 30,000 illegal speakeasies" in New York.

Another agreement that the sources A and B have is that the Anti-saloon league was an important factor in the final national ban on alcohol. In source A it says that among other reasons their was the "influence of the anti-saloon league at a time when large numbers of …show more content…

I think that this is indicating that prohibition was bound to fail, because if it created that much criminal activity, then obviously not many people wanted to obey the law. Also, there would have been a lot of difficulty for prohibition agents to make sure that the law was enforced successfully, with so many gangsters.

Source B is similar to source A, it also has the advantage of hindsight of prohibition because it was published in 1979. In this source it shows the confidence in a prohibition agent, who had no doubts he would stamp out the evil of drink. This would indicate that the source does to some extent believe in the success in prohibition. However, Source B does also talk about how many 'speakeasies,' illegal pub, were set up in New York by 1928, 30,000. This shows how many people were people were going against the law, and therefor how unlikely it was to succeed. I think because the source was written after prohibition had failed, it is difficult for it to show that prohibition could have been a …show more content…

Source F was written the year that prohibition was introduced. The source is a speech by a prohibition agent, and is very for the success of prohibition. The agent believes that prohibition will be a success, and that where it is not obeyed, it will be enforced. This means that the source disagrees that prohibition was bound to fail, however, it was bound to be biased towards the success of prohibition as a prohibition commissioner wrote it.

Sources G and H both show police statistics on, in source G, stills that were seized and alcohol, in gallons, seized, over nine years of prohibition. In source G the figures increase, in both cases, I think that this would indicate prohibition is not working effectively, because if more illegal alcohol is being found, then more of it is being made. In source H the statistics are on the amount of people found drunk, and or in disorderly conduct, and drink driving. All of these figures increased over the years as well, accept drunk and

Show More
Related

  • Assess The View That The Policy Of National Prohibition Case Study

    1972 Words  | 4 Pages

    Prohibition was intended to reduce the manufacture and distribution of alcohol, and hence reduce the amount of crime, poverty and death rates, as well as improve the economy and the quality of life. Arguably, prohibition solved some of the problems to do with alcohol consumption of those from a low status background, as they could not afford drinks from new illegal establishments such as speakeasies. However, critics argue that the “noble experiment,” failed well before it was repealed in 1933. For example, although prohibition eradicated saloons, they were replaced by illegal bars known as speakeasies. Prohibition also led to other types

    Read More

  • Prohibition: Why Did America Change Its Mind?

    549 Words  | 2 Pages

    Out of all 27 Amendments of the Constitution, only one has been repealed; that would be the 18th Amendment, Prohibition. From 1920 to 1933 the manufacture, transport, and sell of alcoholic beverages in the United States was illegal. The Amendment passed in 1919 and went into effect during 1920, only to be repealed 14 years later. What made America change its mind about Prohibition? There are three main reasons America repealed the 18th Amendment; these include increase in crime, weak enforcement and lack of respect for the law, and economic opportunities.

    Read More

  • Prohibition DBQ Essay

    790 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the late 1800’s and early 1900’s, many saw alcohol as a cause of instability among communities. To counteract the effects of alcohol on American society, The Temperance Movement, Prohibition Party and many others sought to enact anti-liquor laws that would prohibit the sale, manufacture, and transportation of alcohol. On January 19, 1920, the Eighteenth Amendment had taken effect and a nationwide ban on alcohol was enacted. This was thought of as a solution to the many problems that America had at the time, but it only made matters worse. The American society had been greatly affected by the Eighteenth Amendment in many negative aspects such as increasing crime and violence, worsening the economy, and much more.

    Read More

  • Okrent’s Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition

    1451 Words  | 3 Pages

    In conclusion Okrent’s Last Call: The Rise and Fall of Prohibition is a wonderful, and for the most part fair account of the events and people living and taking part in the Prohibition era. His account is detailed, interesting, and well versed on the basis of public knowledge that can easily be referenced. Something the author seems to have been done for the reader, in the last pages of the book following the story. This book is an interestingly exciting read and is highly recommended for anyone interested in discovering what a mistake and giant failure prohibition really was.

    Read More

  • Prohibition Synthesis Essay

    1504 Words  | 4 Pages

    In 1920, a leading Prohibitionist declared in Congress that “There is as much chance of repealing the Eighteenth Amendment as there is for a hummingbird to fly to the planet Mars with the Washington Monument tied to its tail.” 13 years later, after the outbreak of the Great Depression this is exactly what happened? However, the main reason lies not with the Depression itself; this was merely the catalyst for its repeal. The simple fact the prohibition did not achieve its aims was the main cause of the passing of the Twenty-first Amendment, bringing about other factors which pushed the anti-Prohibition movement forwards.

    Read More

  • Speakeasies In The 1920s

    1466 Words  | 3 Pages

    Supposedly there were over 100,000 saloons in New York at one time. Business leaders thought that if alcohol was withheld from the workers they’d be more productive. John D. Rockefeller alone donated over $350,000 to the Anti-Saloon League. Henry Ford stated “The country couldn't run without Prohibition.

    Read More

  • Prohibition Dbq

    1152 Words  | 3 Pages

    The real reason the Prohibition Act was passed is not because the Legislation had voted for it, but rather the large amount of supporters it had. 33 out of 48 states had already passed the laws within 1920. The direct support was mainly coming from the South, which the number grew from 1820’s to 1840’s. These groups mainly campaigned against the outcome of drinking alcohol. Woman’s groups were behind many temperance movements for they were targets of abuse due to drunken husbands. Many times drinking was blamed upon the economics and the changes it has undergone.

    Read More

  • The Backlash of Prohibition

    807 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ment. In addition, the government lost the tax revenue generated from these business enterprises as well as from the sale of alcohol. The revenue generated from alcohol had amounted to one-third of the yearly tax revenue collected prior to prohibition. Actually, it is a fallacy that drinking increased during prohibition, though the middle class exposure to drinking did increase. The major argument to prohibition was the power it created for organized crime and the need for tax revenue in the throes of the Great Depression. With the country in dire need of revenue, in 1932 politicians supported a platform calling for the repeal of the act. The anti-prohibition platform became the death knell for prohibition. (Two changes needed in this sentence.) In1933 the 21st amendment to the Constitution was ratified, which repealed the 18th amendment and the end of prohibition.

    Read More

  • Prohibition - 'The Noble Experiment'

    884 Words  | 2 Pages

    Prohibition did not succeed at all. In order for prohibition to achieve what it was set to do it had to meet four specific guidelines.

    Read More

  • Economic and Social Effects of Prohibition

    1180 Words  | 3 Pages

    It was apparent that Prohibition didn’t achieve its goals, instead, it added to the existing economic and social problems, as well as creating new problems that would be prominent in today’s society. Organized crime grew into an empire, disrespect for the law grew, the per capita consumption of alcohol increased dramatically, city officials fell to gangsters, and the government lost money. It is obvious that prohibition was a miserable failure from all points of view. Reasonable measures were not taken to enforce the laws, so they were practically ignored.

    Read More

  • Prohibition in the 1920s

    569 Words  | 2 Pages

    " First, the adage is a slam. prohibition was a popular step. Supporters of prohibition, who? endorsed the law, believed that it would help the poor because paychecks would not be wasted on alcoholic beverages, which was done. by many people during this time, many of whom had starving children. Many industrial leaders of the time, such as Rockefeller, Ford, and Carnegie, all supported prohibition because they believed that alcohol decreased productivity of workers.

    Read More

  • The Success and Failure of the Prohibition

    978 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Prohibition had good intent, but it ultimately failed. Criminal activity rose rapidly and the economy fell harshly. America originally supported the Prohibition, but it eventually turned against it. The Prohibition lasted nearly fifteen years, but its legacy lives on. Nowadays the modern problem that closely mirrors the Prohibition is the war on drugs. Their illegal manufacture and sale is similar the manufacture and sale of alcohol during the Prohibition. History repeats itself.

    Read More

  • The Hopes and Realities of Prohibition

    806 Words  | 2 Pages

    The hopes of the prohibitionist were dreams of a healthier and more successful nation. Their dreams were spun from the idea of shutting out the alcohol industry and enforcing large industries and stressing family values. The eighteenth amendment consisted of the end of sales, production, transportation, as for importation and exportation of intoxicating liquors. Their imaginations were large and very hopeful. The prohibitionists felt that alcohol is a slow poison of their community. They felt that if the liquor industry was shut out that Americans would spend their hard earned money in the clothing, food, and shoe industries therefore boosting the American economy. Many felt, “Seeing what a sober nation can do is indeed a noble experiment and one that has never yet been tried, (Crowther, 11) Prohibition was a test of the strength of the nation and an attempt at cleaning up societies evils. These reformers denounce alcohol as a danger to society as well as to the human body. Some ethnic hopes of prohibition was to regulate the foreigners whose backgrounds consisted on the use of alcohol for religious purposes. And try to enforce an American valued society upon them. Many reformists felt that ending the use of alcohol would protect American homes and families. They felt that alcohol use was the root of their family’s destruction. Many women felt that their husbands would waste a lot of their income on the purchase of alcohol and not on family needs. Alcohol was often known as a “poison, or sin”. Another hope for the eighteenth amendment was to reduce the crime and death rate. Many people felt that drunkenness was the cause of many of the nations crimes. Prohibitionist felt very passionately on their cause and were often called “dry’s.” They felt their battle was justified and that, “it is manifest destiny that alcohol will not survive the scrutiny,”(Darrow and Yarros, 20).

    Read More

  • Prohibition in the Great Gatsby

    1346 Words  | 3 Pages

    The 1920s were greatly influenced by prohibition. The prohibition law restricted the manufacturing, consumption, transportation, and sale of alcohol. The law was put into effect to lower the crime and corruption rates in the United States in the 1920s. It was also said to reduce social problems and lower taxes. In The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald examines the negative repercussions of prohibition on the economy, characters in the Great Gatsby, and on the different social classes of the 1920s.

    Read More

  • Prohibition and the Birth of Organized Crime

    2133 Words  | 5 Pages

    Prohibition failed to improve health and virtue. Prohibition was supposed to be an economic and moral godsend. Prisons and poorhouses were to be emptied, taxes cut, and social problems eliminated. Prohibition did not achieve its goals. Instead, it added to the problems it was intended to solve and supplanted other ways of addressing problems. The only successors of Prohibition were bootleggers, crime bosses, and the forces of big government.

    Read More

More about Synthesis Essay: The Failure Of Prohibition

Open Document