The Contrast of Odysseus’s and Agamemnon’s Fate

Odysseus and Agamemnon are heroes who fought side by side to take down the city of Troy during the Trojan War. In Homer’s The Odyssey, why is Agamemnon slaughtered when he arrives home while Odysseus returns to find his loved ones still waiting for him? The reasons for the heroes’ differing fates are the nature of their homecoming and the loyalty of their wives.
The difference in Agamemnon’s and Odysseus’s approach of their homeland is a reason for their differing fates. Agamemnon, the king of Argos, returns from Troy after a safe journey. Once he lands on the shores of his native earth, his false sense of security renders him unsuspecting of the possible danger that lurks in his own home. His naiveté leads him to approach his home directly to show his people that he has returned. Since his subjects were no longer loyal to him, his exposure leads to his demise. Their disloyalty is revealed when Aegisthus, the man who plots to kill Agamemnon, gathers the town’s best soldiers to ambush the king. Agamemnon meets Aegisthus, who organized a banquet where the king and his company are mercilessly slaughtered. Because he fails to assess the danger that exists in his homeland, Agamemnon meets his end soon after his return.
Odysseus approaches his homeland differently; thus coming to a different fate. When Odysseus lands on Ithaca, he is aware of the possibility of danger, which makes him skeptical and cautious. His attitude is a result of the things he had encountered on his journey, like monsters and Agamemnon’s ghost. The monsters, such as Polyphemus and the Laestrygonians, surprise Odysseus when they eat his men instead of being good hosts. Agamemnon’s ghost influences Odysseus’s mindset by informing him of his own unfortunate end....

... middle of paper ...

...t, she prays to Artemis so that she may die and escape her remarriage. Penelope’s prayer reveals that she would rather die than remarry because she understands that she will never love anyone more than Odysseus. Her refusal is unlike Clytemnestra, who betrays her husband by having a lover. Penelope remains loyal to her husband and she is ecstatic when she realizes that he has returned from his twenty years of absence.
Agamemnon and Odysseus meet different ends after their return home from Troy. Their outcomes are affected by the choices they make once they arrive home and by the devotion their wives have for them. Odysseus’s long voyage home serves to teach him lessons, something Agamemnon did not get the chance to have when he encounters his tragic demise.

Works Cited

Homer. The Odyssey (Translated by E.V.Rieu). London, England: Penguin Classics, 2003.