The Commander - Both Villain and Figure of Sympathy

1014 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Women in the handmaid's tale

To what extent is the Commander presented as both villain and a figure of sympathy?

The commander can be seen as a man torn between two worlds, he was one of the founders of Gilead yet still enjoys and yearns for the pleasures of the old society he managed to break. The commander is cool and collected on the surface but underneath he is bitter and corrupted for the world he has managed to create. The commander secretly longs for the world to be as it once was and this is why he savours his time with Offred because she may remind him of life before Gilead. It is also ironic how both characters feel under the surface an anger and repression of Gilead and they both want to break free. However on the surface when they play scrabble with each other they are calm and to a certain extent sophisticated, which shows a certain amount of sexual power.

Our first description of the Commander is on page 99. Here Atwood begins to dig more deeper into the complex and emotional themes that permeate the story. Here, Atwood opens up to us about the Commanders character and he is almost revealed to the reader and for Offred. The Quotation ‘he just looks like a museum guard’ show us that he’s just playing the part in the system. He is the main part in the play which can not go ahead without him. He is just doing his job. Here we almost have sympathy for him, as he is portrayed with a sense of insecurity and a loss in power. He doesn’t have a choice.

However then Atwood uses the word ‘semi-retired’, which suggest he is just killing time before death. We get the impression that we should not underestimate this man, there is more to him than meets the eye. This can be shown because Atwood has waited 100 pages to show us the character of the command...

... middle of paper ...

... relationship.

Women were becoming more powerful, and men felt challenged and forced for their place in the world. This shows the Commanders control, he wanted them to procreate further and give men back the power. The quotation ‘Better never means better for everyone, he says. It always means worse, for some. While it seems clear that the regime truly believes that drastic measures are necessary to ensure the survival of this population, it does not seem clear that the new rules are actually better for anyone. The only possible answer is that they are better for the Commanders, who, as Offred's Commander tells her, had lost all interest in sex because it was so easy to get. Even so, the Commander himself seems no happier, no more fulfilled or free in his sexual relations, than any man prior to the institution of the new regime. This suggests that the commander is

Show More
Related

  • Free Handmaid's Tale Essays: The Struggle of Women

    850 Words  | 2 Pages

    The main character in the book is Offred, one of these unfortunate servants whose only right to exist depends on her ovaries’ productivity. She lives with the Commander and his wife in a highly supervised centre.

    Read More

  • Character Analysis: A Handmaid's Tale

    804 Words  | 2 Pages

    He develops a liking towards her that only she is to know about. Secret meetings and alone time sparks up multiple meetings between Commander and Offred. Despite strict rules that forbids any meeting of this sorts, they continue to do so anyway. With something to gain out of the relationship, Offred begins faking it as best as she can. Scrabble, late night talks and romantic meetups, Offred is in the process of achieving what she wants to most, answers. Answers to whatever she wants to know and other perks she may think of along the way. Offred is hesitant about the meetups at first, but realizes if she were to be caught, the punishment could be just as worse if she denies his invitation. Though other handmaids find out, it isn’t until the end when Serena Joy finds out and threatens her well being, “How could you be so vulgar?...Pick up that disgusting thing and get to your room. Just like the other one. A slut. You’ll end up the same” (p287). This is a sure threat made to Offred by Serena Joy for disobeying rules and sneaking around with the Commander. Even though Serena Joy knows that the Commander put Offred up to this, she still has little sympathy for her. Serena’s power over Offred is visible not only in this scene but others. When Offred blatantly disobeys Offred, she is well aware her punishment could be the Colonies or even

    Read More

  • Handmaid's Tale Quote Analysis

    266 Words  | 1 Pages

    Also, the influence of this passage, from the Bible, results in the gender hierarchy as well as the theme about male dominance within the Gilead society because Offred and other handmaids have to take orders from the males (Commanders).

    Read More

  • The Symbolic Meaning Behind the Black Procession in O'Conner's A Late Encounter with the Enemy

    2222 Words  | 5 Pages

    O'Conner exploits this weakness and slowly breaks the General down through the course of the story. She demonstrates the dangers of living a lie, of becoming someone that one is not. Her message is that the fate of the General will be the fate of all man if he chooses to live within a lie. O'Conner warns that life lived without human identity is comparable to Havel's river of pseudo-life. Only she uses the image of a black procession -- dark, solemn and resulting in painful death. The analogies are very different, but the message is the same.

    Read More

  • Gender Role In The Handmaid's Tale

    1029 Words  | 3 Pages

    Offred is consistently cautious when it comes to interacting with the Commander. She feels as though she has to present herself in a way that will allow her to gain his trust and utilize it in her favor. Offred says, “The Commander likes it when I distinguish myself, show precocity, like an attentive pet, prick-eared and eager to perform” (Atwood 183). When Offred poses herself in the way that the Commander expects, it shows how his power influences Offred’s actions. The connection of Offred to that of “an attentive pet” also shows how the Gilead Society has taken away her humanity. Without her humanity, Offred loses her sense of self-worth which leaves her vulnerable to the Commander’s power. Along with this constant fear of portraying herself in a manner that would upset the Commander, Offred is also afraid to give away too much information about herself which could potentially end with the Commander ceasing their private meetings together. Offred expresses, “And if I talk to him I’ll say something wrong, give something away. I can feel it coming, a

    Read More

  • Individualism In The Handmaids Tale

    834 Words  | 2 Pages

    Because these women aren’t valued, it is as if she’s not there which greatly diminishes their self-worth. One quote to highlight this claim is “All you have to do, I tell myself, is to shut your mouth and look stupid (Atwood).” This quote connects to this claim because Offred knows that she is only valuable because she can reproduce, she settles for having no self-worth and knowing that she is no longer entitled to an opinion. Offred staying quiet and dumb can be viewed as a role or mask in the persona because due to her environment of low worth find it fitting to become an

    Read More

  • handmaids tale

    1154 Words  | 3 Pages

    The central social hierarchy within the novel is the gender hierarchy, placing men in a position of extreme power. This is evident in every aspect of the book, as the entire Gilead society is male dominated. The Commander is at the top of the hierarchy and is involved with designing and establishing the current society taking control of a nation of women, and exploiting their power by controlling what is taught, what they can teach themselves and the words that they can use. Soon all of the women will become brainwashed, simply because it is made nearly impossible to defy the rules

    Read More

  • Essay on the Character of Offred in The Handmaid's Tale

    1209 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the times the commander and Offred were seeing each other secretly, he began to develop some feelings for her that he tried to hide. Somewhere along the times when Offred and the commander began having secret meetings with each other, Offred too began to develop some feelings for the commander. Offred is also a special handmaid, because she has actually experienced love, the satisfaction of having a child years before. She knows what it is to feel loved, to be in love and to have someone love you. That is all when she has knowledge, a job, a family and money of her own.

    Read More

  • The Handmaids Tale Nonconformist Analysis

    773 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this quotation Offred is describing how Moira’s once rebellious attitude has changed. “Moira,” I say. “You don’t mean that.” She is frightening me now, because what I hear in her voice is indifference, a lack of violation. Have they really done it to her then, taken away something – what? – that used to be so central to her? But how can I expect her to go on, with my idea of her courage, live it through, act it out, when I myself do not? I do not want her to be like me. Give in go along, save her skin. That’s what it comes down to. I want gallantry from her, swashbuckling, heroism, single-handed combat. Something I lack…. Anyway, look at it this way: it’s not bad, there’s a lot of women around. Butch paradise, you might call it.” (Atwood 249). Moira was captured after her escape she now works at a night club as a prostitute, because she was too dangerous to be allowed to return to the red center. Moira is content with her life and is giving up. She enjoys her work calling it a paradise. Offred misses the old rebellious Moira saying she has lost her voice and gallantry. This disappoints Offred stating “I’d like to tell a story about how Moira escaped, for good this time… I’d like to say she blew up Jezebel’s, with fifty Commanders inside it. I’d like her to end with something daring and spectacular, some outrage, something that would benefit her.” (Atwood 250). Moira conforming upset Offred,

    Read More

  • Essay On Non Existentialism In A Handmaid's Tale

    1771 Words  | 4 Pages

    The commander forces Offred to sneak out of her room every night to come meet him in his office. This is a big risk because if she gets caught leaving her room she could get whipped. Moreover, women, in general were not allowed to enter the office, however she did anyways to obey the commander’s request. Many forbidden things are done in the office. One of the many prohibited things that the commanders influenced her to do is to play scrabble. “I’d like you to play a game of Scrabble with me.” (Atwood 176). This was not allowed, since it involved a lot of reading and writing. He also made Offred change into different outfit so she could leave the house to go to a club, late at night. Even though he was a poor influence, Offred thought that saying no would put her in a large amount of danger. He also controls Offred, pressuring her to be an intimate partner. “I want you to kiss me.” (Atwood 176). The commander asks Offred for a kiss and he convinces her to have sex with him in a hotel room. She did not want this to happen, but she could not push her away, it was too much of a risk. The last thing he made her do is to drink and smoke. As a Handmaid it was forbidden to drink and smoke because it can be harmful to the baby. The commander forced her to drink, and for the first time she declined, but he kept insisting until she did. This is connected

    Read More

  • Shooting an Elephant

    1589 Words  | 4 Pages

    Overall, in this essay, Orwell uses effective language to make his narration of the story more impressive and thoughtful, and to explore an imperial officer’s struggle between his good nature and his imperial role.

    Read More

  • Feminist Criticism Of The Handmaid's Tale

    1251 Words  | 3 Pages

    Though Offred is developed as a character through her opinions on female sexuality, she is further characterized by her individuality and willingness to defy her social expectations as a female, assigned to her by her government. In Atwood’s work, the narrative is told by an intelligent individual named Offred who is oppressed by Gilead’s female expectations but is not afraid to defy these assigned roles despite not being a traditional heroine (Nakamura). Even as Offred’s previous identity is stripped away from her, she retains small pieces of her womenhood and individuality through defiant actions such as manipulating men with her feminity from swaying her hips slighty in their line of sight to making direct eye contact with certain men, which she is forbidden from. On the other hand, a major act of rebellion from

    Read More

  • Military Suicide

    307 Words  | 1 Pages

    In according with Army Regulation 600-20 (AR 600-20) (2008), “Commanders are responsible for everything their command does and fails to do”; therefore,

    Read More

  • The Cardinal of the Kremlin, Kremlin

    1088 Words  | 3 Pages

    This shows that he is very respected by his superiors and one can assume that he has worked hard to earn that respect. Later in the book the President and Colonel Decker are deciding whether or not Jack can be briefed on the identity and existence of Misha, or as he is known in the inner circle "Cardinal." Here is a response from Decker when the President asks if they can trust Jack: "Sir, he may not be military, or even worthy of any medal we have to give, but he is a true American" showing that the people around him have faith in him and that what he has done has proved to be enough to win the accolades of even the most cynical (Decker.) In conclusion, I feel that this was over all a good novel with mediocre characterization. It definitely was not on my top ten list but was not on the worst ten either. I think that Tom Clancy could have done better in the areas of both direct and indirect characterizing. For example, he could have given more of an introduction to each of the characters; he also could have had a better flowing dialogue between all the characters. Many of his characters contradicted their characterizations with their actions, which left me a little upset and at times confused. In the first 150 or so pages it is easy to get lost, you are bombarded by literally scores of Russian names that all kind of blend together, especially if you're reading late at night and somewhat

    Read More

  • Free Handmaid's Tale Essays: The Struggle of Women Handmaid's Tale Essays

    525 Words  | 2 Pages

    Offred from The Handmaid's Tale uses different tactics to cope with her situation. She is trapped within a distopian society comprised of a community riddled by despair. Though she is not physically tortured, the overwhelming and ridiculously powerful government mentally enslaves her. Offred lives in a horrific society, which prevents her from being freed. Essentially, the government enslaves her because she is a female, and she is fertile. Offred's reminisces about the way life used to be by remembering stories about her husband Luke, her daughter, and her best friend Moira, provides her with temporary relief from her binding situation. Also, Offred befriends the Commander's aide, Nick. Offred longs to be with her husband and she feels that she can find his love by being with Nick. She risks her life several times just to be with Nick. Feeling loved by Nick gives her a window of hope in her otherwise miserable life.

    Read More

More about The Commander - Both Villain and Figure of Sympathy

Open Document