The Case Against Monarchy

1620 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Concept Of Tyranny

The Case Against Monarchy

The idea that a monarchy is the ideal form of government is a fallacy. Al-Farabi and Aquinas’ ideas about government are wrong, and are filled with irreparable holes. In modern times, the idea of a monarchy has become counter-intuitive and counter-productive. A democratic republic paired with an educated and empowered middle-class is the solution to the quandary of how to create the perfect government. While the ideas of the Arabic philosophers are interesting, there ideas on the perfection of monocratic rule are outdated by both new technology and new ideas

Al-Farabi says that, “what is intended by man's existence is that he attains supreme happiness (Bailey 285).” Al-Farabi’s fixation is on that of what makes up the ideal “virtuous city”. In his ideal city, one supreme ruler who has vast amounts of knowledge commands and directs the subordinate classes. Al-Farabi lays out what makes up an ignorant city. He says a bad society is overly fixated on “bare necessities”, “wealth”, “sensual pleasures”, fame, “domination”, or “freedom” (Bailey 289). According to Al-Farabi, the ideal society is ruled by someone who can manage the problems of society or “weeds” (Bailey 289). Al-Farabi argues for a strictly monocratic government, ruled by someone who can fight temptation.

St. Thomas Aquinas believes that, "tyranny is more likely to develop from rule of the many than that of one person. Therefore monarchy is preferable (Aquinas 21).” Aquinas believes that, “dissension among the rulers leads to general dissension." He thinks that, “nearly all governments by the many have entered into tyranny, as is demonstrated in the case of the Roman commonwealth (Aquinas 23).” Aquinas compares the king to the captain of the s...

... middle of paper ...

...lta (ed.), URL = .

Thomas, and Paul E. Sigmund. St. Thomas Aquinas on Politics and Ethics. New York: Norton,

1988. Print.

Wikipedia contributors. "Abolished monarchy." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia,

The Free Encyclopedia, 14 Feb. 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2012.

Wikipedia contributors. "List of countries by date of transition to republican system of

government." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 14 Feb. 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2012.

Wikipedia contributors . "Plato's five regimes." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia,

The Free Encyclopedia, 2 Feb. 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2012.

Wikipedia contributors. "Social contract." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The

Free Encyclopedia, 14 Feb. 2012. Web. 15 Feb. 2012.

Show More
Related

  • Revival of Monarchy in Northern Europe

    390 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Inquisition run by Tomas de Torquemada persecuted other religions and was a base of counter-reformation

    Read More

  • Was absolute monarch the foundation of Democracy?

    909 Words  | 2 Pages

    In today’s world, there are several types of governments that control their countries. There are democracies, dictatorships, republics, monarchies etc. Absolute monarchy was a very common form of government centuries ago. Throughout this time period, many leaders, dictators, monarchs made mistakes that the government looks at today. The abuse and misuse of power by absolute monarchs inexorably led to the rise of modern democracy. This is shown through leaders abusing their powers as absolute monarchs, the unreliability of monarchy, and corrupt governments.

    Read More

  • England and the Austrian Habsburg Empire from the late 16th century through the late 18th century

    947 Words  | 2 Pages

    ... Constitutional Monarchy form of government was the solution not only the problems of the moment, but also the overarching issue guiding a nation and ensuring unity of effort.

    Read More

  • Collapse of the Absolute Monarchy Between May and October 1789

    1541 Words  | 4 Pages

    In 1788 Louis XVI had had to call the Estates General to ward off the

    Read More

  • The Purpose Of Government In Machiavelli's The Prince

    1192 Words  | 3 Pages

    Is the purpose of government today, similar to that of philosophers of the past, or has there been a shift in political thought? This essay will argue that according to Machiavelli’s The Prince, the purpose of government is to ensure the stability of the state as well as the preservation of the established ruler’s control, and that the best form of government should take the form of an oligarchy. In contrast, in his book, Leviathan, Thomas Hobbes argues that the purpose of government should be to preserve the peace and security of men and, that the best form of government would be an absolute monarchy which would sanction such conditions. This essay will utilize themes of glory, material advantage, peace and stability to illustrate

    Read More

  • Plato vs. Machiavelli

    1692 Words  | 4 Pages

    A longstanding debate in human history is what to do with power and what is the best way to rule. Who should have power, how should one rule, and what its purpose should government serve have always been questions at the fore in civilization, and more than once have sparked controversy and conflict. The essential elements of rule have placed the human need for order and structure against the human desire for freedom, and compromising between the two has never been easy. It is a question that is still considered and argued to this day. However, the argument has not rested solely with military powers or politicians, but philosophers as well. Two prominent voices in this debate are Plato and Machiavelli, both of whom had very different ideas of government's role in the lives of its people. For Plato, the essential service of government is to allow its citizens to live in their proper places and to do the things that they are best at. In short, Plato's government reinforces the need for order while giving the illusion of freedom. On the other hand, Machiavelli proposes that government's primary concern is to remain intact, thereby preserving stability for the people who live under it. The feature that both philosophers share is that they attempt to compromise between stability and freedom, and in the process admit that neither can be totally had.

    Read More

  • Louis XIV: An Absolute Monarch

    931 Words  | 2 Pages

    Louis XIV exemplified absolutism, and his ruling set the example for other monarchs throughout Europe. The aims for absolute monarchy was to provide ‘stability, prosperity, and order’ for your territories (458). The way Louis XIV set forth to accomplish this was to claim complete sovereignty to make laws, sanction justice, declare wars, and implement taxes on its subjects. This was all done without the approval of any government or Parliament, as monarchs were to govern ‘by divine right, just as fathers ruled their households’ (458). In Bishop Jacques-Benigne Bossuet’s Politics Drawn from the Very Words of Holy Scripture, he described that absolution was one of the four characteristics imperative to royal authority, “Without this absolute authority, he can do neither good nor suppress evil; his power must be such that no one can hope to escape him” (460). This was epitomized when Louis XIV sought to control the legal system as well as the funding of the financial resources through a centralized bureaucracy for the monarchy. The church was also brought under control, and Louis sought to do away with all other religions by revoking the Edict of Nantes. Political power was given to noblemen, who were seen as ...

    Read More

  • Aristocracy in Plato's The Republic and to Build a Democratic State

    531 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Plato' "ideal" model of a city; he chose an aristocratic form of government, describing it as the rule of the most strong, wise and intelligent. In his system people are robbed of their basic rights to live as a primitive human being. People had no right to choose what they want to be after they are born; their occupation is chosen for them by the "philosopher king." He chooses one's job after assessing one's talent in a variety of areas. ...

    Read More

  • Capitalism and Proletariats

    935 Words  | 2 Pages

    Morgan, Michael L., ed. Classics of Moral and Political Theory. 5th ed. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 2011.

    Read More

  • Aquinas Definition Of Happiness

    1464 Words  | 3 Pages

    The importance of the ultimate good must act as an entire rule of life, we must behave in a matter that is tending to the perfect good (Stephens, 2015, p. 324). Aquinas argues that for every action there must be an order of intention, that there must be a final cause that motivates us to act in the first place,this action must be always be reliable and consistent for the intention of the cause which is the ultimate good (Van-Nieuwenhove & Wawrykow, 2005).

    Read More

  • The Absolute Monarchy Of France In The 17th Century

    731 Words  | 2 Pages

    An Analysis of the Absolute Monarchy of France in the 17th Century This historical study will define the absolute monarchy as it was defied through the French government in the 17th century. The term ‘absolute” is defined I the monarchy through the absolute control over the people through the king and the royal family. All matters of civic, financial, and political governance was controlled through the king’s sole power as the monarchical ruler of the French people. In France, Louis XIII is an important example of the absolute monarchy, which controlled all facts of military and economic power through a single ruler. Udder Louis XIII’s reign, the consolidation of power away from the Edicts of Nantes to dominant local politics and sovereignty

    Read More

  • The Responsibility of the Monarchy for Their Own Downfall in 1793

    1967 Words  | 4 Pages

    or creed of a Deist, one who believes in the existence of a God or

    Read More

  • Coexistence of Equality and Inequality under the Social Contract

    1501 Words  | 4 Pages

    Morgan, Michael L., ed. Classics of Moral and Political Theory. 5th ed. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2011. Print.

    Read More

  • The Constitutional Monarchy in Britain

    883 Words  | 2 Pages

    through fear of god and so now we can abolish them as this fear is no

    Read More

  • Constitutional Monarchy and Malaysia

    2562 Words  | 6 Pages

    Jali, N.H.M., M. Redzuan, A.A. Saman, and I.H.M. Rashid. 2010. Malaysian Studies: Nationhood and Citizenship. Petaling Jaya: Prentice Hall.

    Read More

More about The Case Against Monarchy

Open Document