Technological Determinism And The Industrial Revolution

2409 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Technology and its Impact on Society

Many across the world have come to appreciate the transformation that happens with technology. The society, individual communities, countries, the world and day to day interactions have been affected by the introduction and continued use of technologies. In the midst of the still ongoing debate as to the relation between the society and technology, the document will evaluate how the social shaping perspective helps in the understanding of the organizational and social implications of technological change. In addition, this essay will evaluate Ruth Cowan’s case in her work on the industrial revolution which took place in the home in the 19th and 20th century. Though many would not consider the home setting as one befitting to be labeled as having …show more content…

Technology determinism is based on the notion that technological development and change are inevitable and the characteristics of any technology determine how it is used in the society where it was developed. The technological determinism concept is dependent on premise that social changes result from new capabilities enabled by technology (Feist et al. 2010, pp189-192). However, this is a notion that is heavily criticized by the likes of Cowan (1976) who discredit this claim. To her and her fellow critics, the whole scene in terms of events should be evaluated. Social determinism as opposed to technology determinism should be in use. Social determinism takes technology to be the result of the society where it is developed. Acts such as social processes determine the technology (Tatnall 2012, pp79-84). Technology developments throughout history have been born of social needs with the needs in this case being economic, social or political are facts supported by social determinism. With those who support social determinism such as Cowan (1976) technological developments have been informed by non- technical factors. Technology is developed with a particular objective or purpose in mind (Flichy 2007, …show more content…

In Chicago, Cyrus McCormick’s manufacturing plant introduced pneumatic molding machines. The move was not meant to modernize the plant but was meant to decapitate the union of Iron molders at the time. McCormick was engaged in battle with the same group at the time Bollier & Helfrich (2012). The system actors in form of advertisers, McCormick and Robert Moses ensure that though technologies can be appreciated for their use and purpose, the same can be in fact designed and arranged in a way they are meant to have or achieve some form of system purpose, in this case, either a social or political agenda. In other words, technologies sometimes are a way of achieving order in the world (Kaplan

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of Eric Schmidt And Jared Cohen's Our Future Selves

    721 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Our Future Selves” by Eric Schmidt and Jared Cohen construct views on countries’ technologies that changes the world on a daily basis. Conversely, technologies reconstruct countries in various simpler ways to live throughout economic trends. Furthermore, the quality of life is massively changing with new technologies. Consequently, wealthy countries are viewed differently from poor countries towards technological advantages. Ordinarily, technologies have made the difficult obstacles so much easier than just by hand. Industries have utilized the advanced technologies to provide huge manufacturing productivity. Moreover, Eric Schmidt and Jared Cohen have some very compelling reservations within their article, “Our Future Selves”, on the trends

    Read More

  • Analysis Of David Noble Progress Without People: In Defence Of Luddism

    1907 Words  | 4 Pages

    In today’s fast paced modern society, there are many individual’s who wish we could turn back time to the where we weren’t surrounded by computers, cell phones and all manners of surveillance and recording. Many say that these things have added a hassle to our lives by being striped away from our own personal privacy and educational learning experiences. However, the evolvement of new technology during the industrial revolution was more then just the loss of privacy and quality education, but the loss of jobs that many blue collared workers relied on. In the English industrial revolution of the 19th century, industries were being revolutionized by new mechanization and organizational techniques which took the place of hand produced work. This

    Read More

  • Daguerreotype-Louis-Jacques-Mande Daguerre

    1379 Words  | 3 Pages

    Wiebe E Bijker, T. P. (1987). The Social Construction of Technological Systems. London: The MIT Press.

    Read More

  • Langdon Winner's Theory Of Technological Determinism?

    1104 Words  | 3 Pages

    Technology is crucial in influencing society, therefore it is imperative to understand what influences technological development and how it changes society, such as social shaping and theories of technological determinism. Langdon Winner supports the social determination of technology through the findings of others and his theories of politically influenced technologies, thus Winner accounts for technological determinism through defining the theory in this context.

    Read More

  • Robert Heilbroner The Worldly Philosophers Summary

    825 Words  | 2 Pages

    Technology brought the world not only new things but new problems. People were unsure of how to deal with new innovations and unregulated items. New technologies were viewed for a long time as bad until the final shift came along. Inventing, the final paradigm shift spoken about in Heilbroner’s book, brought for the first time a sense of ease to the communities who had recently been bewildered and confused by the new technology. As Heilbroner puts it, “The idea of invention itself took hold; experimentation and innovation were looked on for the first time with a friendly eye.

    Read More

  • Machinery And The Industrial Revolution

    1162 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout history there has been a vast development of organisation which has led us to today’s modern factory systems. Machinery and the Industrial Revolution in the 19th century obviously play a vital role in these changes however before we can analyse how they have influenced the system greatly; we have to understand how the organisations came about in the first place and how they have changed in order to have created the demand for machinery and therefore the industrial revolution. There has been much debate over what prompted development and change. Marglin (1974) states that it wasn’t the new machinery and industrial revolution that prompted change it was in fact, the control and new efficiency from the old organisation systems to the more modern factory system that created the demand. He questions whether work organization is determined by society or technology and asks whether hierarchical authority is really necessary for high levels of production (Marglin 1974 p19). However others disagreed and it is still an ongoing debate eg. David Landes (1969) argues that the symbol of revolution was a combination of technological and cultural factors.

    Read More

  • Smarter Than You Think

    664 Words  | 2 Pages

    Societal changes stem from many forces including economic and cultural. From some theorists perspective that technology is neutral, technology would not become an important force-- it would act as a tool to advance already existing attitudes. On the contrary, technology is not neutral, the mere existence influences the everyday life of people in society. Technology cannot be described as an empty item controlled with specific intentions of the user; rather, technology can persuade and manipulate the actions of people both positively and negativity. Some perceive technology as the force behind a narrow focus of enhancement that disregards anything it has undone-- old world morals and meaning. Others convey the importance of technology through

    Read More

  • The Industrial Revolution: The Great Divergence

    1563 Words  | 4 Pages

    After doing a bit of reading about the Great Divergence and the factors that possibly lead to its occurrence, it's quite apparent that there is quite a bit of controversy on this topic. The Great Divergence began in the later years of the fifteenth century. The Great Divergence occurred when parts of Europe and North America became prosperous. Europe and North America flourished while other parts of the world were poverty-stricken. This is where the name the Great Divergence comes from great divergence means the great dividing.

    Read More

  • Understanding Technology: Beyond Everyday Electronics

    604 Words  | 2 Pages

    Corporations feed off of power, money, and competition. “These people and their organizations operate in a network of resources, skills, applications, economic and political supports, and cultural understanding” (pg. 140). When we think of technology as a system we must look at the production aspect of it which include regulations and laws. Companies and corporations are competitors for profit which easily leads to conflict. According to Hutchinson technology as a system cannot be understood without power. To America, technology is everything that makes life easier; we are always using things that allow better quality and faster service. However, America is quick to forget about the underlying aspect of technology. The social nature of technology is emphasized throughout the chapter, including the social content from which new ideas, devices, and skills emerge (Hutchinson). So what does it really take to gain this power? One example I thought was appropriate from the book is on page 140, the railroad. The book goes into detail that the invention of the railroad is much more than just wood, steel, tracks, etc. There is an entire legislation behind the scenes that is creating the funding for the railroad to be functional. This is a perfect example of how corporations and state work in technology systems. Companies are the backers, putting in time, money, experience, development,

    Read More

  • Does Technology Drive Social Transformation

    701 Words  | 2 Pages

    What is technology and how does it drive social transformation? Technology is the universe of tools, means, and methods through which we interact with our environment. Technology causes social change and is itself influenced by culture. Technological advances such as automobiles, airplanes, radio, television, cellular phones, computers, and fax machines have brought major advances changes.

    Read More

  • Technology Vs. Society: The Role Of Technology And Society

    1316 Words  | 3 Pages

    As we now see that Technology and Society are interdependent on each other to an extent, we must ask ourselves what is technology exactly. According to the syllabus, ”Technology can be represented as one means by which society meets its needs and solves many of its problems” Syllabus. Black and Harrison in their 1994 publication seemed to agree, stating that “Technology has been called upon, when practical solutions to problems have been called for.” (Black and Harrison, 1994, p.13) Both of these references suggest that technology is there to help us, helping us to solve problems in our everyday lives. However, we must question these practical solutions on the basis as to what the problems are? And also, who creates these problems? It could be said that it is society as a whole creates these problems which then creates a niche for these new techn...

    Read More

  • Positive Impacts of Technology

    968 Words  | 2 Pages

    The standard 21 year old adults have exchanged 250 thousand emails, spent 5 thousand hours video gaming and 10 thousand hours using their mobile devices (Lei, 2009). When people hear the word technology, they think of microwaves, televisions, cars, NASA, different types and transportation and more. For all that, technology has occurred long ahead these discoveries. Technology is an arguable matter amongst people. .In the old days, people lived an extremely simple life without technology. They used candles to light their houses and lanterns at the dark to travel, they used fire to cook and used newspapers and mail to share news. On the other hand, technology has seized an important place in our society. People are living in a stage of progressive technology. They are using all natural reserves applicable for making their lives better and easier. The society cannot picture life without electricity since it allows them to live through their everyday life. This paper argues that technology positively impacts people’s lives.

    Read More

  • Technology and Social Change

    336 Words  | 1 Pages

    Today, Americans are faced with the increasing change of technology in our everyday life. Sometimes the change happens and we do not realize how it affects our lives. I think it is always a good idea to talk to someone that is older than yourself, like your grandparents to remind you of the times in their younger years. Hopefully, that will open your eyes to the changes we face in this generation and the generation to come. In this chapter, the author explores the relationship of changing technology to changes in both the environment and social institutions.

    Read More

  • Technological Determinism And The Relationship Between Technology And Society

    1548 Words  | 4 Pages

    The social construction of technology holds that the path of technological development is more or less shaped by society itself. In other words, political decisions, economic allocations, and social arrangements influence the direction of technological progress. The framework of the social construction of technology is mainly based on the pessimism towards technology and science from the mid-20th century. In the early 20th century, humanity saw how evil technology could become by human manipulation. The brutal human experimentations committed by the Nazi and Japanese troops and the use of biochemistry medicine and nuclear energy as weapons of mass destruction revealed how humans could exploit technology to attain inhumane goals. As world leaders began emphasizing the need to control the course of technological development, some scholars began to suggest the social construction of technology theory in contradiction of the conventional technological determinism

    Read More

  • The Relationship Between Technology and Society

    1278 Words  | 3 Pages

    This paper discusses the relationship between technology and society. It focuses on how technology has influenced various aspects of the society. The areas looked are: how technology has affected the communication, transportation, education, health, economic activities, environment, food production, food conservation and preservation and food distribution. It has gone further to explain how technology has radically changed the demographic structure of the societies in question, specifically Japan society. In addition, it has discussed how technology has influenced government policy formulation.

    Read More

More about Technological Determinism And The Industrial Revolution

Open Document