THE CONTRACTING EARTH THEORY: AN OUTDATED UNIFYING PARADIGM IN EARTH SCIENCES

639 Words2 Pages

Leibniz (1691) wrote that the Earth has cooled down from a liquid state. Dana (1843-1873) described oceanic subsidence and mountain-building as results of the thermal contraction of the Earth. Lyell suggested that, due to unequal cooling, parts of the Earth sink faster than the rest, so that continents of the past have become ocean floors today and vice versa. Suess (1885, Vol. 1, p. 778) said that “the collapse of the world is what we are witnessing”. This paper reviews the Contracting Earth Theory.

INTRODUCTION
The Contracting Earth Hypothesis was once a dominant paradigm in geology (Wegener, 1929). The origins of this theory can be found in the works of European scientists such as Constant Prévost [d.1856], Henry de la Beche [d.1855] and Léonce Élie de Beaumont [d.1874] (Greene, 1982). James Dwight Dana [d. 1895], an American geologist, was a key contributor to the development of this theory. The Contraction Hypothesis did not completely fall out of favor until the Plate Tectonics appeared: Hans Stille [d.1966] and Leopold Kober [d.1970] were prominent advocates of this theory (Pamir, 1960). However, from early 20th century on, it competed with another global geological theory: the Continental Drift of Alfred Wegener, which can be considered a precursor of the Plate Tectonics. In this paper, we discuss the Contracting Earth Hypothesis with a literature review and compare it to the Continental Drift.
The Contraction Theory supposes the interior of the Earth to be diminishing in size as a result of cooling, which then puts the rigid crust under stress and leads to tectonic motions. A simple illustration of this process is seen in an apple that is drying up and wrinkling [originally, C. Prévost’s idea (Greene, 1982)]. This theor...

... middle of paper ...

...e: Bulletin de la Société Géologique de France, 1(4), p. 723-825.
Pamir, H. N., 1960, Dinamik Jeoloji: Istanbul.
Rogers, W. B. and Rogers, H. D., 1843, On the physical structure of the Appalachian Chain as exemplifying the laws which have regulated the elevation of great mountain chains generally: Transactions of American Geologists and Naturalists for 1840-1842, p. 474-531.
Schardt, H., 1893, Sur l’origine des Préalpes romandes: Archives des Sciences physiques et. Naturelles de Genève, 30, p. 570-583.
Staub, R., 1924, Der Bau der Alpen: Beiträge zur geologischen Karte der Schweiz: Bern.
Suess, E., 1885, Das Antlitz der Erde: Vienna.
Suess, E., 1911, Synthesis of the Paleo-geography of North America: American Journal of Science, 4th series, v. 32, p. 101-108.
Wegener, A., 1929, Die Entstehung der Kontinente und Ozeane [translated by Biram, J., 1966: New York, NY].

Open Document