Gina Stelluti v. Casapenn Enterprises, LLC, d/b/a Powerhouse Gym
FACTS
Stelluti joined gym On Jan 13, 2004, Injury occurred the day she joined the gym. While participating in Spinning class at the fitness center, she started pedaling in a seated position. She altered the position from seated to standing on their bikes.
When she upturns to standing position, the handlebars ejected out from the bike. As a result, she fell ahead while her feet attached to strapped to the pedals. However, she succeeded in disconnected herself from a bike and she resumed the participation. she soon had to find herself in immense pain.
She was having pain in her neck and soreness in her thigh and back. she claimed that she felt continuous pain because of this
…show more content…
incident but her medical expert stated that she was suffering from myofascial pain for 3 years. Stelluti filed a case and complaint about damages in law Division against Powerhouse which comprised negligence claim against the powerhouse. ISSUE Stelluti signed an agreement with defendant powerhouse gym for Membership at brick, New Jersey Facility. She filled out 3 Forms Membership Agreement Form, Membership Information Form, and Health and Safety Consent which asked many questions regarding Physical condition. These Form Also provide information to the customer to wear the Proper footwear and clothes RELEVANT LAW Identifying that the standardized pre-printed document needed for membership to the club facility accustomed contract of adhesion d.
at 448-50, the panel first applied the factors identified in Rudbart v. North Jersey District Water Supply Commission, 127 N.J. 344, 356 (1992)
A contract cohesion is defined as formed on nonnegotiable basis, commonly in a standardized printed form, without opportunity for the ‘adhering’ party to negotiate.” Rudbart, supra, 127 N.J. at 353. In contrast, a contract of may need to one party to choose either to accept or reject the contract as is, the agreement nevertheless may be enforced. See id. at 353, 356-61
APPLICATION OF LAW
Gym submitted the summary of Expert Liability report, according to that handlebars have chrome stem post and fully handlebars may be detached and separated from the bike. The Post was 7 inches tall and have seven elevation positioning holes.
Gym expert said that Beginner would not notice that mark. Powerhouse expert commented that accident happened because the handlebars displayed on the stationary bicycle that she was using unanticipated and without warning detaches from bicycle causing her fall. As defendant filed a motion for summary
judgment. Before the trial court needed the further briefing on whether common law postulate liability impose. The court granting summary judgment in favor of powerhouse. The judge Found that exculpatory agreement was enforceable because the gym was not subject to perform under the legal duty by any rules. Furthermore, Stelluti signed the waiver and understood the agreement provision while signing it. CONCLUSION The case implicated an exculpatory release from liability for injuries occurred at the training facility. The plaintiff was injured not by an equipment malfunction but falling when she was complying with an order to lift heavy bars. REFERENCE Gina Stelluti v. Casapenn Enterprises, retrived from http://www.morelaw.com/verdicts/case.asp?n=%28A-43-09%29&s=NJ&d=44504 2. New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division - Published Opinions Decisions › 2009 › GINA STELLUTI v. CASAPENN retrived from https://law.justia.com/cases/new-jersey/appellate-division-published/2009/a3780-07-opn.html
Cynthia Adae was taken to Clinton Memorial Hospital on June 28, 2006. She was taken to the hospital with back and chest pain. A doctor concluded that she was at high risk for acute coronary syndrome. She was transferred to the Clinton Memorial hospital emergency room. She reported to have pain for two or three weeks and that the pain started in her back or her chest. The pain sometimes increased with heavy breathing and sometimes radiated down her left arm. Cynthia said she had a high fever of 103 to 104 degrees. When she was in the emergency room her temperature was 99.3, she had a heart rate of 140, but her blood
Case citation: Awkerman v. Tri-County Orthopedic Group, 373 N.W.2d 204 (Mich. Ct. App. 1985). (Child abuse reporting)
There were no concealed, unreasonably increased risks present at the time of the incident. D’Agostino graduated Massapequa High School in 2000. When the plaintiff’s injury caused, D’Agostino was 27 years old and weighed 275 pounds. When he was in high school, he wrestled for all four years, and he won some championship. On the other hand, the plaintiff was 6’2”, weighted 275. He was under age. He had many experiences of wrestling because he wrestled from 7th grade through 12th grade. Thus, they were almost in the same situation, except for their
Her little boy wasn't expected to make it through the night, the voice on the line said (“Determined to be heard”). Joshua Deshaney had been hospitalized in a life threatening coma after being brutally beat up by his father, Randy Deshaney. Randy had a history of abuse to his son prior to this event and had been working with the Department of Social Services to keep custody over his son. The court case was filed by Joshua's mother, Melody Deshaney, who was suing the DSS employees on behalf of failing to protect her son from his father. To understand the Deshaney v. Winnebago County Court case and the Supreme courts ruling, it's important to analyze the background, the court's decision, and how this case has impacted our society.
Frye v. United States and Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals are both legal decisions that set forth standards as they pertain to the admissibility of scientific or forensic evidence, and the admissibility of expert witness testimony. Both cases deal with the admissibility of evidence in judicial proceedings, and prevent prosecutors from abusing the use of expert witnesses and testimony. Due to a loophole that dismisses recent scientific advances when applying the Frye Rule, the Supreme Court revisited Frye, and “took the occasion to issue guidelines for deciding the admissibility of scientific evidence” (Gaensslen, Harris, & Henry, 2008, p. 53). The decision resulted in a five-prong approach called the Daubert Standard.
In the book Cycle of Hope, Tricia Downing went from a competitive cyclist to a paraplegic in a matter of minutes. After spending the summer competing in multiple cycling races, Downing is back home enjoying the sunny autumn day riding her favorite route with her friend, Matt. Together, they go for a bike ride sightseeing and appreciating the beauty of the city. As they reminisce about their enjoyable summer, a car appears out of nowhere, and crashes into her. After landing on her back, Downing recalls that something feels terribly wrong; consequently, this woman becomes paralyzed from the waist down. The author uses the strength, courage, and determination learned as a competitive athlete to overcome her disability.
In “A Work in Progress” by Aimee Mullins the main character is Aimee. As an infant she had both legs amputated below her knee, and at age five had a major surgery to correct the growth of her tibia. After the surgery, she was first put into a wheelchair, and her teacher called her a distraction and that she shouldn’t attend school anymore. She had struggled as a child with being in a wheelchair, but gets prosthetics when she gets older and decides she wants to become an Athlete. She becomes comfortable prosthetic legs and becomes the athlete she always dreamed she could be.
Since one of the prominent concerns she has is related to health, she needs to be reassured by a physician that these symptoms are not dangerous, along with being aware about the fact that she misinterprets these symptoms and these symptoms can be created if she persistently focus on the certain parts of her body.
While working, Alex Bennett slipped and fell onto a lumber saw, severing his ankle joint. After cleaning and stitching his hanging foot to his leg, Myra and Alex traveled 60 miles to the doctor in Bonne Bay while Myra was pregnant. Due to her efforts, amputation was avoided. (Green, 1973/2012, pp. 127-133)
In a memo from Helia Hull dated September 20, 2016, the details of the incident involve an inadvertent disclosure of privileged attorney-client documents submitted for discovery by Rosen & Quinn of Chicago, council for defendant in Whelan v. Speedy Motors, Inc. The suit arose as a product liability case from the alleged injuries suffered by Ms. Whelan when the accelerator pedal installed in a Wondercart manufactured by Speedy, failed to function properly. On behalf of Speedy our office was retained for the purpose of performing certain aspects of discovery that later proved to be the result of the inadvertent disclosure.
...the pressure of those moments will follow me the rest of my life…When Kerri is making the final vault, I am thinking, One legged, no legged, just stay there. And bless her heart, she did it” (Jenkins 39). Kerri landed square, desperately trying to keep the weight off of her left foot. She hopped on one foot to acknowledge the judges and then collapsed in a heap of tears and frustration. The rest was a blur. America cheered as Bela carried her to the stand to receive her gold. There were so many emotions playing across her face as the national anthem played: pain, happiness, and a deep sadness because her injury would end her Olympic experience (Parillo n.pag). Kerri’s bravery acts as a symbol to all human beings. If a four foot ten, one hundred pound girl can carry the weight of an entire nation on only one ankle, then who’s to say that anything is impossible?
J.P., a 58 year old female, presents to the Emergency Room on March 18th. She has a past medical history of cervical cancer, atheroembolism of the left lower extremity, fistula of the vagina, peripheral vascular disease, neuropathy, glaucoma, GERD, depression, hypertension, chronic kidney disease, and sickle cell anemia. She complains of right lower extremity pain accompanied by fatigue, a decreased appetite, increased work of breathing, burning urination, and decreased urine output for three days. Upon admission, a complete physical assessment was performed along with a blood and metabolic panel. The assessment revealed many positive and negative findings.
Explain the issue or dilemma using information from the readings in the book and other sources.
I stood up, shook the dust off, and climbed back up on the bike. I felt how proud my mother was to watch me try again. She chanted that I could do this. Taking in a few deep breaths to calm my nerves enough to place my feet back on the pedals. Once again, I pedaled as fast as I could to gain momentum while trying to maintain my balance. My mother still behind me supporting me. She then let go of me and I kept going. I didn’t fall that time. Finally, I could ride a bike by myself without help. My mother cheered me on as I rode my newly improved bike to the end of the block and back. Once I arrived back to her, I stopped and gave her a gigantic hug. A soft cry came from my mother. I questioned why she had tears coming down her face, but she said it was tears of happiness.
Ben Rupert, a firefighter with Station 12, says his mind immediately went to the worse possibility when he heard a child was struck while riding a bike. Thankfully, though, Matthew wasn’t critically injured. The injuries to his body were only minor. The damage to his bike; however, was quite significant. Rupert said, “You couldn’t use the bicycle. It was damaged to the point where the tires and breaks were pretty bad.” Another fireman suggested they take Matthew’s bike back to the fire station with them in hopes of fixing it. The bike that was damaged in the accident had been a gift to Matthew at Christmas, so the young boy wanted to save his bike. He was hoping the firemen could work a miracle and repair his