Similarities Between Dr. Jekyll And Mr. Hyde And The Picture Of Dorian Gray

1720 Words4 Pages

It is know that the human-self has conflicting counterparts that are hidden from the rest of

the world. Sigmund Freud stated that there are three parts of the human psychic parts, which are

super-ego, ego, and Id (Mitchell, n.d.,). The super-ego is the human counterpart where it is highly

conscious of moral values, and Id is described as the darkest human desires that are kept away,

while ego serves as a mediator between super-ego and Id to balance both parts. Although these

psychological phenomenon are better researched in these modern times, they were not widely

understood in the old days, for example, the 19th century Victorian Era. People back then did not

understood the odd psychological disorders deeply, thus many people …show more content…

Presenting the concept of the hidden self, the two main characters are somehow similar but they

have different attitudes towards morality. This essay will evaluate both characters' personalities,

starting from Dr. Jekyll then Dorian Gray, and also how these characters are different from each

other.

Firstly, it could be seen that Dr. Jekyll was the ego and Hyde was the projection of Jekyll's

Id. Dr. Jekyll was described as an elderly but handsome man with a high social standing and

everyone was fond of him. In contrast, from Enfield's recount, Hyde was described as a deformed

human being, from the line "It wasn't like a man; it was like some damned Juggernaut." (Stevenson

1886, p. 40) He further emphasised the loathing people had for Hyde at first glance by describing a

doctor's reaction in the child trampling incident "Well, sir, he was like the rest of us; every time he

looked at my prisoner, I saw that Sawbones turn sick and white with desire to kill him.". This

portrayal of Jekyll and Hyde fits the stereotype where good people are described as beautiful and

graceful creatures, while evil beings are described as hideous and repulsive. Because Hyde was …show more content…

Also, in terms of self realisation, Dorian Gray is

considered to be more self-accepting than Dr. Jekyll. Even though both characters enjoys doing bad

deeds, compared to Dorian, Jekyll tried to suppress Hyde from taking over his mind. He hated the

idea that Hyde might endanger anyone because he is still and foremost a victorian gentleman. This

hatred of Hyde could be seen from the line "I still hated and feared the thought of the brute that

slept within me, and I had not of course forgotten the appalling dangers of the day

before." (Stevenson 1886, p.77). Different from Jekyll, Dorian unleashed his devil within without

having to hide them from the public. He fully accepted the idea that he is doing nothing wrong at all

and he was merely satisfying his curiosity in life. Nevertheless, he was still unconsciously ashamed

of his tainted soul, thus he hid his portrait. However, both characters also had different impacts

towards society. Dorian's bad deeds had an effect to a number of people in the society, causing

people to sneer and avoid him, while Jekyll was still loved by his friends and all around him.

Open Document