Should Canada Break Up Essay

Should Canada break up? Canada is the second largest country with great health care, education systems, and job opportunities. Canada is diverse in many ways economically, culturally, politically and regionally. However, these diversities have caused conflicts and issues within Canada, for example, the 1995 sovereignty referendum. Thus, Canada should break up due to these diversities that have only led to dissatisfaction and resentment of our federal government.

Firstly, Canada should separate because of the economic diversity. For instance, the equalization program which makes prosperous provinces share its wealth to provinces that need extra funding. This is done by the federal government giving some of the tax revenue to less wealthy provinces which have caused unfair treatment to provinces that are economically stable. Consequently, provinces like Ontario does not benefit from the taxes they pay. Ontario receives less public services per capita than the residences of most other provinces and in 2013, the Mowat center revealed that Ontarians send $11 billion more to the federal government than it receives back in transfer payments. Therefore, due to the economic diversity, equalization has caused mistreatment to wealthier provinces.

Secondly, our cultural diversity has caused conflicts in Canada.

For example, in Central Canada, Quebec is so different from the rest of Canada culturally and language wise that for some people staying in Canada’s confederation is intolerable and needs to be separated. Take the 1995 sovereignty referendum as an example, When the votes were in, the no side won by a narrow majority of 50.58 percent, only a 1 percent margin. Even after the victory of the 1995 referendum, it did not solve any of the issues, there’s still unrest and the need to protect Quebec’s language and culture from the rest of Canada. Hence, our differences culturally are not being acknowledged and are causing an uproar of conflicts in Canada’s

confederation.

Furthermore, Canada should break up because of political diversity. For example, the west alienation. The west is excluded many times in the federal government and has felt that their priorities are not heard and appreciated by the Canadian government. In 1973, the oil prices increased exceptionally, the government tried to relieve the oil price weight by before they calculated federal taxes owning, freezing oil prices, and imposing an oil export tax, they forbid resource companies from reducing provincial royalty charges. The west felt that the increase in oil prices was their opportunity gain more profits to diversify their economies and felt that the federal government was putting the need of Central Canada over the West. In addition in the 1980’s, the NEP, the National Energy Policy created which allowed the Canadian government to extract the oil and use it independently which alienated the West farther. For that reason, Canada should split up because some regions feel that the Canadian government concerns are only for the Central Canada’s interests.

In conclusion, Canada should break up. Due to the fact that Canada's diversity, economically, culturally, politically and regionally have not benefitted Canada instead it causes challenges in Canada's confederation. These differences continue to bring Canada farther apart.