Shannon Dudley's 'Judging'

424 Words1 Page

Subject/ Topic

In “Judging “By the Beat”: Calypso versus Soca”, Shannon Dudley explores the idea of rhythmic feel. The author is looking at a way to analyze and describe different, but closely related, musical styles and genres in African and African American music. The method she is looking at, in particular is rhythmic feel. Here in this article Dudley focuses on calypso and soca, which are two Trinidadian styles of music that are very similar to one another, but have elements that differ. Dudley investigates this topic by analyzing the interactive rhythmic feel of calypso by contrasting African and western concepts and practices. Conclusion

Shannon Dudley concluded that western musical concepts do not acknowledge the importance of rhythmic feel in African and African American music. Analyzing calypso demonstrates her topic of rhythmic feel is important in distinguishing African and African American genres from one another. …show more content…

285) so examining the distinguishing factors of the two styles one should focus on rhythmic patterns. Even though Calypso and soca both have fixed rhythms but antiphonal structure is characteristic of soca, not calypso. Calypso hase an African base, while soca may have been influenced by East Indian music, and “if these traits [soca rhythms] were indeed rekindled by East Indian influence, they were only accepted because of their similarity to familiar African traits” ” (Dudley, 1996, p. 287). In the end, she found that interactive rhythmic feel cannot determine whether or not soca comes from the calypso tradition and that the determining factor of genre boundaries is really based on what the listeners and the musicians perceive the music to be, but interactive rhythmic feel can help distinguish the two styles based on their rhythmic

More about Shannon Dudley's 'Judging'

Open Document