The end of the Civil War in 1865 ended slavery and made African Americans “free and equal”. However, many of the Africans Americans were still not satisfied with America; because they were supposed to be free, but they were not treated equally in the 20th century. This was due to segregation which said that African Americans were separate from whites but equal. Unfortunely, for the African Americans segregation was unconstitutional, because the facilities that were given by white Americans to the Negro were considerably worse than what the whites had. African Americans were outraged at the decision of the Supreme Court Case, Plessey v. Ferguson (1896), where it was deemed that segregation was constitutional. The harsh treatment of the African …show more content…
Americans led them to start the Civil Rights Movement where African Americans fought for better rights. Two black leaders stood up above the rest to fight for African American Rights. Those two leaders were Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X. In his text, David Howard- Pitney gathered several documents about the two leaders that told how their experiences and goals were different for each other which led to them opposing each other’s ideas, they both wanted and contributed to make the lives of African Americans better, but Martin Luther King Jr. had a greater impact than Malcolm X. The experiences with white people in their early life and religion had an impact on Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X on how they fought for African American rights. King had a better experience with the white community than Malcolm. However, at one point King almost succumbed in to the hatred of the white Americans. It was mentioned in the text that, “when King was six years old, he had a white friend. The white friend later ended the relationship because of race problems. This angered King and made him want to hate the whites.” Fortunately, his religion taught him to not make enemies with white Americans, but to befriend them. This helps explain why King fights for integration later in the text, “My parents would always tell me that I should not hate the white {man}, but that it was my duty as a Christian to love them.” Since King was very religious, he followed this and was optimistic that he can help African Americans and whites to get along. Malcolm X’s encounter with whites made it really simple on why he had hatred towards them and wanted to be completely separated from them. The whites basically ruined his family’s life, “the Black Legion killed his father” and “his mother was send to mental hospital by white people.” This obviously made his hatred rise against the whites because of the unjust hatred of the whites against the blacks. Malcolm’s religion also shaped on how he was going to deal with segregation. He learned from his new Muslim religion, that “The White man is the devil” . He accepted this and was the reason he wanted to be separated from them. King and Malcolm’s different experiences led them to have different goals and different strategies to end segregation and racism in America.
King wanted desegregation but his ultimate goal was integration. King explained integration as better than desegregation because “integration is the positive acceptance of desegregation and welcomed participation of Negroes into the total range of human activities.” Integration is beneficial to the Negroes because it made them have better rights and made them more connected to the whites in the society. To fight for integration, King used Civil Right Laws to try to stop segregation. However, King did not believe that the Civil Right laws were enough to get the whites and African Americans integrated because he claimed that, “Although the laws brought an end to segregated facilities. Civil Right laws cannot bring an end to fears, prejudice which are the barriers to a truly integrated society.” He explains this because even though the laws were in place. White Americans still attacked African Americans with racism. Another strategy implemented by King was nonviolence. Professor Davis stated in lecture that “King used nonviolence because he saw how successful Gandhi was in India against England.” In his letter in Birmingham City Jail on 1963, He wrote to Clergymen expressing that nonviolence direct action “creates a crisis and established tension that a community had constantly refused to negotiate is forced to confront the issue.” …show more content…
This praises nonviolence because the government is forced to look at the situation and confirm that segregation is unconstitutional. Malcolm, on the other hand, was different on his goals from King.
He was fought for Black Power and independence from white race. Malcolm described his intentions as, “a complete separation from this wicked race of devils” , which illustrated the hatred he had against whites. Malcolm X did not believe in Kings methods of nonviolence. Instead Malcolm X suggested that, “asserting African Americans’ right to self-defense and keeping the threat of retributive violence alive was strategically necessary to get a positive response from whites.” To a certain extent he is right that they need to protect themselves, but fighting “fire against fire” just led to more chaos. Since, the 20th century was where whites were superior it just caused more trouble to the African
Americans. King and Malcolm X were in opposition to each other because of the ideas they used to fight for better rights for African Americans. King in Howard-Pitney’s text argues against Malcolm’s tactic of violence when he says that “Violence only brings temporary results, violence never brings permanent peace. It solves no social problem; it creates new and complicated ones.” This provided an explanation of why King did not agree with Malcolm’s standpoint of violence. Malcolm X also criticized Kings tactics of integration. Malcolm X thought of King negatively because he felt King was a puppet for the white leaders against African Americans. Malcolm expressed by announcing that, “King is the best weapon that the white man, who wants to brutalize Negroes, has ever gotten in this country, because when the white man attacks Negroes, they can’t defend themselves, because King has put this foolish philosophy out-you’re not supposed to fight or defend yourself.” It can be easily realized that Malcolm X had a disapproval of King because of the way he influenced African Americans to be nonviolent. As mentioned before, they are both similar because they wanted African Americans lives to be better. There ideas were similar in that “they stood resolutely in calling for black resistance to racial oppression.” It can be seen that they wanted the black community to be prideful for their rights. Malcolm was first hateful of whites. Later in Malcolm’s career, he learned that all whites are not evil just like King preached. This came to be true when Malcolm gave his speech at the Organization of Afro-Americans unity implying towards the whites that “whichever one of you acts with me, you’re alright with me.” This is a large stepping stone for Malcolm because he used to hate all whites not matter what, but in 1964 he formed a similar opinion with King that the white race is not all evil. They both had a great impact because they both influenced the black community to fight for better rights. King, however, had a greater impact than Malcolm X. King’s nonviolent movements like the Montgomery Bus Boycott and Sit-ins made the government see that segregation was unconstitutional and needed to change America. For Martin Luther King Jr., our understanding of him changed because he was first extremely popular with African Americans but later on in history, “Groups as diverse as feminists, gay rights activists, peace forces, pro-life movement all invoke King to support their causes.” In conclusion, King and Malcolm X fought for the lives of African Americans to be better. They had different uprisings which made them believe in a certain way to stop segregation in America. King fought for integration, while Malcolm fought for separation. They opposed each other tactics. Although, they both had a good impact on the Civil Rights Struggle, Martin Luther King Jr had a greater impact because his tactic of nonviolence led the Government to see that segregation is unconstitutional and that change needed to occur to make lives in America better.
Throughout American History, many minorities have fallen victim to cruel discrimination and inequality, African Americans were one of such minorities that greatly suffered from the white majority’s upper hand. After the end of the Civil War and the Reconstruction period following it, many people, especially the Southern population, were extremely against African Americans obtaining equal rights in the American society. Due to this, these opponents did everything in their power to limit and even fully strip African Americans of their rights. The Supreme Court case of Plessy v Ferguson in 1896 is an excellent example of the obstacles put forth by the white population against their black counterparts in their long and arduous fight for civil liberty and equality. Even though the court upheld the discriminatory Louisiana law with an 8-1 decision, John Marshall Harlan’s dissent in the case played a significant role in the history of the United States for it predicted all the injustice African Americans would be forced to undergo for many more years, mainly due to this landmark decision.
Of the people whose names are mentioned in history, some men like Thomas Edison are praised for their genius minds, while others such as Adolf Hitler are criticized for leaving a depressing legacy behind. While it is relative easy to notice the type of legacies these two men left, legacies of other men are often vague and they seem to be imbedded in gray shadows. This is how many people view the life of Malcolm X. Malcolm X during his lifetime had influenced many African Americans to step up for their rights against the injustices by the American government. One on hand, he has been criticized for his hard stances that resemble extremism, while on the other hand he has been praised him for his effort in raising the status for African Americans. The extremes in viewing his life from the modern day perspective have often come from reading his climatic speech The Ballot or the Bullet that he gave in many cities across America in 1964. When he was with the Nation of Islam, Malcolm X favored Blacks to be separated from the Whites, and during this time he strongly opposed White Supremacy. This also seems quite prevalent in his speech The Ballot or the Bullet. However, one events during the last year of his life reveal that he wanted the Blacks and the Whites to coexist as peaceful Americans.
Blacks were left at the mercy of ex-slaveholders and former Confederates, as the United States government adopted a laissez-faire policy regarding the “Negro problem” in the South. The era of Jim Crow brought to the American Negro disfranchisement, social, educational, and occupational discrimination, mass mob violence, murder, and lynching. Under a sort of peonage, black people were deprived of their civil and human rights and reduced to a status of quasi-slavery or “second-class” citizenship. Strict legal segregation of public facilities in the southern states was strengthened in 1896 by the Supreme Court’s decision in the Plessy vs. Ferguson case. Racists, northern and southern, proclaimed that the Negro was subhuman, barbaric, immoral, and innately inferior, physically and intellectually, to whites—totally incapable of functioning as an equal in white civilization.
Non-violent direct action and respectful disagreement are a form of civil disobedience. Martin Luther King, Jr. defines “civil disobedience” as a way to show others what to do when a law is unjust and unreasonable. King is most famous for his role in leading the African American Civil Rights Movement and using non-violent civil disobedience to promote his beliefs. King also firmly believed that civil disobedience was the way to defeat racial segregation against African Americans. While leading a protest march on the streets, King was arrested and sent to jail. In response to his imprisonment and an article he read while there, King wrote Letter from Birmingham Jail, explaining that an injustice affects everyone and listed his own criteria for
he had grown frustrated with the non-violent, integrated struggle for civil rights and worried that blacks would ultimately lose control of their own movement. The reason Malcolm X was so beloved and iconic was due to him being a key figure in the black movement about the same time as Martin Luther King jr.. The era of the 1950-1960, advocating black pride, a separate black community and violence disguised as self defense. He stood against white aggression. Changing the last name of his to an x to demonstrate how he denies what he said to be a “slave” name. Charismatic and eloquent. His death in 1965 is what sparked and later laid the firm foundation for the Black Power movements in the late 1960s and 1970s. Opposite to popular belief, this man had done more harm than good in using violence against the white “devil”. It only proved those that though African Americans were only violent animals right. Even Martin Luther King Jr didn't like what how Malcolm X was going about gaining their civil rights , even going as far as saying he hated the use of the words “black power” because. Ultimately Malcolm didn't make any type of immensely big impact on the civil rights movement in a good way or help them stop the spread of racism and
The Plessy vs. Ferguson (1896) ‘equal but separate’ decision robbed it of its meaning and confirmed this wasn’t the case as the court indicated this ruling did not violate black citizenship and did not imply superior and inferior treatment ,but it indeed did as it openly permitted racial discrimination in a landmark decision of a 8-1 majority ruling, it being said was controversial, as white schools and facilities received near to more than double funding than black facilities negatively contradicted the movement previous efforts on equality and maintaining that oppression on
“I’m for the truth, no matter who tells it. I’m for justice, no matter who it is for or against. I’m a human being, first and foremost, and as such I’m for whoever and whatever benefits humanity as a whole” (X). This quote by Malcolm X represented his attitude towards equality and self-empowerment. The true Malcolm X was a passionate human rights activist as well as an extremely outspoken man during the fifties and sixties. X encouraged millions of African Americans to fight for what they believed in and to take pride in their ethnicity. X persuaded a multitude of African Americans that they are supreme and should not be degraded for their skin color. He learned at a very early age if he wanted something in life, he had to make some noise
Although the Fourteenth Amendment, when adopted in 1868, gave certain rights to blacks, including citizenship, equal protection of law and other freedoms, African-Americans were considered inferior by whites in this country. In 1896, Plessy v. Ferguson officially made segregation legal, and put “separate but equal” into effect. African-Americans were excluded from hotels, restaurants, theatres and schools. African-Americans had lower paying jobs than did whites. Accumulated frustration led blacks to call for dramatic social change. (Good, 8-10)
The history of the United States has in it much separation or segregation due to race. For a long time our country has seen racism as a large problem and this has caused ethnic groups to be looked down upon and forced into a lifestyle of difficulties and suppression. Due to this, races, particularly African-Americans, have been forced to deal with unequal opportunity and poverty, leading to less honorable ways of getting by and also organizations that support change. Malcolm X is one strong example of an African American man who became apart of a group acted against it, uniting people to promote the advancement of colored people and change. Malcolm's thoughts towards race and civil right in the previous years were displayed in a less way to the people and "by any means necessary" perspective. After his pilgrimage in 1964 his view of civil rights had quickly changed into a more complete view of civil rights, and the peoples views towards him. No one really knows what kind of impact Malcolm X would have had on history if he had not been assassinated. His beliefs and philosophy did gain him a place in history as one of the best-known Black Nationalist Leaders. Everyone seems to have known who Malcolm X was, and he ranks high with all other Black leaders. His ideas were radical and he was very out spoken. He was a major force in the development of black history. He fought not only for his people but also for all oppressed people everywhere. He was well spoken and he laid the groundwork for the black power movement of the late l960's.
the segregationists, resulting in the injury and deaths of many of King’s followers. With these points in mind, King came to the conclusion that the best strategy in gaining the rights of African American was the use of non-violent protest. He believed that violence only “intensifies evil,';
Toward the end of the Progressive Era American social inequality had stripped African Americans of their rights on a local and national level. In the 1896 Supreme Court case of Plessey vs. Ferguson, the Supreme Court sided with a Louisiana state law declaring segregation constitutional as long as facilities remain separate but equal. Segregation increased as legal discriminatory laws became enacted by each state but segregated facilities for whites were far superior to those provided for blacks; especially prevalent in the South were discriminatory laws known as Jim Crow laws which surged after the ruling. Such laws allowed for segregation in places such as restaurants, hospitals, parks, recreational areas, bathrooms, schools, transportation, housing, hotels, etc. Measures were taken to disenfranchise African Americans by using intimidation, violence, putting poll taxes, and literacy tests. This nearly eliminated the black vote and its political interests as 90% of the nine million blacks in America lived in the South and 1/3 were illiterate as shown in Ray Stannard Baker’s Following the Color Line (Bailey 667). For example, in Louisiana 130,334 black voters registered in 1896 but that number drastically decreased to a mere 1,342 in 1904—a 99 percent decline (Newman ). Other laws prevented black...
Martin Luther King is a famous Civil Rights activist who played a huge role in the desegregation in the United States. While confined in the Birmingham prison, he wrote a letter to his clergymen and describes and defends his plans of how to desegregate the black and white communities in harmony. A major part of his plan was to take nonviolent direct action as it was necessary. Martin Luther King wrote,
Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. had faith in his beliefs of equality, and that all people, regardless of race should be free and governed under the same laws. In the later part of the 1960's, Birmingham, Alabama, the home of King, was considered to be the most racially divided city in the South. "Birmingham is so segregated, we're within a cab ride of being in Johannesburg, South Africa", 1 when King said this he was only speaking half jokingly. In Birmingham the unwritten rule towards blacks was that "if the Klan doesn't stop you, the police will."2 When King decided that the time had come to end the racial hatred, or at least end the violence, he chose to fight in a non-traditional way. Rather than giving the white people the pleasure of participating in violent confrontations, King believed if they fought without violence for their rights, they would have a faster success rate. King also saw Birmingham as the major problem in America.
Throughout his education, Martin Luther King Jr. tried to find a way to demonstrate his belief of racial equality with the most effective means possible. He quickly realized that the best strategy to end segregation was to use nonviolent forms of protest. At Crozer, Morehouse and Boston University, he studied the teaching of Mohandas Gandhi, who used nonviolent methods to help India claim its independence from Britain. King read several books on the ideas of Gandhi, and eventually became convinced that his methods could be employed by African Americans to obtain equality in America. King knew that any violence on the part of African Americans would lead to violent responses from segregationists, which would lead to injury or maybe even death for his followers. He had to teach his followers not to respond violently to cruel attacks from segregationists. King decided to sponsor workshops to train African Americans in nonviolent beh...
Malcolm X was a freedom fighter like Dr. King who fought for the right and freedoms for black Americans. Unlike Malcolm, Dr. King called black Americans blacks while Malcolm called them Negros. Malcolm used violence in his fight for freedom when he said, “Revolution was based upon bloodshed”. Malcolm was ready for anything as far as blacks will gain the respect and freedom they needed. In Malcolm’s black revolution, he made it clear how blacks were treated differently no matter their age, what school they came out of, no matter what their intellectual or professional level was, they were still recognized as a boy and were not given the respect they deserved. He also pointed out how whites made them think they had different goals and objectives.