Robin Mather's Article: The Threats From Genetically Modified Food

1215 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Sustainability easy

Considering an argument as valid requires critical analysis of several aspects and providing strong evidence. Robin Mather, a journalist who “has passion for food and its sources, has worked at major metropolitan newspapers (the Detroit News, the Chicago Tribune)”(86), argues that GMOs have risks and hazards to human health and threats to wildlife and environment in her article “The Threats from Genetically Modified Foods”, whereas Entine, a colleague at the Genetic Literacy Project, and Wendel, a science writer(82), claim that GMOs are safe to eat and no harm to people or animals in their article “2000+Reasons Why GMOs are Safe to Eat and Environmentally Sustainable” Both articles’ authors state their ideas clearly for whether GMOs could be eaten or not. However, Mather provides more solid …show more content…

She provides some excellent examples to analyze logically and solid evidence to persuade readers to agree with her views, such as she begins with Roundup-Ready which could cause cancer and damage to DNA that would catch readers’ attention wondering how. Then follows the definition of GMOs and how they perform which may cause unpredictable harm and hazard to humans for the Bt crops can damage the ileum and kill beneficial insects, Roundup causes effects on environment and damage soil, GM milk raises the high level of risk of breast and prostate cancer, and GMOs can’t help to end hunger. All of those statements are proved by the solid evidence that Mather gives. Mather also gives the historical events to support her ideas effectively, and she ends of some suggestions about what consumers should do, such as GMOs labeling, growing own food, buying organic, etc. Clearly, Mather has a convincing argument by providing the solid evidence and logical analysis throughout her

Show More
Related

  • Genetically Modified Organisms and How They Have Changed Food in America

    1669 Words  | 4 Pages

    Food is an essential part of everyday life without it one could not survive. Every day we make choices on what we put in to our bodies. There are countless varieties of food to choose from to meet the diverse tastes of the increasing population. Almost all food requires a label explaining the ingredients and the nutritional value allowing consumers to make informed decisions on what they are consuming. However, many may not be considering where that food is coming from or how it has been produced. Unfortunately, there is more to food than meets the eye. Since 1992, “ the U.S. Food and Drug Administration ruled, based on woefully limited data, that genetically modified foods were ‘substantially equivalent’ to their non-GM counterparts” (Why to Support Labeling). GM food advocates have promised to create more nutritious food that will be able to grow in harsh climate conditions and eventually put an end to world hunger in anticipation of the growing population. There is very little evidence to support these claims and study after study has proven just the opposite. GM crops are not only unsafe to consume, but their growing practices are harmful to the environment, and multinational corporations are putting farmers out of business.

    Read More

  • Negative Essay: Devil's Advocate On GMO

    1015 Words  | 3 Pages

    Miller first mentions how in any study a lot of scientists use animals as a way to test out theories. In this case animals were given modified food and what they found was that the food was harming the animals; they were suffering. Considering what occurred to the animals, why should we even consider trusting a modified plant? “Genetically modified foods - also called genetically engineered foods – contain DNA that scientists have modified in an unnatural way, such as by adding a gene from a different organism, according to the world Health Organization” (Miller). In this aspect no one would be willing to purchase a product like this, there should be a reason to be scared of the word GMO. Some of the make up`s are good for our economy and the plants but they cannot or should not be classified as a GMO. Miller even points out “At the event, Druker, a public interest attorney, argued that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has misrepresented the safety of genetically modified foods and violated federal food safety law by allowing them onto the market.” That right there should answer anyone’s question about GMO`s not being proven to be safe, because not every make up is suitable for our

    Read More

  • Analysis Of How Dangerous Are GMO Food

    933 Words  | 2 Pages

    Genetically modified food is a significant issue that America is currently dealing with; it has affected millions around the world. Genetically modified food is crops, plants, and animals whose DNA has been altered for agricultural and nutritional reasons. In the Alltime Conspiracies video, “How Dangerous Are GMO Food” he argues that GMOs can have budding effect on humans, and the more we consume the more damage that is being done to our DNA cells. The author Alltime Conspiracy begins building his credibility with personal facts plus highly regarded sources, citing credible facts and statistics,

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay: Does Gmos Cause Cancer?

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    GMOs has been around for nearly 50 years. It is something that has emerged itself within our lifestyles and become something that appear in our daily lives, whether it’s on the shelf in grocery shops or on your plate right know; GMOs can be found almost anywhere. However, although the production of GMOs have certainly increased over the years, opinions on it has differed. Some people have come to believe it is dangerous for our health, while other people has stated the exact opposite. Something that

    Read More

  • The Controversy Over Genetically Modified Foods ( GMOs)

    2216 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Controversy Over Genetically Modified Foods The genetic engineering of foods has, in one sense, been in existence for hundreds of years. The first time Gregor Mendel bred different varieties of pea plants to observe the various traits present in their offspring, the concept was born. Today, genetic engineering has developed into one of the most complex and advanced fields of scientific thinking, all the while provoking many questions and acquiring many opponents along the way. While there are compelling arguments presented for each side of the issue, the simple fact is that genetically modified (GM) foods are a reality, especially in the United States, as they are already present in many products that are consumed on a daily basis.

    Read More

  • Gmo Persuasive Speech

    1022 Words  | 3 Pages

    How many of you hear the words “genetically modified food” and immediately think “BAD”? How many of you scorn the idea that genetically modified foods are useful? How many of you have been manipulated by the media to think that all biotechnology is evil? Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are organisms that have been genetically spliced to achieve a certain trait. As the demand for a larger food supply is increasing due to population growth, the benefits that GMO foods provide are being hailed as the only solution to the food crisis. However, many people are making inadequately informed decisions, and are pushing them to the back shelf. I will inform you on why genetically modified organisms may be the only way to a stable, safe future for the less fortunate.

    Read More

  • Genetically Modified Food (GMOs): Annotated Bibliography

    2902 Words  | 6 Pages

    Genetically modified food’s, or GMOs, goal is to feed the world's malnourished and undernourished population. Exploring the positive side to GMOs paints a wondrous picture for our planet’s future, although careful steps must be taken to ensure that destruction of our ecosystems do not occur. When GMOs were first introduced into the consumer market they claimed that they would help eliminate the world’s food crisis by providing plants that produced more and were resistant to elemental impacts like droughts and bacterial contaminants, however, production isn’t the only cause for the world’s food crisis. Which is a cause for concern because the population on the earth is growing and our land and ways of agriculture will not be enough to feed everyone sufficiently. No simple solutions can be found or applied when there are so many lives involved. Those who are hungry and those who are over fed, alike, have to consider the consequences of Genetically Modified Organisms. Food should not be treated like a commodity it is a human necessity on the most basic of levels. When egos, hidden agendas, and personal gains are folded into people's food sources no one wins. As in many things of life, there is no true right way or wrong way to handle either of the arguments and so many factors are involved that a ‘simple’ solution is simply not an option.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech Rhetorical Analysis

    1158 Words  | 3 Pages

    While critics may argue that GMOs actually hide dangerous deep-rooted detriments, there is no solid evidence to support this claim. As stated by the National Academies of Science, when “Scientists compared health trends in North America, where foods made from genetically engineered crops are common, with trends in Europe, where such foods are rare. They found no differences in patterns of cancer, obesity, diabetes, kidney disease, gastrointestinal problems, celiac disease, autism, or food allergies” (“Foods Made with” par 4). This objectively disproves the claim of adverse long-term effects, as, well, there were no differences between the data. The positive effects of GMOs far outweigh the negative effects, in both worldly and domestic aspects, proving why they should be available.

    Read More

  • Genetically Modified Organisms are Safe

    1945 Words  | 4 Pages

    In this day and age Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) have become a topic of large interest in the media. GMOs are defined as an organism whose genetic structure has been altered by incorporating a gene that will express a desirable trait (Dresbach et. al 2013). Often times these traits that are selected are either beneficial to the consumer or producer. Currently, GMOs are being created at a higher rate than ever before and are being used in the foods that we eat. This has created a large amount of debate on local, national, and international levels about the safety of genetically modified foods to human health. There are many angles that have been taken from different groups about this issue. Some believe it is harmful to our health with one source stating that, “mice eating GMO corn had fewer and smaller babies (Jagelio 2013).” Without testing on humans how are we to know these harmful effects aren’t impacting our health and reproduction. Other groups see GMOs as being both beneficial and having no impact on human health. These individuals site that , “Since GMOs were introduced into the food supply almost 20 years ago, there has not been one documented case of any health problem in humans, not even so much as a sniffle, linked to GMOs (Entine 2013).” They have also found GMOs to be beneficial to human health. Dresbach et. al(2013) found, “The biotechnology of gene splicing allows for the opportunity of creating plants that will produce food that is more nutrient dense.” With so many different views that all cite different information about GMO’s impact on human well-being, the question remains how GMOs affect human health?

    Read More

  • The Benefits and Risks of Genetically Modified Foods

    862 Words  | 2 Pages

    This report explains genetically modified food (GMOs) and discusses the benefits and risks associated with the consumptions of GMOs. Genetically modified foods (GMOs) are foods that have been genetically altered using engineering techniques. The most common technique used today is called recombinant DNA technology; this technology combines different molecules from different plant species to create a plant with a new set of genes, a hybrid plant. Another recombinant DNA technology being used is recombinant bovine somatotropin (rBST) an artificial growth hormone; this hormone is being fed or injected into cows to improve milk production. (ThefreeDictionary)

    Read More

  • Genetically Modified Food are Pandora´s Box to Humans and the Environment

    536 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Genetically modified foods are a "Pandora's box" of known and unknown risks to humans and the environment. They have been forced onto the American public by multinational biotech and agribusiness corporations without adequate oversight and regulation by the United States government (Driscoll, SallyMorley, David C).”Genetically Modified Food is food which has been chemically altered by scientists during the production process to give the food more nutrients, better appearance, and a longer shelf-life (Rich, Alex K.Warhol, Tom). The importance of this issue is that these GMO’s can actually have a negative effect in our society in general. It could mutate in a negative way and cause cancer or other diseases. Genetically modified food should be strictly controlled due to its various detrimental effects on the environment, human health, and potentially insect/animal effects.

    Read More

  • The Ethics of Genetically Modified Food Production

    4155 Words  | 9 Pages

    As human technological innovation proceeds into the twenty-first century, society is faced with many complex issues. Genetic engineering and cloning, encryption and information security, and advanced weapons technologies are all prominent examples of technological issues that have substantial moral and ethical implications. Genetic engineering in particular is currently a very volatile subject. One important aspect of this field is GMO or Genetically Modified Organisms, which has far-reaching potential to revolutionize modern agriculture. GMO crops are already being developed by many leading biotech companies, and have come under intense scrutiny by society. This is easily understood, however, because there is not much that is more important than how people get fed. Specifically, where their food comes from, and how it is produced. Thus, it is essential that we examine the ethical dilemmas as well as the practical benefits posed by such a powerful technology.

    Read More

  • Gmo Persuasive Speech

    631 Words  | 2 Pages

    Specific Purpose: To persuade the audience Introduction I. Attention Getter: GM technology has been around for the past 20 years, and today, 70-80% of the foods we eat in the United States, both at home and away from home, contain ingredients that have been genetically modified. II. Speaker Credibility: After finding out that GMO exist everywhere I conducted extensive research into the topic and tried to find out the important things I found. III.

    Read More

  • TED Talk: Genetically Modified Food

    340 Words  | 1 Pages

    The TED talk about the genetically modified food really stuck me. The TED talk was about all the modifications being made to crop to protect them from disease and other problems. I believe this would be relating to agriculture and scientific engineering. The speaker mention that people have a preconceived idea that GMOs are bad for you, but she went on to explain all the good they have done. For example, saved all of Hawaii’s papayas because they engineered the papayas to be resistant to the disease. She also talked about how they’ve created ‘golden rice’ that is rich is vitamin A and could stop children in third world countries from dying, if they had one bowl a day. She said that GMOs are good for our planet and that they have seen no negative

    Read More

  • Genetically Modified Foods Debate Summary

    1374 Words  | 3 Pages

    Lallanilla specifically points out the the safety, politics and the overall uses of GM foods around the world. Her argument is that genetic modification of food can both be helpful and harmful to the world. She does this by providing facts to show what genetic modification can do to many types of foods. Lallanilla’s article is not biased because she shows both sides of the argument by providing examples of the negative and positive effects of GM foods. Lallanilla does not have a specific side on the argument but instead clearly shows both sides of the argument to the reader and leaves out nothing to avoid being biased.

    Read More

More about Robin Mather's Article: The Threats From Genetically Modified Food

Open Document