Road Not Taken Criticism

1474 Words3 Pages

Robert Frost’s “The Road Not Taken” has influenced the hearts and minds of people over America since the 1900’s and has achieved the honor to be inducted into America’s literary standard. Robert Frost, one of America’s greatest poets of all time, composed this piece of literary perfection in 1916. “The Road Not Taken” stumps a man with the decision to choose a path as he encounters a fork in the road. The man in the poem says, “Two roads diverged in a wood, and I— I took the one less traveled by, and that has made all the difference”. Unfortunately, The man does not know at that moment the path he chose was the correct one; all he says is that his decision made a momentous impact on his life. For decades, various literary critics have analyzed this piece of writing trying to uncover its true meaning. Many scholars have found this piece to be a truly inspirational work while others have pictured it nothing more than an ironic tale of right and wrong. Alexander Meiklejohn is one scholar who used Robert Frost’s poem to teach others about making the right choices. Katherine Kearns, on the other hand, feels that the poem does not live up to its popularity. The viewpoints and criticisms regarding this unique piece of literature stretch far and wide, proving that Robert Frost’s poem has intrigued readers for decades. A large volume of criticisms have emerged that offer new perspectives for readers to explore as they continue to read “The Road Not Taken” for decades to come.

Robert Faggen is a professor of literature and acclaimed American literary critic. Robert Faggen criticizes Frost’s poem as being an ironic interpretation of the choices one makes in life and the lost possibilities of the choices no...

... middle of paper ...

...terpretations of the story will vary. Robert Faggen takes this criticism a step further and relates the poem to Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution and how species evolved by making difficult choices through their existence. Karen Kearns represents those critics who do not feel strongly about Robert Frost’s poem. Though many critics can agree Robert Frost’s poem illustrates various levels of irony; Kearns finds it ironic that “The Road not Taken”, a mediocre poem at best, is being regarded as one of the most popular poems in the American literary canon. The criticisms for this poem will never end as long as people continue to make difficult choices in their lives. After reading the “The Road not Taken,” one can form their own criticisms about what path is right for them; whether it means taking the road bent in the undergrowth or embarking on the road not taken.

Open Document