Rhetorical Analysis Of Fredrick Douglass '

1048 Words3 Pages

In the excerpt from Fredrick Douglass, “What a Black man wants” We see a very motivated, Educated, Comedic, and humble black man speaking out against the discriminatory laws against all black men. While reading the excerpt, we find that a General Banks has instituted a new policy which brings Mr. Douglass to argue said policy. Does this make Douglass a radical for his time? Throughout his presentation, he speaks on many things such as the comparisons between The Nation and the Anglo Saxons, and the state of black citizens in time of war and peace. General banks had instituted a policy in Louisiana that was discriminatory of blacks, claiming that it was to help prepare them to better handle freedom. How could a policy discriminating blacks …show more content…

Douglass states, “What doth it profit a man if he gain the whole world, and loses his own soul? It may be said, also, What doth it profit a nation to gain the whole world, and lose its honor?” stating that America loses their honor when they call upon their citizens in time of war but once war has been won and America is in a time of peace they alienate those same citizens and make them slaves and discriminate against them again, which leads Douglass to ask this question, “Shall we be citizens in war, and aliens in peace? Would that be just?” Absolutely not! Douglass states that the negro has been a citizen three times and each time in a time of war. Never in a time of peace and that’s so true. In 1776 when America gained their independence The Constitution stated that all men were created equal and rightly so. In Americas time of need nobody discriminated on who they were fighting alongside but rather welcomed the brother to arms. Once the war was over the African Americans went back to the plantations and to slavery. What did American constitution have to say then? They acted as though the same man who gave his life for his country those three separate times was not worthy to be a citizen afterwards due to the color of their skin. Well the right to bear arms and fight for his country grants you the right to suffrage, which was Fredrick Douglass’s

Open Document